Know Your 'Rafale'

Flying Dagger

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
3,583
Likes
9,441
Country flag
Single engine Mirage 2000 and F-16 are in a different weight class to Tejas



Tejas IS a formidable jet, IAF and pilots swear by it and it must and will be inducted in large numbers.

Tejas is viewed as a Mig 21 replacement. Original and latest MRCA were replacements for Mig 27s, Jaguars etc.
This is a discussion that has happened umpteen no. of times

Tejas mk2 will have MTOW higher than Mirage 2000

In short it can replace role of Jaguar and mig 27 to a great extent.

Mirage was our MRCA before it got replaced by Rafale and if Tejas can outperform Mirage 2000 in terms of capability and Gripen etc in tech then it would be good enough to replace MMRCA too.

Damn we have been repeating this for over a decade I feel weird reading same line writing similar line.
 

BON PLAN

-*-
Contributor
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
6,433
Likes
7,047
Country flag
But we can compare the prices too right ?

There is a reason Rafale was left out in many procurement against Gripen.


By the time F4 upgrade of Rafale start rolling out for French airforce
Gripen is lighter, less ranged, less load able, less powerful but slightly less costly. That's why peaceful country think it is enough. These country only made air policy mission. (Brazil, Switzerland...).
Egypt, Qatar, India may have to fight and conduct air to ground mission sometimes deep inside the enemy lands : they chose Rafale for that.

About Tejas mk2 : Indian time is strange.... French one not.
 

Flying Dagger

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
3,583
Likes
9,441
Country flag
Gripen is lighter, less ranged, less load able, less powerful but slightly less costly. That's why peaceful country think it is enough. These country only made air policy mission. (Brazil, Switzerland...).
Egypt, Qatar, India may have to fight and conduct air to ground mission sometimes deep inside the enemy lands : they chose Rafale for that.

About Tejas mk2 : Indian time is strange.... French one not.
Pakistan isn't that deep from our airbases and the price difference isn't slight less but almost half And Saab has a record of delivering what they said when it comes to TOT.

Qatar is buying everything Egypt is following that's it and how they fought war is known
For Gripen list is long south Africa Thailand Hungary etc...

As far as timeline is concerned indian industry has matured over time with Pvt companies coming up . We have seen it in the delivery of Tejas mk1 everything is going smooth now. And whatever bottleneck remains are being sorted out.
 

uoftotaku

Regular Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
937
Likes
3,544
Country flag
And Saab has a record of delivering what they said when it comes to TOT.
Saab is distinctly NOT in control of the vast majority of critical component IP in regards to the Gripen NG project so the question ToT is not in their hands. If they receive permission from the IP holders and waivers from the US then yes ToT can be easily followed through.
 

Flying Dagger

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
3,583
Likes
9,441
Country flag
Saab is distinctly NOT in control of the vast majority of critical component IP in regards to the Gripen NG project so the question ToT is not in their hands. If they receive permission from the IP holders and waivers from the US then yes ToT can be easily followed through.
No one is going to provide complete TOT but Saab would have helped us in Tejas if we had gone that way. If we are in any dreamy land that french would part with any critical tech it's not gonna happen. Our manufacturing process would have learnt and developed a lot too. Saab is a very efficient organisation.

There are compromises everywhere either we dish out truck loads of money or make a smart choice within budget.
 

BON PLAN

-*-
Contributor
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
6,433
Likes
7,047
Country flag
No one is going to provide complete TOT but Saab would have helped us in Tejas if we had gone that way. If we are in any dreamy land that french would part with any critical tech it's not gonna happen. Our manufacturing process would have learnt and developed a lot too. Saab is a very efficient organisation.

