bhramos
New Member
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2009
- Messages
- 25,644
- Likes
- 37,250
The definitive engine for Pak-Fa enters testing around 2015(rumored). To spend money on signal management of non definitive engines is wasteful.Look at the engine body of PAKFA and F-22. It seems Russians didnt made any efforts to reduce heat signature from the engine.
Raptors are designed to reduce its infrared signal too.
Nozzle design helps in reducing the thermal bloom as well. Flying at 60,000 feet, the exhaust plume of a jet engine makes a stark contrast with the ambient temperature. The plume of a regular jet nozzle is of conical shape, what the flat nozzles manage to achieve is pressing the exhaust plume into a sheet, similar to what happens when you squeeze your gardening hose end and water spreads into a sheet instead of a circular cross section. Due to this, the surface area of plume in contact with freezing air increases several times as compared to your regular jet nozzle, the cooling is more rapid and the exhaust plume as visible in the IRST shrinks several time (some rumours quote 4-5 times reduction in size). This achievement comes at the cost of reduced thrust. Serrations on the nozzle help achieve lower RCS and also create ripples on the surface of plume that increases its surface area (though not as much as a flat nozzle). The idea of using flat nozzles is also used in hairdryers, where an excessively hot plume used to damage the hair, flattening the nozzle made the temperature of hot air a little more homogenousThey can always go for Seratted Nozzle of F-35 type with Round Nozzle to give it stealth.
And you cannot reduce heat signature to the extent that it is usable in any Stealth Fighter , unless you to to some extreme length like using non-after burner engine and careful placing of engine mixes with cool air and other thing like B-2 does which needs size , the idea of using Serrated Nozzle or Flat Nozzle on fighter is to reduce Radar Signature and not heat.
Saturn and Salyut are working together for the definitive engine.Saturn's flat nozzles.
saturn flat nozzle patent(2008) - YouTube
However Salyut has been chosen for Type 30 engine.
All that is cool and can be considered a nice scientific argument , if you fly at 60 thousand feet the radar will any way detect you and most modern radar are designed to detect small RCS target at sufficiently long range ( and dont tell me stealth is invisible )Nozzle design helps in reducing the thermal bloom as well. Flying at 60,000 feet, the exhaust plume of a jet engine makes a stark contrast with the ambient temperature. The plume of a regular jet nozzle is of conical shape, what the flat nozzles manage to achieve is pressing the exhaust plume into a sheet, similar to what happens when you squeeze your gardening hose end and water spreads into a sheet instead of a circular cross section. Due to this, the surface area of plume in contact with freezing air increases several times as compared to your regular jet nozzle, the cooling is more rapid and the exhaust plume as visible in the IRST shrinks several time (some rumours quote 4-5 times reduction in size). This achievement comes at the cost of reduced thrust. Serrations on the nozzle help achieve lower RCS and also create ripples on the surface of plume that increases its surface area (though not as much as a flat nozzle). The idea of using flat nozzles is also used in hairdryers, where an excessively hot plume used to damage the hair, flattening the nozzle made the temperature of hot air a little more homogenous
PS: If you can get hold of an IR camera, you can observe the exhaust of hair dryers with regular round nozzle and flat nozzle
Nope, I don't think that stealth is a magic bullet, its far from it. But I would also take SAM radar manufacturers claims with a pinch of salt. The fact that there is one stealth fighter flying around, 3 in prototype stages and 3 on drawing boards suggest that the advantage of a low RCS is undeniable. How long do you think before vlo planes get jammers with processors strong enough to counter frequency hopping and frequency modulation for dozens of channels ? There is a limit for application of LPI modes before it gets prohibitive for 1500 i/p o/p channels (assuming al T/x modules can operate independently and are not bunched together in large numbers), of which only a small fraction will be dedicated per target which will enable 5th gen platforms to come closer to LPI radars with minimal risk of being targeted than ever before ?All that is cool and can be considered a nice scientific argument , if you fly at 60 thousand feet the radar will any way detect you and most modern radar are designed to detect small RCS target at sufficiently long range ( and dont tell me stealth is invisible )
The jet nozzles, if made of proper material, would not be glowing hot (I am just talking about outer view of nozzles, not the plume or rear view looking into exhausts)For modern IR sensors seeker that are cooled at below zero degrees , they can even detect a small match stick flare at long distance , even if they manage to reduce Thermal Signature many fold with Flat Nozzle , the nozzle it self is sufficiently hot and the plume is enough to get a sweet IR spot for any decent single or two color IR seeker that looks at 2 different IR frequency.
Now if you add FPA type array that actually images the entire target and not just sweet hot spots , your flat nozzle wont help you much in IR spectrum.
If you recollect in one of the Franborough air show were the Rapier IR system detected a B-2 flying and created a controversy , you would have realised the B-2 did not create any engine signature but still the IR system could see the aircraft and image it. Now only if that was a missile nose it would have hit that bird.
The problem with IR system is how to cue it to the right place and for that you need a radar , if you can sufficiently be less visible to the radar you are in a way beating the IR system , but for any modern AAM like Python-5 ,RVV-MD and similar type finding a target like F-22 or PAK-FA wont be a challange if you are in a WVR duel with it.
One can design a 3D nozzle with petals but that would lead to terrible nozzle efficiency (although it will be squeezing plume into 3 planes instead of one and lead to a greater reduction in heat signature).Nozzle is that much better becuase you can exploit the 3 D TVC to enhance your manouveribility over a just 2D type nozzle that is what you will get with Flat Nozzle.
Ofcourse where did i ever say Stealth was useless , far from it it gives you a killer advantage when combined with Super Cruise and Super Manouveribility over conventional 4th gen fighter that lack these qualities.Nope, I don't think that stealth is a magic bullet, its far from it. But I would also take SAM radar manufacturers claims with a pinch of salt. The fact that there is one stealth fighter flying around, 3 in prototype stages and 3 on drawing boards suggest that the advantage of a low RCS is undeniable. How long do you think before vlo planes get jammers with processors strong enough to counter frequency hopping and frequency modulation for dozens of channels ? There is a limit for application of LPI modes before it gets prohibitive for 1500 i/p o/p channels (assuming al T/x modules can operate independently and are not bunched together in large numbers), of which only a small fraction will be dedicated per target which will enable 5th gen platforms to come closer to LPI radars with minimal risk of being targeted than ever before ?
Ceramics are used to reduce reduce the heat thats true and you can see the white coating even on PAK-FA nozzle but those gains are not substantial to reduce its effectiveness against modern 2 color Seeker or FPA array.The jet nozzles, if made of proper material, would not be glowing hot (I am just talking about outer view of nozzles, not the plume or rear view looking into exhausts)
^This is the substance used on the outer surface of space shuttles, developed in the 60's. Its ability to maintain high temperature gradient enables one side to be as hot as 3000 degree celcius and other side cold enough to be held in hand without being too uncomfortable. Raptor's nozzles use a more durable material like this, both in form of lining and forming sawtooth edges. Even MiG 1.44 was supposed to use ceramic lining in the nozzles.