Indian Navy Developments & Discussions

binayak95

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2011
Messages
2,526
Likes
8,790
Country flag
Sa'ar 6 :
Displacement: 1,900 long tons (and weapons coming out of the wazoo)
Range: 4,000 nmi

Nilgiri :
Displacement: 6,560 long tons
Range: 5,500 nmi

Need I say any more??
No storms to face, no monstrous monsoon waves, just the placid waters off the Israeli coast.

No flagship facility, no scope of upgradation, no power and space overheads.

And Brahmos VLS is a monster that occupies a shit load of tonnage.
 

binayak95

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2011
Messages
2,526
Likes
8,790
Country flag
After observing this phenomena for far too long & giving this much thought , let me confess I'm not convinced of the figures in terms of the armaments put forth by the IN .

Not only are we hiding information , we're also creating a lot of floor space for future upgradation like for instance our Destroyers will be armed not just with the XR range of SAMs but also the AD-1/AD-2 series.
Thats a given.
Take it for granted that IN ships are hiding stuff.
 

Adm Kenobi

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2021
Messages
207
Likes
1,290
Country flag
No storms to face, no monstrous monsoon waves, just the placid waters off the Israeli coast.

No flagship facility, no scope of upgradation, no power and space overheads.

And Brahmos VLS is a monster that occupies a shit load of tonnage.
No redundancy, negligible repair capacity, and few days at sea.

Not to mention that it has fewer missiles in reality than mentioned on the Wiki page.
16 Barack-MX cells (not 32)
8 Gabriel 5 canisters (not 16)
4000km (not nmi)

It's a corvette, nothing more.
saar6.jpeg
 

Fatalis

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2022
Messages
1,440
Likes
9,875
Country flag
No redundancy, negligible repair capacity, and few days at sea.

Not to mention that it has fewer missiles in reality than mentioned on the Wiki page.
16 Barack-MX cells (not 32)
8 Gabriel 5 canisters (not 16)
4000km (not nmi)

It's a corvette, nothing more.
View attachment 259265
Along with 40 C-Dome systems. Pretty impressive for a corvette.
 

blackleaf

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2021
Messages
295
Likes
1,037
Country flag
No storms to face, no monstrous monsoon waves, just the placid waters off the Israeli coast.

No flagship facility, no scope of upgradation, no power and space overheads.

And Brahmos VLS is a monster that occupies a shit load of tonnage.
Is the Brahmos really worth the size and weight? The IN could instead carry 16 of the stealthy Naval Strike Missile (NSM) for much less weight like some Western Navies.
The weight and space savings should be enough to have a 48 cell VLS for air defence instead of the 32 cell currently used.
 

Smoothbore125mm

Regular Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2024
Messages
879
Likes
2,408
Country flag
Is the Brahmos really worth the size and weight? The IN could instead carry 16 of the stealthy Naval Strike Missile (NSM) for much less weight like some Western Navies.
The weight and space savings should be enough to have a 48 cell VLS for air defence instead of the 32 cell currently used.
Yes it is very very lethal purely quality over quantity
 

Lonewolf

Psychopathic Neighbour
Senior Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Messages
7,365
Likes
27,771
Country flag
Is the Brahmos really worth the size and weight? The IN could instead carry 16 of the stealthy Naval Strike Missile (NSM) for much less weight like some Western Navies.
The weight and space savings should be enough to have a 48 cell VLS for air defence instead of the 32 cell currently used.
Western navel forces in worst scenario will face some terrorist in Mediterranean or red sea area, not the same for Indian Navy, we will face atleast two wars in next 50 years
 

blackleaf

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2021
Messages
295
Likes
1,037
Country flag
Western navel forces in worst scenario will face some terrorist in Mediterranean or red sea area, not the same for Indian Navy, we will face at least two wars in next 50 years
The bigger Western Navies are setup to face the Russians and the Chinese.

For the Indian Navy, Pakistan should not be too difficult to handle. However, I worry about China with their 96+ cell destroyers/cruisers.
 

Lonewolf

Psychopathic Neighbour
Senior Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Messages
7,365
Likes
27,771
Country flag
The bigger Western Navies are setup to face the Russians and the Chinese.
There won't be any war in European context except for Americans, rest all are just keeping the tech alive and for show of strength.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top