There are compromises everywhere either we dish out truck loads of money or make a smart choice within budget.
Tejas was inspired by Dassault design contrat. Long time ago.
And as quite always with India, the first contrat was not followed... So Tejas is not fine tuned
 

BON PLAN

-*-
Contributor
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
6,433
Likes
7,047
Country flag
Saab is distinctly NOT in control of the vast majority of critical component IP in regards to the Gripen NG project so the question ToT is not in their hands. If they receive permission from the IP holders and waivers from the US then yes ToT can be easily followed through.
Gripen is Swedish + English + Italian + US made. Not easy for a non align country....
 

BON PLAN

-*-
Contributor
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
6,433
Likes
7,047
Country flag
I need some specialists opinion : what is the use of chaff on a 5th gen aircraft ?

Why such 4'th gen old technology on a marvelous plane so stealthy that any other plane can't come close.
Why add weight on this impressive product that can fired any other plane at 100km thanks to its so powerfull radar and EOTS ?
I don't understand.... o_O

https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zo...termeasures-to-confuse-enemy-radars-next-year
 

Assassin 2.0

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2019
Messages
6,087
Likes
30,705
Country flag
French President announces 3-pronged security partnership with India for Southern Indian Ocean



French President Emmanuel Macron announced a three-pronged security partnership with India in the southern Indian Ocean in the backdrop of China’s growing ambitions in the region. French President Emmanuel Macron announced a three-pronged security partnership with India in the southern Indian Ocean in the backdrop of China’s growing ambitions in the region. Macron stated that India and France were sharing the analysis of joint maritime security in the southern Indian Ocean, working on a joint maritime surveillance in the region and looking at possible deployment of an Indian Navy maritime patrol vessel in Reunion Island from the first quarter of 2020. In an indirect reference to China’s designs on the western and southern Indian Ocean Region, the French President said in his speech, “We must protect the Great Indo-Pacific space for no hegemony to reign. A security presence in the region is essential for building this freedom in sovereignty and for establishing a common agenda.” “Together with India, we have been working with PM Modi on a shared ocean vision and strengthened our operational cooperation for stability and security in the region….It’s an unprecedented movement, a very profound change. A few years ago we had never planned to engage with our Indian friends here in the same way as the operations we did recently. This is the reality of this strategic agenda that we share,” he said. Macron said, “This common security agenda in the region is an agenda of maritime surveillance, protection of our marine areas, construction of a joint agenda to avoid any form of hegemony or intrusion and it is noted that the France is the 2nd largest maritime power in the world.” The French President’s comments came at the event where ministers of India, France and Vanilla Islands (Comoros, Madagascar, Mauritius and Seychelles in the western Indian Ocean) met to explore economic and development partnership. India was represented by the minister of state for external affairs V Muraleedharan at the first such ministerial meet. India, in partnership with France, is keen to focus on port development, blue economy, trade, connectivity, tourism, skill development, hospitality and healthcare in this resource-rich region, said people aware of the matter. India is also eyeing gas deposits in the Mozambique Channel near Vanilla Islands. The joint statement issued after Modi’s meeting with Macron on August 22 had indicated enhancement in the Indo-French partnership in the western Indian Ocean. “Based on a shared commitment to maintaining the freedom of navigation, particularly in the Indo-Pacific zone, maritime security cooperation between France and India is a domain of excellence in their strategic partnership,” said the joint statement. surveillance in the region and looking at possible deployment of an Indian Navy maritime patrol vessel in Reunion Island from the first quarter of 2020. In an indirect reference to China’s designs on the western and southern Indian Ocean Region, the French President said in his speech, “We must protect the Great Indo-Pacific space for no hegemony to reign. A security presence in the region is essential for building this freedom in sovereignty and for establishing a common agenda.” “Together with India, we have been working with PM Modi on a shared ocean vision and strengthened our operational cooperation for stability and security in the region….It’s an unprecedented movement, a very profound change. A few years ago we had never planned to engage with our Indian friends here in the same way as the operations we did recently. This is the reality of this strategic agenda that we share,” he said. Macron said, “This common security agenda in the region is an agenda of maritime surveillance, protection of our marine areas, construction of a joint agenda to avoid any form of hegemony or intrusion and it is noted that the France is the 2nd largest maritime power in the world.” The French President’s comments came at the event where ministers of India, France and Vanilla Islands (Comoros, Madagascar, Mauritius and Seychelles in the western Indian Ocean) met to explore economic and development partnership. India was represented by the minister of state for external affairs V Muraleedharan at the first such ministerial meet. India, in partnership with France, is keen to focus on port development, blue economy, trade, connectivity, tourism, skill development, hospitality and healthcare in this resource-rich region, said people aware of the matter. India is also eyeing gas deposits in the Mozambique Channel near Vanilla Islands. “Based on a shared commitment to maintaining the freedom of navigation, particularly in the Indo-Pacific zone, maritime security cooperation between France and India is a domain of excellence in their strategic partnership,” said the joint statement.
 

