India China LAC & International Border Discussions

[ARVION]

No road between f4-f8 was build by chinese after 1999. And we still patrolled it as claimed by some ex army men .
But what was the last patrol in 2005 or 13 or just few months ago. We need answer to that.

See my previous texts it is not first time we lost human lives chini had previously murdered our 33 brave hearted warriors in cold brutally manner in 1962. Let us show them it is not 1962.

 

[COLDHEARTED AVIATOR]

Let them stay, let's see how there bodies can handle the Himalayan weather in upcoming months. They won't be able to take piss. Ouch!

Whatever they can do, they can do at this present conditions only.

i was talking about indian soldiers not retreating.

 

[Tanmay]

He spoke simple to assure the masses . It's tiny minority of so called experts who seem butthurt.

PM has to face politics too. Most Indian don't even know what aksai chin is or what lac is.
Congress is trying to fool everyone that kargil has repeated.

What should PM do then? Explain everyone what is IB , lac , what are Perceptions and claim lines.??
How many people will understand that.??

I have trying the same for English educated idiots here and most are still clueless including some senior members.

Modi did what he had to do.

Yes Sir agree with you. Domestic politics plays important role in shaping foreign policy. I dont want him to explain entire geography, but just use the exact phrase (territory vs area inside LoAC )


My intention was simple. Just like the corona and GST mess where babus/ministers give a statement and then follow up with multiple clarification,the babus did it again now. The speech should have been unambiguous to the the point.

No point of mischiveous interpretation should ever be there. Else we have Siachen like problem

The genesis of the Siachen dispute lies in the 1949 Karachi Agreement. Signed to end the 1947-48 Indo-Pakistan war over Kashmir, it had clearly demarcated the Ceasefire Line (CFL) in Kashmir up to map coordinate NJ-9842 — but mentioned, indistinctly, that the CFL ran “… thence north to the glaciers.” After the 1972 Indo-Pak War, the CFL was converted into the Line of Control (LoC) — but the ambiguity on the boundary beyond NJ-9842 continued. India is of the view that “thence north to the glaciers” correctly implies “to Siachen”, which is due north of NJ-9842.

Else this clarification was never needed if the earlier statement was clear and ambiguous.

 

[fire starter]

 

[TheMayank]

Here's a 'clarification'.

He messed up in his speech and this is now being clarified.

 

[Waanar]

I feel like amassing troops at the LAC is to deter the Chinese and eliminate the threat at LOC once and for all. What are our capabilities in winter on both fronts, LAC and LOC?

Is a speedy, heavy mobilization against Pakistan possible in winter?

Also, could China effectively intervene in winter to save it's slave nation?

 

[mokoman]

Indo China war in 1962 was fought in Sept Oct window. I think future clashes will occur in this time frame as well.

their attack coincided exactly with the Cuban missile crisis .

I think they will hit us when the monsoon reaches Himachal Pradesh , uttarakhand , arunachal pradesh areas .

this will be next week to before september

Like another poster from Himachal said , there will be land slides , roads will be washed out , long line of army conveys stopped . The monsoon rain will hit there next week .

 

[hit&run]

some more info about swap.
View attachment 50724

This must be fake because it is printed in Hindi. We only accept utterances of English speaking Brown gora sahIb as authentic.

 

[IndianHawk]

Yes Sir agree with you. Domestic politics plays important role in shaping foreign policy. I dont want him to explain entire geography, but just use the exact phrase (territory vs area inside LoAC )


My intention was simple. Just like the corona and GST mess where babus/ministers give a statement and then follow up with multiple clarifiation, babus did it again. The speech should have been unambiguous to the the point

Else this clarification was never needed if the earlier statement was clear and ambiguous.

This is the game. Masses in rural India or small towns Don't care about these things. They heard what PM said .

Clarification is now issued for experts / elites.

So both bases are secured.

If PM would fall in Congress trap. It would be kargill kargil all over the media and no amount of clarification would reach common people.

Modi has played it well as much as some of us don't like the way he played it.

 

[scatterStorm]

By the time the Sino-Indian War started on 20 October 1962, the Indian post had been reinforced by a company of troops. The Chinese PLA bombarded the Indian post with heavy shelling and employed a battalion to attack it. The Indian garrison suffered 33 killed and several wounded, while the company commander and several others were taken prisoner, By the end of the war, China reached its 1960 claim line

Question, did the first shot came from them or us? I suspect from them, right? Arty is the first thing we will hear going up.

 

[COLDHEARTED AVIATOR]

As reported by me again and again ... now small inputs coming in Swap did happen

#LAC #GalwanValleyFaceOff

But no official confirmation

 

[WARREN SS]

He messed up in his speech and this is now being clarified.

No He was not People With agenda Driven Ideology Is Just Purposely Misinformed

 

[Lancer]

Clarification on PM's statement from All Party Meet (APM) - espc. see the screenshot attached. Should clear things for those who were losing their shit about Aksai Chin and other occupied territories being "given up."

BREAKING: Statement from
@PMOIndia
to clarify yesterday's statement:

 

[Gandaberunda]

As the chinese reached the 1960 line claimed by them only in 1962 in galwan valley, so I presume after that we effectively lost control till finger 8

This shows exact claim lines over the years...

 

[IndianHawk]

Incident Are Goes Long Back Of Brawl
And Without AFV Its impossible

Then where are all those claims of patrolling till f8 coming from? Also Congressi propaganda.

 

[ARVION]

Question, did the first shot came from them or us? I suspect from them, right? Arty is the first thing we will hear going up.

Yes they shot first as they previously tried to harsh or capture the post since 1960, but only succeeded completely during the wars thanks due to their RT support

 

[TheMayank]

Statement to clarify statement

 

[cereal killer]

their attack coincided exactly with the Cuban missile crisis .

I think they will hit us when the monsoon reaches Himachal Pradesh , uttarakhand , arunachal pradesh areas .

this will be next week to before september

Like another poster from Himachal said , there will be land slides , roads will be washed out , long line of army conveys stopped . The monsoon rain will hit there next week .

That's why Modi said we will reply at the time & Place of our choosing. My biggest worry is Corona, it is expected to be at its peak during that time frame. Believe it or not China has notorious plans we have to pre empt even if we look like aggresors. Use this month to gain world sympathy & get some weaponary stock piled.

 

[scatterStorm]

i was talking about indian soldiers not retreating.

Its alright, I was talking about PLA troops ain't also retreating this time. They are there to stay. At least until December.

 

[ARVION]

Then where are all those claims of patrolling till f8 coming from? Also Congressi propaganda.

If I remember properly after the war they PLAGF dismantled the post of the Indian army it had captured during the war and basically it was no man's land as I was told by my grandfather.