Indian Special Forces

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,059
Likes
33,675
Country flag
Back then, the way Indian army reacted to situations was far superior:
1. After Operation Blue Star, Indian forces suffered heavy casualties due to inexperience in room clearing ops against urban guerillas, hence NSG was formed SPECIFICALLY to keep commando units out of coin ops (back then we had no SOF only top tier commandos (in b4 accused of jai ho gang)).
2. Formation and expansion of RR after Lanka to keep infantry units out of COIN ops in mid-late 90s.
3. Creation of CI schools.
4. Creation of HAWS right after 1948 war (which was entirely mountain- in 65 India woild dominate the entire Kashmir sector)
5. Creation of para brigade after formation of SAS in 50s
6. Creation of 10 para commando in 1970 for desert warfare as Rajasthan was a hot sector in 65 (and did top tier commando ops)
7. Creation of SF regiment for strategic ops as commandos couldn’t do strategic ops in Lanka (costing us a lot of time and men)
8. Adoption of Camo after usa in Vietnam

Ofc 1962 happened but that solely happened due to heavy pol. Interference in armed forces (for eg. thimayya wanted to but western rifles but was denied by MoD as Menon was a full blown commie, same with western-fighter jets- resulting in using .303 rifles against AKs). Not to mention the corrupt generals Kaul and Thapar who were promoted due to politics.
Current gen of officers are riding on the legacy of their predecessors. What’s their contribution? Diluting SF? Opening up ranks to women? Endless RFIs?

almost all reforms For IA in the last decade were forced on them from above. IA’s current generals are too busy jealously protecting their privileges

a lot died with Gen Rawat
 

Kumaoni

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2022
Messages
8,464
Likes
23,058
Current gen of officers are riding on the legacy of their predecessors. What’s their contribution? Diluting SF? Opening up ranks to women? Endless RFIs?

almost all reforms For IA in the last decade were forced on them from above. IA’s current generals are too busy jealously protecting their privileges

a lot died with Gen Rawat
It’s sad. Rawat and his COAS, MUkund Navarane, really tried changing things. That SIG deal was golden. It’s just sad that Navarane sir gave up after Rawats death.

Indian army learns no lessons anymore, still doing the same fire daylight assualts it did in 2003
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,059
Likes
33,675
Country flag
View attachment 218305

IN VBSS with PRINCETON TEC CHARGE MPLS HELMET LIGHT (i guess)

View attachment 218308
VBSS is so random. They have some of the highest spec PPE seen anywhere in India and years ahead of the elite units but their drills are poor and of course their primary weapons are beyond outdated. What kind of cognitive dissonance does their procurement officer have?

literally anything would be better- AMOGH, MP5, JVPC, X95. Of course they went for one of the most hilarious options- a full length 7.62*51 assault rifle to board ships with, competence at its finest
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,059
Likes
33,675
Country flag

Kumaoni

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2022
Messages
8,464
Likes
23,058
Clueless generals


FINSAS is utter trash but hey, jet packs

I genuinely have no idea if this is coming from intentional or accidental ineptness.

this is a force that can’t even get a 20 year old (spec) ACH for each of its soldiers
Why Indians want to take back Tibet? To make more Tibetans look like shit with shit equipments? China deserves Tibet at this point.
 

Jedi Operator

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2022
Messages
1,134
Likes
3,296
Country flag
Clueless generals


FINSAS is utter trash but hey, jet packs

I genuinely have no idea if this is coming from intentional or accidental ineptness.

this is a force that can’t even get a 20 year old (spec) ACH for each of its soldiers
It's basically to make the army a circus, just one more step to make the seniors' mood go hunky dory because playing golf is too old school. Enjoy the bad show instead
 

Aditya Ballal

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2020
Messages
3,601
Likes
22,203
Country flag
VBSS is so random. They have some of the highest spec PPE seen anywhere in India and years ahead of the elite units but their drills are poor and of course their primary weapons are beyond outdated. What kind of cognitive dissonance does their procurement officer have?

literally anything would be better- AMOGH, MP5, JVPC, X95. Of course they went for one of the most hilarious options- a full length 7.62*51 assault rifle to board ships with, competence at its finest
The fucking Coast Guard has completely ditched the Sterling and moved on to the 5.56x30mm Amogh and JVPC. The folks at the Coast Guard I’ve interacted with in Mangalore had no specific complaints about it and was definitely better than the Sterling.
1692095293893.jpeg
1692095306317.jpeg
1692095321376.jpeg
1692095376003.jpeg
 

Inderjeet Singh

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2019
Messages
1,492
Likes
7,065
Country flag

New threads

Articles

Top