Assassin 2.0

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2019
Messages
6,087
Likes
30,705
Country flag

India to Deploy Naval Aircraft at France’s La Réunion for Joint Surveillance Mission
Within the first few months of 2020, India will deploy a naval aircraft at France’s reunion island as part of join surveillance mission with France in the southern IOC
 

Imaxxx

"Shaktimev Jayate" - Strength Alone Triumphs
Regular Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
486
Likes
2,114
Country flag

India to Deploy Naval Aircraft at France’s La Réunion for Joint Surveillance Mission
Within the first few months of 2020, India will deploy a naval aircraft at France’s reunion island as part of join surveillance mission with France in the southern IOC
Reunion is fast becoming India's southernmost outpost to monitor chinkis in IOR. Recently this month INS Tarkash did a 3-day halt at Reunion on her way back after participating in the Russian Naval Day Parade in St P.
https://www.aninews.in/news/nationa...es-at-reunion-island-in-france20191004010531/

While India has access to Diego G through the LEMOA, it's for logistical purposes. This agreement with France to base aircraft at Reunion takes IOR monitoring by IN to a whole new level.

PLAN destinations in IOR are to loiter in Arabian Sea to monitor USN/IN activity, or head to Djibouti or porkistan. Access to all of these lies between India and Reunion
Reunion.PNG


IN's strategy to monitor Plan in its entry to the Arabian Sea is taking shape nicely. The distance between Kochi and Reunion is approx. 4000km. P8I has an operating radius of ~2200km, iow, operating from Kochi currently it can cover half the distance to Reunion in its operating mission, leaving a gap in surveillance of the other half distance. A P8I (assuming it's a P8I) based at Reunion, operating in a North-easternly arc could cover the half the distance to India, while another operating from Kochi could cover the other half of the distance operating in a south-westernly arc. This two pronged surveillance would potentially cover all naval activity heading into the Arabian Sea.

In sync, to ensure P8I can operate from Kochi, a Naval Air Enclave was created at Cochin International Airport this year with hangar and other logistic facilities.
According to the Indian Navy officials, the runway at INS Garuda, a Naval air station located in Kochi, is not large enough for take-off and landing of long-range maritime reconnaissance anti-submarine warfare aircraft like the Boeing P8I.

“The runway at the Navy air base could only allow for the take-off and landing of smaller aircraft like C-130, C-70, AN-32 and the Dornier. Aircraft like the P8I can now take off and land from the Cochin International Airport where they will be provided fuelling facility, aircraft ladders and starting supply,” a senior Navy official told IANS.

The MoU was signed between Captain Satish Kumar S., the officer-in-charge of Naval Air Enclave (NAE) in Kochi, and A.C.K. Nair, Director of CIAL.

The NAE is a Naval aviation facility comprising an independent dispersal, aircraft hangar, administrative building and taxi track.
https://newsd.in/military-aircraft-can-now-use-civilian-airport-in-kochi/

Plan may have exploited weaknesses in the past, for example to show up undetected in Karachi, but it will no longer be able to operate with impunity.

#pkkmkb #destroypakistan
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top