Indian Special Forces

jai jaganath

New Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2022
Messages
5,975
Likes
10,474
Country flag
Who needs any kind of personal protective gear when you're wearing the tactical gamcha. Our boys are way better than Bisleri drinking westerners and will take on any kind of problems with hand to hand combat with the added armour protection of the tactical gamcha.
Jo bhi ho bhai
They are atleast bit serious about opsec and blurred the identities unlike para sf
 

AnantS

New Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,890
Likes
15,774
Country flag
New age jobs and career options and unattractive salaries have degraded the officer class of the Indian Army.
Army perks are still great compared to private sector. Makes me remember an incident long long time back where a very bright chap from premium PSU resigns for pvt sector because he was getting "only" 5 lakh per annum as package(along with Govt House, Vehicle, subsidised school etc) in PSU and joins a private firm which 6.7 lakh package. He join very happily seeing great office decors and bling. That happiness lasted till he got his first paycheck - which was less than what he got in PSU. He goes to fight with HR and came back sulkingly. He realised that approx 2 lakh from his package were just value of "Benefits" he could accrue like insurance, PF Employer contribution, "Meal cards" etc :D And now he had to live in the real metropolitan city in that salary paying full rent, school and transportation cost.
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
Not sure if it's SF or not but boy are we behind
It’s not even funny anymore


And some idiots actually agitated against the agnipath scheme (including some veterans)
PLA is modernising rapidly because on top of the additional spending power China has over india anyway they explicitly decided to cut their manpower by 30-40% ~5 years ago. The kind of spending advantage (CAPEX) they must have over the IA has got to be 10-15X
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
Should the premier special forces team of the Air Force be pushing about people in a wheelchair?
I said before, they were acting more as ground crew for aircraft Ops than combatants. What’s even the point in having ‘SF’ if this is what they are for?
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
Army perks are still great compared to private sector. Makes me remember an incident long long time back where a very bright chap from premium PSU resigns for pvt sector because he was getting "only" 5 lakh per annum as package(along with Govt House, Vehicle, subsidised school etc) in PSU and joins a private firm which 6.7 lakh package. He join very happily seeing great office decors and bling. That happiness lasted till he got his first paycheck - which was less than what he got in PSU. He goes to fight with HR and came back sulkingly. He realised that approx 2 lakh from his package were just value of "Benefits" he could accrue like insurance, PF Employer contribution, "Meal cards" etc :D And now he had to live in the real metropolitan city in that salary paying full rent, school and transportation cost.
Yeah this free ride isn’t going to exist in 10 years, the PSUs that do exist then will be corporatised and have to respond to market forces
 

AnantS

New Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,890
Likes
15,774
Country flag
Even OFBs have gone through that process (or are starting to)

corporatised =/= privatised But the kind of fat deals that defined the public sector for so long will fall away in the medium term, that golden period(for them) is long gone
not even ofb :)
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
not even ofb :)
Read the room buddy, the direction is only one way

The days of propping up failing entities is long gone, the vestiges will linger for a bit but the peak is long since gone

it seems MoD/PMO/DMA has woken up after Galwan and see the existential threat right at the gates. Failing DPSUs and a bloated army unable to even fund boots and uniforms regularly is not just a matter of angst for defence fanboys but a national security threat.

Consistently the armed forces have been leaned since 2020, equipment harmonised, logistics prioritised and CAPEX bolstered (+ emergency funding)

Sadly Rawat departed at a time when much of the big steps were still being spun up but I guess over the next 4-6 years they’ll be rolled out now.

plenty of cribbing from PSU workers and veterans incoming but their moment has gone too, the wheels have already been turning for some time
 

Spindrift

New Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
2,745
Likes
8,978
Read the room buddy, the direction is only one way

The days of propping up failing entities is long gone, the vestiges will linger for a bit but the peak is long since gone

it seems MoD/PMO/DMA has woken up after Galwan and see the existential threat right at the gates. Failing DPSUs and a bloated army unable to even fund boots and uniforms regularly is not just a matter of angst for defence fanboys but a national security threat.

Consistently the armed forces have been leaned since 2020, equipment harmonised, logistics prioritised and CAPEX bolstered (+ emergency funding)

Sadly Rawat departed at a time when much of the big steps were still being spun up but I guess over the next 4-6 years they’ll be rolled out now.

plenty of cribbing from PSU workers and veterans incoming but their moment has gone too, the wheels have already been turning for some time
There is a lot of prime land in the hands of the civilians in cantonments with a lot of restrictions on constructions. I mean you have to follow the regulations and you can't play around with them. I guess some of BJPs friends are looking to monetize that and this is not good due to security concerns, for example if the land comes into civilian administration and someone builds a high rise that over looks the Army area, that can used for recon and launching a rocket or a sniper attack.
More over the cantonment boards have been managing the civilian areas just fine
 

kaboom

New Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2022
Messages
1,426
Likes
5,639
Country flag
Marcos with PCR152 (ig) and a manpack radio .
This combination is generally seen with combat air controllers but both are generally carried by the same person........ (Marcos may have such capabilities Afterall)........

WhatsApp Image 2023-05-02 at 10.19.27.jpeg
 

AnantS

New Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,890
Likes
15,774
Country flag
Read the room buddy, the direction is only one way

The days of propping up failing entities is long gone, the vestiges will linger for a bit but the peak is long since gone

it seems MoD/PMO/DMA has woken up after Galwan and see the existential threat right at the gates. Failing DPSUs and a bloated army unable to even fund boots and uniforms regularly is not just a matter of angst for defence fanboys but a national security threat.

Consistently the armed forces have been leaned since 2020, equipment harmonised, logistics prioritised and CAPEX bolstered (+ emergency funding)

Sadly Rawat departed at a time when much of the big steps were still being spun up but I guess over the next 4-6 years they’ll be rolled out now.

plenty of cribbing from PSU workers and veterans incoming but their moment has gone too, the wheels have already been turning for some time
Mate even in great US of A , those kind of entities(which I am referring to) have not been corporatized. They might have competitors in private sector. But its one area where as of now and in near future no Govt wants to relinquish its control. I shall refrain from further saying anything on this.

The move that you referred to is simply various Govts that have been eyeing that sweet well maintained cantonment areas in otherwise messy civic centres around them for so long. Most Cantts were way outside population centres. But with unplanned rapid growth some town and cities have grown beyond where cantt used to lie. Cants because of their upkeep and relatively planned layout, - can become really hot properties - this is something real estate sharks know. And all politicians want piece of actions on same.

All the talks of Galwan and knowing that defence budget is inadequate is leading to this decision is BS. Defence Capex deficit is recurring problem. To solve the issue one needs to generate means of sustained funding. One time real estate sales are no way to get you sustained funding. Even if Govt reaps windfall on fire sale, believe all money reaped from it will all go in some vote garnering social schemes.

If Govt was really serious about funding from utilizing real estate. The way would have been to allow military to lease those assets. And in turn whatever revenue they get from leasing - its sent into defence kitty.
 
Last edited:

Articles

Top