INS Vikrant Aircraft Carrier (IAC)

kamaal

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2016
Messages
515
Likes
1,952
Country flag
These news are good for the deal, the dassault will think about price. Commonality will help them reduce the cost, they must go all out. If they think they can milk us, they are wrong here. Now Boeing knows once you enter in business with India, you can earn as much as you can.
 

MonaLazy

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2019
Messages
1,320
Likes
7,897
Caatsa waiver mila hai...ab aiga to hornet hi

Why not more P8Is (with more kit after BECA, LEMOA & COMCASA), AH-64s, Chinooks, C-5, C-130 etc etc. US has a different line up we are interested in.


These news are good for the deal, the dassault will think about price. Commonality will help them reduce the cost, they must go all out. If they think they can milk us, they are wrong here. Now Boeing knows once you enter in business with India, you can earn as much as you can.
I am hoping what you are hoping - that these are just pressure tactics to squeeze a better Rafale M deal.
 

The Shrike

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2021
Messages
2,427
Likes
9,363
Country flag
All hail Uncle Sam?

F-18 Super Hornet managed to exceed Indian Navy's requirements for MRCBF program.


MRFA to Rafale and MRCBF to F-18? Bye bye commonality and common sense?
Like it of not the US has 10-11 aircraft super carriers in its force, and the Super Hornet makes up most of the carrier fighter fleet - that means they have 10-20x the number of flight hours, number of people that designed and operated this fighter compared to a country with a single small carrier. We have already made that mistake once with the Russians (worse we bought a completely un prove fighter). And french have there share of lemons like NH-90 and Tiger attack helicopters (these are euro projects). So I won't be surprised if the SH is actually a much better package overall compared to the Rafael, which may not be apparent when looking at just Wikimedia specifications.
 

Chinmoy

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2015
Messages
8,834
Likes
22,936
Country flag
All hail Uncle Sam?

F-18 Super Hornet managed to exceed Indian Navy's requirements for MRCBF program.


MRFA to Rafale and MRCBF to F-18? Bye bye commonality and common sense?
Wow.... Thats another level of RR.

It exceeded the expectations. Does it mean we had done the deal?

Even if F/A-18 gets selected, what's wrong in it from this cribbing? It is the best available carrier based fighter as of now.
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,059
Likes
33,675
Country flag
All hail Uncle Sam?

F-18 Super Hornet managed to exceed Indian Navy's requirements for MRCBF program.


MRFA to Rafale and MRCBF to F-18? Bye bye commonality and common sense?
Literally Boeing sales pitch. Funny how much of the defence media is captured by US MIC talking points meanwhile French are going about their business quietly and actually getting things done in india.

the standard is the standard, you don’t actually get points for exceeding it under Indian procurement methodology (remember Parrikar wanted to implement T1/T2 bias). So if both meet the requirements (NSQR) both will be down selected and it will be purely up to cost (L1/L2).

Given that Boeing will always have to price in $3-5bn in additional fixed costs that Dassualt has already amortised in india (ISE, training, basing, infrastructure, support etc etc) it’s hard to see how Boeing wins on L1 especially as we already know the export price is quite eye watering for the SH (RAAF) and that’s without carrier integration costs
 

Gessler

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,311
Likes
11,236
Country flag
Which Experts? Praveen Sawhney type?

Ypu seriously believe that this aircraft worth millions of dollars was lifted by a crane and put on the deck?

View attachment 163635

Yes, IN did 4 extensive sea trials of an aircraft carrier without testing whether an aircraft can land and take-off from the carrier. Totally believable.

this line looks directly copied from some Chinese or Pakistani troll
Do you seriously think they would conduct traps or takeoffs from Vikrant and not tell anybody?

The maiden trap on a carrier is a landmark event, no less than commissioning itself. When the fixed wing flight ops do happen, it's going to be a huge event.

It might even happen after the ship is commissioned, no rule that says otherwise. Commissioning only means the ship itself is ready. The aviation complex can be treated as a separate system with its own operational certification.

The ship itself may be commissioned next month - but its going to be YEARS before its fully operational.

> No fighter flight trials yet, with any payload config
> No flight trials under different Sea States & weather conditions
> MFSTAR radar not even installed yet
> Definitive aviation complex for Vikrant is NOT Mig-29K - it will be MRCBF which will likely arrive only by 2025 if ordered this year, and maybe operational by 2026-27. That's when we can say Vikrant carrier air wing is fully operational. Until then everything is stop-gap.
 

Latest Replies

New threads

Articles

Top