India-China 2020 Border Dispute - Military and Strategic Discussion

[Shashank Nayak]

There is a premium on old farts trying to create panic for more eyeballs.. Gurkhas in PLA, will be for livlihood. .no big deal.. but talking about China Nepal defense treaty, as a done deal.. comeon.. there will be no Nepal..

 

[Shashank Nayak]

This old fart's twitter page looks like he is into conspiracy theories big time.. and whats this stereotyping: Chinese are weak in mountain warfare.. ? Its the training at places like HAWS that makes mountain warriors.. Noone is born a mountain warrior from his mother's womb.. Trying pitting an Indian Army Gorkha battalion against a Nepali trained one..

 

[Jay99]

This is very worrying ...

India's response is dialogue

 

[prasadr14]

I would rather you lot go easy on Rajiv malhotra.
This guy has done incredible service to Hindu cause...Any lapses must be forgiven without a mention.
He earned it.

 

[Sanglamorre]

Worrying as in script provided by chinese and being towed by their commie slaves,
This first of all us is false and even if true how much soldiers are chinese going to hire and train and equip to make a difference in their supposed weakened mountain warfare capability? A few dozen or a few hundred or maybe a few thousand?


Errrr sirjee the world seen through red glasses appear red to hired red help from all over, red tricks are long known.

China isn't going to import soldiers from another country due to the simple fact that all Chinese are required to enlist, which means they'll come on contact with a people with a much freer system and inculcate those ideas and go spread it after returning to civilian life after just few years.

Secondly, China runs on the China stlong agitprop, hiring foreign soldiers is admitting they're weak.

 

[Aegis888]

Rajiv Malhotra is a learned person in case of Hindu Identity. But i sincerely doubt his foreign policy expertise.
But if true than IFS officers, in charge of Nepal desk should be castrated.

 

[kaaleshwaar]

Not easy to do proclamation of emergency. After 1 month of prolcamation, A resolution must be passed by either House of Parliament only by a majority of the total membership of that House and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the Members of that House present and voting.

Modi dont have numbers in RS as of now. But after November he, NDA, will have Majority in Rajya sabha (122 seats). I am assuming nothing will move till then.
LOK sabha no problem
RS have to wait till Nov this year.

Have heard of rs majority coming soon multiple times in 2018 and 2019 as well, when the hell is it actually going to happen?

 

[cereal killer]

India's response is dialogue

lol how come they'll do this. If India stops pensions of Ex Gorkha soldiers, Nepal will be crying loud. I think if anything Nepal ever decides to do Anti India stuff then blood fill start to flow in Kathmandu streets. We don't even need our Army to do the job. Madhesis coupled with Bihari Bros with Arms supplied can wreck Havoc in Nepal. I hope better sense prevails.

 

[SimplyIndian]

Have heard of rs majority coming soon multiple times in 2018 and 2019 as well, when the hell is it actually going to happen?

25-Nov-2020 to be specific. NDA will have 121 Seats out of 241 ( 4 vacant). Majority is 121.

 

[Lancer]

This is very worrying ...

I had a silent fear they might do something like this after someone in the Nepal Gvt said they were re-examining the agreement under which Gurkhas serve in the Indian Army.

 

[Assassin 2.0]

lol how come they'll do this. If India stops pensions of Ex Gorkha soldiers, Nepal will be crying loud. I think if anything Nepal ever decides to do Anti India stuff then blood fill start to flow in Kathmandu streets. We don't even need our Army to do the job. Madhesis coupled with Bihari Bros with Arms supplied can wreck Havoc in Nepal. I hope better sense prevails.

India and Nepal both are hindu countries. Our goal should be wiping away communism not wiping Hindu population in Nepal those kiddies which are trolling india and bad mouthing us are nothing more than jingoism followers. Communist flesh needs to be snatched.
We need to see that whether ex Gurkha soldiers are pro india or not? If they are pro india we should not stop the pension and technically sayin our win will be defeating Chinese in Nepal and by launching a idiotic assault on Nepalese will make people even more pro China.
For now

 

[Flying Dagger]

On flip side it does take way chances of apps like chingari becoming popular. With MS buying Tiktok GOI will get unblock it. Long term apps like Chingari wont be able to compete with big players like MS. You have to maintain servers availability, keep providing new features to keep youngsters addicted to platform and attract advertisers. I am batting for MS buy failing, e-NREGA people need to find new job on chingari

Apparently RELIANCE IS IN THE PLAY TOO.

