Immanuel
New Member
- Joined
- May 16, 2011
- Messages
- 3,605
- Likes
- 7,574
Buddy, I work with MOD and PMO directly. I have been to several of those schools and I am well aware of the things that happen.Philosophy lecture..yawn!
So you have no idea about the school also and you spent time with SF...mmmmm!!!
Why would i have a problem with infantry being praised when my old man was a infantry officer having served with some of the units you talk about.
Infantry wont thrash Para sf but Garuds and marcos which i was reluctant to share.
My friend in ghatak had the privelage of being in CIJWS and HAWS and was in CBS in 2006 or 07 when he had the oppurtunity to train with Garuds in CBS.
I wont share what happened but he wasnt impressed.
You guys have no idea what happens in such schools when the SF from other units come and train.You guys think all the SF go to this school and they become the best when some of them even find it really hard to just survive.At a time when their instructors are Para guys.
The Infantry guys or Para guys train in this school for a deployment..other SF guys train to increase their skill.
Is it hard to get?..One will be practically using the skill..the other would go back to south india and no practise.
ALL marcos dont do HAWS...or desert warfare school.
First get good knowledge about SF,their deployments and training and then you would understand.
As said, MARCOS and GARUDs even now are actively deployed in Africa and near by regions.
Garuds are a slightly different bunch, their first leg of training of 72 weeks is basic infantry training, at this stage a Garud's skill level is similar to that a hardened infantry man. A Garud during this phase still has about 3 more years of training before they are fully labeled a SF operative. So if your friend came across a few Garuds who weren't impressive, don't worry they'd be weeded out by the time their training is done. Just as a Para SF probie needs many more years of training to be a true SF operative.
So what if all Marcos don't go to HAWS, it is not their mandate, they only need a few platoons trained in these areas, Last we checked the naval war is to be fought along enemy coastlines which are quite far away from the Northern, Eastern and Northwestern frontiers.
Also your silliness shows when you say that Para SF train for deployment but Garuds and Marcos train for skill. MARCOS almost goes out everyday even in known anti piracy ops. They are also active in Kashmir. Garuds will also be part of ops in Kashmir which will do them good. Para SF is a Tier-1 formidable force and off course they wrote the handbook as far as Indian SF is concerned but to disrespect the sacrifice made by the Garud who lost his life fighting till his last breath the pigs at Pathankot. Garuds are also quite busy with anti-naxal ops, they don't do the killing but they have done many a hot extraction of wounded men. Also by dismissing these men to a second rate breed; you dismiss the training imparted to them by Para SF, SG, NSG instructors.
Why do you imagine that Garuds and Marcos are just sitting around pulling lice out of each other's hair? They train, when they are not training they are rotated.
When it's time to kill, a bullet from an experienced operator is just as likely to kill as that from a ragtag militia pig.