DRDO, PSU and Private Defence Sector News

Gessler

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,312
Likes
11,249
Country flag
My take on SMART:

In all likelihood this is an indication of the presence of passive sensors such as seabed hydrophone arrays (i.e. SOSUS) which can detect presence of surface or subsurface targets over a wide frontage (SOSUS arrays can span thousands of kms).

Once a threat has been localized (at this stage it may or may not be positively identified, which introduces complexity into the mix), a ballistic missile like SMART can deploy a torpedo in the region at only a fraction of the time it would take a MPA like P-8 to arrive in the location, let alone the much slower shipborne helos.

If SMART is anything like Shaurya, it should be able to attain hypersonic velocity inside the atmosphere (above Mach 7) for most of the trajectory. Time is everything for a submarine interception, and SMART can address a big part of that problem.

Another possible advantage is that it would afford a standoff option to deploy ASW weapons into an area where you lack air dominance (like inside the A2/AD influence of a hostile Surface task force, with a submarine escorting it underwater). It wouldn't be possible to safely penetrate that airspace with P-8s or helos...and as long as the enemy surface ship's A2/AD is up, the enemy subsurface element is free of air threats in that region. SMART can fix that.
 

IndianHawk

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2016
Messages
9,058
Likes
37,675
Country flag
Why we need rustom when we will have CATS ?
I am curious , can anybody tell me what's the difference between the two ?:scared1::scared1:
Both look UAVs to the noob in me.
Rustom is long endurance. Which is necessary for large area surveillance and also can loiter for long time to pick up hidden targets like submarines , enemy convoys etc.

While cats hunter will be fast short ranged attack machines.
 

Super Flanker

Aviation and Defence Enthusiast
Senior Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2021
Messages
5,104
Likes
12,242
Country flag
Why we need rustom when we will have CATS ?
I am curious , can anybody tell me what's the difference between the two ?:scared1::scared1:
Both look UAVs to the noob in me.
That's because both are UAVs but both have different Roles to do. One is a UAV(Rustom in this case) and the other will be a UCAV(in this case cats)

Rustom is a Medium Altitude Long Endurance unmanned air vehicle and its role will be Surveillance mostly, basically its role will be like that of Israeli Heron UAVs.
1600x960_165469-hhfffffffff.jpg


HAL cats will be a Wing man drone which will be Operated in Conjecture with Tejas MAX I believe. Its role will be in Attacking and it will be used in Combat.
76678_p1180204copy_213268.jpg


Basically one will be used mostly for Surveillance and the Other will be used in Combat.
Hence Both are being developed for Different roles.
 

IndianHawk

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2016
Messages
9,058
Likes
37,675
Country flag
That's because both are UAVs but both have different Roles to do. One is a UAV(Rustom in this case) and the other will be a UCAV(in this case cats)

Rustom is a Medium Altitude Long Endurance unmanned air vehicle and its role will be Surveillance mostly, basically its role will be like that of Israeli Heron UAVs.

HAL cats will be a Wing man drone which will be Operates in Conjecture with Tejas MAX I believe. Its role will be in Attacking and it will be used in Combat.

Basically one will be used mostly for Surveillance and the Other will be used in Combat.
Hence Both are being developed for Different roles.
Rustom will have armed version too.
 

Super Flanker

Aviation and Defence Enthusiast
Senior Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2021
Messages
5,104
Likes
12,242
Country flag
Rustom will have armed version too.
I am not sure about that though but still both UAVs are being developed for Different roles.
It's like MQ-9 reaper has an Armed Variant and a surveillance Variant of it too.
But CATs will be a wing man drone and Wing man drone need Different designs.
Rustom can't be used as a Wing man drone in my opinion, it's design is just not good enough for a wingman drone in my opinion and that too a stealthy wingman drone.
So cats will do the Job.
Not much to say here after this though @IndianHawk
 

Love Charger

चक्रवर्ती
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2021
Messages
13,045
Likes
34,996
Country flag
That's because both are UAVs but both have different Roles to do. One is a UAV(Rustom in this case) and the other will be a UCAV(in this case cats)

Rustom is a Medium Altitude Long Endurance unmanned air vehicle and its role will be Surveillance mostly, basically its role will be like that of Israeli Heron UAVs.
View attachment 126257

HAL cats will be a Wing man drone which will be Operated in Conjecture with Tejas MAX I believe. Its role will be in Attacking and it will be used in Combat.
View attachment 126256

Basically one will be used mostly for Surveillance and the Other will be used in Combat.
Hence Both are being developed for Different roles.
Thamks , as a gesture of appreciation
Accept this
1635366193168-iriaf_mig-29.jpg

Iran air force mig 29
 

Karthi

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2018
Messages
2,214
Likes
17,755
Country flag
Breaking:

France has agreed to make an 'engine' in India under the strategic partnership model, Def Min Rajnath Singh says.Doesn't go into details but says such an engine is currently not even being made in France.Def Min @rajnathsingh says decision to make an engine in India under SP model taken during his meeting with @florence_parly on Friday.


Manu Pubby


May be if we Order more Rafales . Or without core technologies
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top