Good observations and understanding of the problem.
Modi's statement will be used by China in future discussion about ditermination of LAC. China will now insist that their position as on 30 Apr 20 has been accepted as LAC.
But is there anything wrong in that ? As per our (MEA's ) perceptions that indeed is LAC,
In so far as the future boundary question is concerned, article six of BPTA says that the question of determination of LAC will not prejudice determination of boundary in future.
That way it is a safe position.
I will try to reduce confusion by giving an example. Let's say India claims from 0->100 on the graph for border but we have only claim till 0->75 for LAC. China likewise claims 100->0 for border and 100->25 for LAC. In this case... when they try to define LAC.. both will finally settle at 50 based on mutually accepted solution.
Now since modi said there is no incursion.. Indian LAC claim came down from 0-75 to 0-50. China hasn't done so.. so Chinese claim is still 100-25 for LAC. Mutually acceptable solution is somewhere around 37 on the graph instead of 50.
When the border settlement time comes.. nobody will say let's go back and start from the scratch even though they can. Our negotiation starts from +37 points and their negotiation starts from +63 points. not from 50/50. So whatever is beneficial.. China will take that. When we give away anything we have to account for weak PM scenarios as well. Chinese suffer from small d**k syndrome which is visible in their negotiations. After sometime.. people who negotiated will die off and only the documents will remain and at best interpretations of what might have happened.
About your last question - Rahul and Sonia , Congress stooges have no right to ask about how much territory lost? With what face do they ask such questions? The country of course has the right to ask any thing from their PM. But here again why is any one ask Modi only? Why did they not ask MMS, Sonia and Antony... That makes their sincerity questionable .
I don't know what this is. I am totally lost. I was being sarcastic there when asked where everyone is before.
Everyone including Rahul, Sonia and Congressis have a right to ask. Just like Modi had the right to ask when in opposition. Before we saw khangressi chamchas in UPA1/2 regime and now we are seeing Modi chamchas in UPA-3/4 regimes trying to silence opposition saying nasty things.. Then we are called religious fanatics by congress supporters and now we are called trolls and congressis by Modi supporters. But nobody called us desh bhakts. We asked questions to them too.. not just Modi. And we rooted and fought for Modi (including yours truly) when most of the people are Rahul supporters.
I request everyone to judge a post by it's merit and not by who posted it or who they support or oppose for every single post. And please stop calling troll on everyone who disagree with your opinion (not directed to you specifically).
