Exactly, its worse than collage ragging, i was a member for 10years since 2000 and they ban me without second thought. Its not just new comers, some times they do have valuable points and also teach the new comers some modesty and self criticism when it comes to mindless criticism towards DRDO etc., Some people join in only to criticize stuff without knowing the highly complex nature of these technologies under development, such people deserve a wallop to make their lazy a$$ read more about the stuff before opening their mouth.
Either way BR is a brutal place and i know who your talking about, Mr.S is not even a surgeon he is an dentist who plays golf and spends most of his time on BR. He probably hates his job so much that he tries to distract himself from it as much as possible. His hate towards his own life shows in his rude and condescending attitude towards others.