Indian Special Forces

airborneCommando

Senior Member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
1,093
Likes
2,890
Country flag
I was just saying that culturally the most mature seems 1 Para SF, 10 seems well sorted like MARCOS (atleast in interviews), and 9 seems the most brawny
Just wanted to add a bit more to your comment..1 para was the first unit to go SF, that is, the unit had organised it's War Establishment kind of similiar to SAS (4 Assualt Teams -> each team with 4 Specialised troops -> Each troop with multiple 6 man squads) while 10 and 9 para were more or less a paradrop capable self sustaining commando unit. 1 was assigned with NSG equivalent mandate and had most of the SF/SOF training infrastructure.
Till date every battalion with Counter Terrorism specialization runs all black kits which has evolved over time in some battalions.
Although personally I believe 1 para should of been raised from scratch instead of converting an airborne unit into SF unit which I believe fueled the whole airborne fraternity's greed to turn whole regiment into SF.
Speaking of 10 para, they have mostly enjoyed a great officer class, even the men they select are really good although some newbies are way too cocky sometimes.
Trivia - 1 para use to run actual red cell type of operations back in the day
 
Last edited:

NoobWannaLearn

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
8,977
Likes
29,221
Country flag
some newbies are way too cocky sometimes
I mean yea young guys Achieving some big things that most people only dream of in NDA or whatever Battalion the Officers come from so I think some do get cocky and Arrogant I think with time Most of not all gets humbled some are just Special cases.

Just wanted to add a bit more to your comment..1 para was the first unit to go SF, that is, the unit had organised it's War Establishment kind of similiar to SAS (4 Assualt Teams -> each team with 4 Specialised troops -> Each troop with multiple 6 man squads) while 10 and 9 para were more or less a paradrop capable self sustaining commando unit.
I am Courius then what made 9 basically a tier 1 unit (Some sf Operators themselves call 9 and 11 tier 1 units now ) is it the rich history that they have and successful ops?
 

Jedi Operator

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2022
Messages
1,206
Likes
3,466
Country flag
Just wanted to add a bit more to your comment..1 para was the first unit to go SF, that is, the unit had organised it's War Establishment kind of similiar to SAS (4 Assualt Teams -> each team with 4 Specialised troops -> Each troop with multiple 6 man squads) while 10 and 9 para were more or less a paradrop capable self sustaining commando unit. 1 was assigned with NSG equivalent mandate and had most of the SF/SOF training infrastructure.
Till date every battalion with Counter Terrorism specialization runs all black kits which has evolved over time in some battalions.
Although personally I believe 1 para should of been raised from scratch instead of converting an airborne unit into SF unit which I believe fueled the whole airborne fraternity's greed to turn whole regiment into SF.
Speaking of 10 para, they have mostly enjoyed a great officer class, even the men they select are really good although some newbies are way too cocky sometimes.
Trivia - 1 para use to run actual red cell type of operations back in the day
Dude during the time of conversion, 1 Para's CO was Lt Gen Inder Singh Gill who was a member of British SOE and also operated with OSS in WW2. He got the millitary cross for his actions in Greece Operation Harling
 

DIE UwU

Regular Member
Joined
May 10, 2023
Messages
298
Likes
752
Country flag
We totally ignored the single earpiece motorola headsets. Proof that multicam makes everything look gucci lmao. Can anyone here make a multicam patka helmet on photoshop xd?
Its not about multicam,
Crye JPC are THE best in the market right now.
Combined with high-cut helmets with MC cover.
its pretty clear that everything has not been standardized yet.
For example , there are no Tavor x 95 in sight.
X95 and comtacs will get standardized eventually
.
 

NoobWannaLearn

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
8,977
Likes
29,221
Country flag
Its not about multicam,
Crye JPC are THE best in the market right now.
Combined with high-cut helmets with MC cover.
its pretty clear that everything has not been standardized yet.
For example , there are no Tavor x 95 in sight.
X95 and comtacs will get standardized eventually
.
It will take a couple of years but Navy will standarise the gear alot has already happened in 2 years and 2 more years they will be completely Standarised and same goes to atleast most para units.
 

ALBY

Section Moderator
Mod
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,666
Likes
7,156
Country flag
Major Surendra poonia was was also good although that was with Ranvir so there is cringe somewhere
Lol. Out of all the talks of SF operators i heard his tedx talk some years back was the most exaggerated cringe one i have ever heard.Reminded me of how ex military persons in family tells how they escaped bombing of pakistan in 1971 and how bullets of chinese dodged them in 67😂 .
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,256
Likes
18,269
Country flag
Just wanted to add a bit more to your comment..1 para was the first unit to go SF, that is, the unit had organised it's War Establishment kind of similiar to SAS (4 Assualt Teams -> each team with 4 Specialised troops -> Each troop with multiple 6 man squads) while 10 and 9 para were more or less a paradrop capable self sustaining commando unit. 1 was assigned with NSG equivalent mandate and had most of the SF/SOF training infrastructure.
Till date every battalion with Counter Terrorism specialization runs all black kits which has evolved over time in some battalions.
Although personally I believe 1 para should of been raised from scratch instead of converting an airborne unit into SF unit which I believe fueled the whole airborne fraternity's greed to turn whole regiment into SF.
Speaking of 10 para, they have mostly enjoyed a great officer class, even the men they select are really good although some newbies are way too cocky sometimes.
Trivia - 1 para use to run actual red cell type of operations back in the day
After 71 which ops have 10 para done which are successfull..

just curious..i can count a few major blunders
 

Blood+

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2011
Messages
3,022
Likes
4,813
Country flag
Lol. Out of all the talks of SF operators i heard his tedx talk some years back was the most exaggerated cringe one i have ever heard.Reminded me of how ex military persons in family tells how they escaped bombing of pakistan in 1971 and how bullets of chinese dodged them in 67😂 .
Yeah, no one beats our faujis when it comes to their wild imagination.
 

NoobWannaLearn

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
8,977
Likes
29,221
Country flag
Lol. Out of all the talks of SF operators i heard his tedx talk some years back was the most exaggerated cringe one i have ever heard.Reminded me of how ex military persons in family tells how they escaped bombing of pakistan in 1971 and how bullets of chinese dodged them in 67😂 .
I haven't seen that so I can't comment but that podcast was good apart from the usual cringe
 

airborneCommando

Senior Member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
1,093
Likes
2,890
Country flag
After 71 which ops have 10 para done which are successfull..

just curious..i can count a few major blunders
Mostly were during the first phase of Op Rakshak and North East. I believe the major blunders which you are talking about was during 80s down in lanka and in 99 where most of their ops were literally what line infantry was supposed to be doing. 1 para too took a lot of casualties during IPKF effort in lanka though. 9 had the lowest casualties out of all three commando units.
 

ALBY

Section Moderator
Mod
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,666
Likes
7,156
Country flag
After 71 which ops have 10 para done which are successfull..

just curious..i can count a few major blunders
In Op blue star they lost men,sri lanka too were a bleeding ground as far as i can recall they had met the worst ambush any SF unit had met .In 2006/07 1st lost 8 men in a single ambush in Kashmir.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top