India-China Border conflict

[Kumaoni]

I thought you were reading the book ? Anyway I mentioned it in my summary.

Yeah, but I missed the part in which they were captured. Maybe it missed my eyesight.

Link to your summary please?

 

[mist_consecutive]

Yeah, but I missed the part in which they were captured. Maybe it missed my eyesight.

Link to your summary please?

Look back few pages you lazy sod

 

[Kumaoni]

i agree with him，even i don't like him.

View attachment 169167

One question to you:

If Party A captured 20+ officers & soldiers of Party B. Party A released those pics and vidoes. Party A hold all the disputed areas.

Is Party A totally crashed Party B，made party B even didn't have any survived pics and vids; or Party B won?

What's ur opinion?

Shitgress agent detected, opinion rejected

 

[Kumaoni]

Look back few pages you lazy sod

Need page number. y

 

[mokoman]

I repeated again and again in this forum, China didn't want full scale war. Humiliate IA is not our strategic aim, the tactic aim was holding the disputed area in GALWAN, they did.

they didnt , actual chinese line is now inside buffer zone , chinese got pushed 1/2 km , away from pp14 .

place in galwan valley where PLA wrote 'never give up inch of land' is .5km from actual line . they pretty much pulled back the claim line by doing this.

entire galwan valley is a death trap for PLA . a 10 km long narrow valley with no room to manoeuvre . they almost triggered a war over nothing .

 

[Neil]

Caught on camera, Chinese construction work in Arunachal Pradesh

Locals of Anjaw district in Arunachal Pradesh have recorded videos showing Chinese machinery engaging in construction in areas near the LAC.

 

[Kumaoni]

i agree with him，even i don't like him.

View attachment 169167

One question to you:

If Party A captured 20+ officers & soldiers of Party B. Party A released those pics and vidoes. Party A hold all the disputed areas.

Is Party A totally crashed Party B，made party B even didn't have any survived pics and vids; or Party B won?

What's ur opinion?

Didn't release casualties but released pictures. HAHA

 

[rockdog]

So basically 1200 fully equipped PLA multiple units vs 400+ Indian soldiers.

More Chinese casualities.

Didn’t pick their dead bodies for 12 hours. (This information came at the very start but didn’t get much traction)

Chinese hostility on ground when their sissy diplomats talked peace.

India Army acted professionally and sticked not to escalate.

Our medic who was forced to give them first aid, later killed in cold blood because he would have revealed exact numbers of their dead.

Whole nation, one of P5s goes mum and grew no balls for months to name its martyrs with silly excuses. Then releases select photographs of Indian contingent that invade deep into their side and only stopped fighting when the battle settled after Chinese retreated at the front in panic after knowing many of its troops are unaccounted.

At the end just imagine the unprofessionalism and panic of PLA (I call militia) that acted like a medieval force who charges enemy cluster by trampling its own tired troops who are getting defeated and retreating.

Well done PLA.

*Weibo info on 2020.06.17, 2020.06.20

5 & 7 days after Galwan conflict, there were news on Weibo, said PLA captured aruond 50 POWs. It's quite accurate with the images & videos released one year later.

If you count the No. of POWs from the pics and Videos, there are 47 POWs, plus the the rest of them, let's say there are 50 POWs totally. Plus 20 dead, 60 injuries but returned to Indian side, there are around 130 losses.

If there were 400+ Indian tropps, which means 30% rate of your troop damage, for common sense of military logic, your combat unit lost attack capablities, let alone to win any battle.

If you again check those images & videos, most of them could walk by PLA's help, which means few of them were badly injured. It seems they didn't had tough fight during the night, they gave up the resistence and surrenderred in combat. Otherwise, the so called "1000" PLAs will make them very hard to be alive.

I hate to debate who beat who by strong words , i just use the current evidence to make analysis. Simplely speaking, in Galwan night, battalion level of Indian troop were collpased and no one had chance to save any "victory image & videos".

 

[Kumaoni]

View attachment 169249


View attachment 169251


*Weibo info on 2020.06.17, 2020.06.20

5 & 7 days after Galwan conflict, there were news on Weibo, said PLA captured aruond 50 POWs. It's quite accurate with the images & videos released one year later.

If you count the No. of POWs from the pics and Videos, there are 47 POWs, plus the the rest of them, let's say there are 50 POWs totally. Plus 20 dead, 60 injuries but returned to Indian side, there are around 130 losses.

If there were 400+ Indian tropps, which means 30% rate of your troop damage, for common sense of military logic, your combat unit lost attack capablities, let alone to win any battle.

If you again check those images & videos, most of them could walk by PLA's help, which means few of them were badly injured. It seems they didn't had tough fight during the night, they gave up the resistence and surrenderred in combat. Otherwise, the so called "1000" PLAs will make them very hard to be alive.

I hate to debate who beat who by strong words , i just use the current evidence to make analysis. Simplely speaking, in Galwan night, battalion level of Indian troop were collpased and no one had chance to save any "victory image & videos".

Prove to me those were genuine Indian POWs and not actors. Prove to me they weren’t unarmed. Identify their units and rank.

 

[jai jaganath]

Prove to me those were genuine Indian POWs and not actors. Prove to me they weren’t unarmed. Identify their units and rank.

So u believe that those pics of our pow were made by actors

 

[Kumaoni]

So u believe that those pics of our pow were made by actors

What is the context behind it? It could’ve been a rescue mission by the PLA. Those pictures of the 70+ “POWs” was first released in May of 2020, in the Galwan area.

 

[rockdog]

So u believe that those pics of our pow were made by actors

U mean like this?

 

[Jimih]

It seems that MODS are taking a day off and letting Weibo propaganda flowing here in this thread uninterrupted.

 

[Kumaoni]

It seems that MODS are taking a day off and letting Weibo propaganda flowing here in this thread uninterrupted.

No, don’t ban this one. I want to troll his ass hard.

 

[jai jaganath]

U mean like this?

View attachment 169257

I didn't even tag u
I was asking him whether he thinks that the pics of our pow were scripted bcoz I don't believe so

 

[jai jaganath]

You mean like this?View attachment 169258

Is pic ka koi sense banta hai bhai

 

[jai jaganath]

It seems that MODS are taking a day off and letting Weibo propaganda flowing here in this thread uninterrupted.

We must have few Chinese members atleast him as he provides few good things regarding this conflict which gives us a better idea about their public thinking and narrative of both sides

 

[Jimih]

We must have few Chinese members atleast him as he provides few good things regarding this conflict which gives us a better idea about their public thinking and narrative of both sides

You completely have no idea.

 

[Kumaoni]

U mean like this?

View attachment 169257

 

[mist_consecutive]

At least they have decent helmets & Sig 716