WolfPack86
New Member
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2015
- Messages
- 10,571
- Likes
- 16,993
GTRE has issued a tender for 'Expression of Interest for Altitude Tests of Kaveri Engine and its Derivative'.
mig29.....Will this need a Flying test Bed?
The above was posted by me on strategic frontier and also here previously...GTRE has issued a tender for 'Expression of Interest for Altitude Tests of Kaveri Engine and its Derivative'.
Sorry bro when i saw kaveri update i got over excited i do not know that you already posted it.The above was posted by me on strategic frontier and also here previously...
Have they put the manufacturing process also? Blade designs are not something new. USA has supplied F16, F18, F15 etc to many countries like Turkey, Pakistan, Egypt, Arabs etc who would already have sold it to others by now and the engine design would be a common knowledge.Our guys are dumb enough to put all the blade designs including blue prints to call tenders for manufacturing blades.
Sent from my Redmi 4 using Tapatalk
what! have they actually done this? really?Our guys are dumb enough to put all the blade designs including blue prints to call tenders for manufacturing blades.
Sent from my Redmi 4 using Tapatalk
The design of a blade is not very sensitive.Our guys are dumb enough to put all the blade designs including blue prints to call tenders for manufacturing blades.
Sent from my Redmi 4 using Tapatalk
My concern is different.The design of a blade is not very sensitive.
The sensitive part is the know how and the industrial equipments to produce it !
In case of a single crystal blade, the metalurgical process is a very hard task. It takes years (not to say dozen years) to master it.
It is well known of the materials used to make the blades. They are all available in research papers. It is the exact process that matters. It is difficult to simply sniff the process of blade making as these critical items are under government control. The companies don't have the control over these items. Also, highly critical things are likely done by Indian PSUs only. There are no private companies who have good metallurgy in IndiaMy concern is different.
If they got blade designs and after few months they will declare the tender winner,so people can sniff what that company is using to make that blade.
This is it !It is well known of the materials used to make the blades. They are all available in research papers. It is the exact process that matters. It is difficult to simply sniff the process of blade making as these critical items are under government control. The companies don't have the control over these items. Also, highly critical things are likely done by Indian PSUs only. There are no private companies who have good metallurgy in India
Just wondering.... Can we use one of the decommissioned Tu 142 as test bed in similar fashion ?View attachment 24781
Having an aircraft is not enough. The engineers need to know/understand the full design of the aircraft before attempting any changes.
Plenty of Boeing and airbus in country, even Ilyushin. but we went to russia for testing kaveri?
India must develop its own flying testbed for testing gas turbine engines
@Babloo Singh @lcafanboy @aditya g @Kshatriya87 @Kshithij
Very true. But a 4 engine commercial airline planes like Boeing 747 can easily be converted into test bed as it can fly with even 2 engines working and one of the 4 engine bay can be designed to accommodate various types of aero engines with instruments on board. Further a couple of MIG 29s also especially twin seater can also be converted easily for advance fighter test bed as it can fly with single engine and instruments can be carried on board by removing second seat. These are achievable for HAL as they are fully aware of mig29 design and Boeing is very much easier to convert.Having an aircraft is not enough. The engineers need to know/understand the full design of the aircraft before attempting any changes.
Even a minor mismatch can have fatal consequences!
Yes, Mig29 or a Su30MKI would be ideal candidates for test - as HAL has expertise with these platforms.Very true. But a 4 engine commercial airline planes like Boeing 747 can easily be converted into test bed as it can fly with even 2 engines working and one of the 4 engine bay can be designed to accommodate various types of aero engines with instruments on board. Further a couple of MIG 29s also especially twin seater can also be converted easily for advance fighter test bed as it can fly with single engine and instruments can be carried on board by removing second seat. These are achievable for HAL as they are fully aware of mig29 design and Boeing is very much easier to convert.
The only issue preventing this is money and lack of vision.... Our successive governments was is penny wise and pound foolish. They would not release funds for test bed but spend a fortune on consultancies only to be told that Kaveri engine is ready to fly but would need test bed which they can provide for a loot....
That is where France deal comes in. We are most likely getting a test bed and auditing from France. Also, the testing at altitude can be done by keeping the engine in Leh and running it. It will give a good sense of 12000 feet. Then it can be tested on flight with Snecma's assistance to get things done quickly. Paying a few million dollars for test bed rent is not a big deal in the overall picture. Money is not a restraint. Moreover, there has been no news about flying test bed. I would not say that India does not have one without source.Very true. But a 4 engine commercial airline planes like Boeing 747 can easily be converted into test bed as it can fly with even 2 engines working and one of the 4 engine bay can be designed to accommodate various types of aero engines with instruments on board. Further a couple of MIG 29s also especially twin seater can also be converted easily for advance fighter test bed as it can fly with single engine and instruments can be carried on board by removing second seat. These are achievable for HAL as they are fully aware of mig29 design and Boeing is very much easier to convert.
The only issue preventing this is money and lack of vision.... Our successive governments was is penny wise and pound foolish. They would not release funds for test bed but spend a fortune on consultancies only to be told that Kaveri engine is ready to fly but would need test bed which they can provide for a loot....
That's exactly what is being done. French were supposed to test fly and certify Kaveri engine this year itself and integration to LCA 2019. Modi government split mmrca deal into milestones first deal for 36 Rafales to test if they deliver jet engine technology as offset once they deliver another 36 Rafales deal will be signed. This has to done before elections to prove rafale deal is not expensive as next lot of 36 will be assembled in India at very low price as all offset cost, factory set up cost and base cost has been done in first deal. This will take air out of opposition propoganda that Rafale deal had kick back and so is expensive...That is where France deal comes in. We are most likely getting a test bed and auditing from France. Also, the testing at altitude can be done by keeping the engine in Leh and running it. It will give a good sense of 12000 feet. Then it can be tested on flight with Snecma's assistance to get things done quickly. Paying a few million dollars for test bed rent is not a big deal in the overall picture. Money is not a restraint. Moreover, there has been no news about flying test bed. I would not say that India does not have one without source.
Modified kaveri engine for AURA/GHATAK in developmentAFAIK Ghatak is the definitive powerplant of the ADA's yet to be produced aura/UCAV which is a version of Kaveri without its afterburner. Former MOD had also referred to the same engine in the parliament while replying to a query. But some members are using the term Ghatak as synonymous with aura/UCAV. It is quite confusing.