I have responded separately. India is doing whatever it can. If you wish to suggest some other action, please provide a list of such possible actions..
India is not doing enough, Is all what I can as of now, the true potential has not been realized. Hopefully the next boom would see some improvement. Yes positive swing in the economy makes such things much easier.
North Korea serves as a launch pad against the US that both Russia and PRC could use while preserving the plausible deniability. I read news that both PRC and Russia were selling them oil in violation of UN resolution. For Russia and PRC, North Korea is an asset. For the US, it gave a defence contractor an opportunity to propose a defence shield along the US West Coast. I wonder what was the need for Trump to muddy the waters with North Korea? I don't believe North Korea is a threat to the US..
South Korea and Japan are two very important countries in the region. They do have great roles to play in isolation of North Korea. For US Russia and China still are the two greatest thread against whom they have strategic deployments in Eastern Europe and two Island Chins on the Pacific rim. Nuclear weapons of North Korea is sufficient to divert these resources(American resources deployed in Europe and Asia) to other parts of the world, If there is proliferation which will happen just like in past in case of Pakistan, stretching the already stretched American resources, and hence weakening the defense, today the tactical nukes which Pakistan talk about is based on plutonium based device, they got their 1st plutonium based device from North Korea in 1998. If South Korea, Taiwan, Japan and Philippines fall, Pacific is just an open sea up for scaling.
We did it officially? Perhaps I was misinformed. Would you please provide the statement from the Army spokesperson that we crossed the international border?.
Please watch the press conference of DGMO, now don't tell me that we also have terrorist camps on our side and Pakistani Army manning these camps for supporting them, Which our forces attacked. And what would be more official than the Foreign Secretary starting that conference.
What should the government have allowed after 26/11? Who sought permission? I ask because someone in a higher authority can allow an action only if someone from a subordinate position seeks permission. So, please clarify..
Air strikes, through guided munitions or cruise missiles. It is higher authority to ask the forces if they can do that, we live in a democracy where Civilian Government calls shots. So this question should not be who sought permission, It should be who gave permission or why wasn't the permission given. And permission for what, a military area were not attacked, civilians were attacked, since when did military started meddling into civilian matters.
And It is beyond me how Brasstacs, Parakaram era had pro-active commanders who jumped gun to seek permission according to your theory but in 26/11 they never came to ask for "permission", seems like the weather was not good or something like that, so they couldn't get to the 7 race course road to seek "permission".
And suddenly it has improved so much that permission is already there on LoC and LAC for active and at times pro-active action.
We have the moral right to respond, yes, so what do you propose we do?.
I hope the recommendation is to actually do against Pakistan and not against fellow Indians. I mean, I don't want a situation where we cannot hit back at Pakistan so we hit back at our fellow countrymen under some flimsy excuses.
Understanding the worth of our own fellow countrymen would be the 1st, about 90000 of them have been slaughtered in these proxy war. Being responsible about them would a 1st, upholding the responsibilities which higher offices hold would be a 1st, enforcing the rule of law would be a 1st. These people don't want non-violence and strategic restrains or moral high grounds which costs their lives and lively hood. These things happen when incompetent people start getting such high offices without doing the hard work, they don't realize the pain of common man when they turn the other cheek.
Our biggest weakness is our propensity to jump to conclusions without any evidence, just because someone said so. India is a highly faith and belief based culture, unlike the west, that is an evidence or metrics based culture.
What conclusions are you talking about ? I don't think we have reached any significant conclusions for a long time on foreign policy matters lately. It look more like state of confusion that conclusion, trying to have all eggs in one basket and ending up with none.
Lets 1st accept the culture we have, strength and weakness come later. And we have to work with what we have.
For the excerpt above, I have responded inline in red.
Oh, I believe they are a victim of terrorism. If someone thinks that I have no sense left, then so be it. It won't change my opinion.
I don't want to respond you anymore on this. Just search for Shahid Afridi's views on Hindus, or that Shoheil Tanveer views on Hindus, or Fawad Khan etc. These are representatives on Pakistan, I am not talking about random people, just get a text book of history Pakistanis have for their school children and see what they say about Hindus, It would put the Nazi hate views on Jews to shame.
You should try teaching their foreign office sometimes, such talent would be a great asset for them convincing the world on their narrative.
Is it on YouTube. If yes, please share.
Search "Secret Pakistan, Double cross" you might find that. It talks about Kunduz airlift and how many times top leadership of Al Qaeda escaped thanks to Pakistan.
You said Georgia's proximity and energy trade forced Russia to take offensive military action, tow which I replied, Kashmir is in India's proximity and we have huge energy reserves waiting to be tapped in central Asia.
India needs to wait for the right opportunity to take control of PoK and Gilgit-Baltistan. It won't happen tomorrow or next year. However, we need to prepare and be ready when the window of opportunity arrives. Access to Central Asia will not only ensure energy security, but it is also important to delink the physical geographical connection between PRC and Pakistan.
While we are talking about Central Asia, I am not very optimistic about attempts to create an alliance with the Uighurs. They have the potential of turning into a Frankenstein. We should learn from our mistake with the LTTE, from Pakistan's mistake with the Mujahideen, the USA's mistake with OBL.
See all this was thought out well by the visionary General Hoon, back in 80s. You are right about waiting for the right time that is very important, but also important is snatching the opportunity when it comes and make full use of that. 80s was the perfect time, when such an opportunity will come next lets wait and watch.