I really hope no one buys it and it just get it's natural death.

Buying off will mean billions of dollar going to chinkis and still potential risk unless overhauled completely.

The drawback is Indian platform don't have catchy names or govt backing which is really needed.

They should identify some good apps create a talent pool and let the developers improve on those selected app under an umbrella provided by gov. In the beginning and let them expand organically throughout world.

Now another downside is all the data centers of these websites are rented ones in foreign country.

Here Reliance needs to pitch in fast.

 

[nick_indian]

Salami slicing in response to salami slicing isa valid option. Otherwise they'd keep doing this mini aggressions and we'll box ourselves in this trap whils the land they take keeps getting bigger.

Salami Slicing is a good idea. We should have done this in May itself. Entered and taken over some other grey zone and then negotiate using it as a bargaining chip. But I guess it's too late for that now. This doesn't merit a full fledged attack on their forces, is what I believe.

 

[Sehwag213]

Salami Slicing is a good idea. We should have done this in May itself. Entered and taken over some other grey zone and then negotiate using it as a bargaining chip. But I guess it's too late for that now. This doesn't merit a full fledged attack on their forces, is what I believe.

Do you really need artillery, tanks and fighter aircraft for salami slicing?
Then this salami slicing has gone extremely wrong for them because this would result in
1. Short war
2. Counter salami slicing from India
3. Near permanent deployment at LAC which neither side wants.

 

[Flying Dagger]

India and Nepal both are hindu countries. Our goal should be wiping away communism not wiping Hindu population in Nepal those kiddies which are trolling india and bad mouthing us are nothing more than jingoism followers. Communist flesh needs to be snatched.
We need to see that whether ex Gurkha soldiers are pro india or not? If they are pro india we should not stop the pension and technically sayin our win will be defeating Chinese in Nepal and by launching a idiotic assault on Nepalese will make people even more pro China.
For now View attachment 56227

Actually we made a mistake by going against the royals during UPA and Atal's time .

Our OFB and its products aided the downfall in military relation.

Not supplying them ammunition etc was the sickest move similar to what we complain abt western world .

They procured 25k rifles from us and have almost dumped them all into reserves etc now.

That is psychologically we proved ourselves weak repeatedly .

Nepal has a long history of being a slave to China in 19th century we could have exploit that through our tv media etc. But instead Indian media went over there mocked them threatened them pretended to be Demi god and resulted in more negative publicity for us.

And these weren't done without purpose but were definitely a planned move who wanted to sabotage the relation.

China may not hire Gurkhas but if they do our first reaction should be to mock them worldwide through media movies etc abt how inferior they are to Nepalese.

What I am saying is pretty simple things that other nation do but we don't.

These things aren't possible until the gov take a hold of what is happening inside India.

 

[Flying Dagger]

That Old fart has done more for the service of this nation than smelly fart like you.

Before name-calling him look where you stand against him or atleast try to know abt him first.

This old fart's twitter page looks like he is into conspiracy theories big time.. and whats this stereotyping: Chinese are weak in mountain warfare.. ? Its the training at places like HAWS that makes mountain warriors.. Noone is born a mountain warrior from his mother's womb.. Trying pitting an Indian Army Gorkha battalion against a Nepali trained one..

 

[nick_indian]

Actually we made a mistake by going against the royals during UPA and Atal's time .

Our OFB and its products aided the downfall in military relation.

Not supplying them ammunition etc was the sickest move similar to what we complain abt western world .

They procured 25k rifles from us and have almost dumped them all into reserves etc now.

That is psychologically we proved ourselves weak repeatedly .

Nepal has a long history of being a slave to China in 19th century we could have exploit that through our tv media etc. But instead Indian media went over there mocked them threatened them pretended to be Demi god and resulted in more negative publicity for us.

And these weren't done without purpose but were definitely a planned move who wanted to sabotage the relation.

China may not hire Gurkhas but if they do our first reaction should be to mock them worldwide through media movies etc abt how inferior they are to Nepalese.

What I am saying is pretty simple things that other nation do but we don't.

These things aren't possible until the gov take a hold of what is happening inside India.

We should make a high budget movie glorifying the Gorkhas. Sounds like a good idea to gain some favour amongst the Gorkhas

 

[Sanglamorre]

We should make a high budget movie glorifying the Gorkhas. Sounds like a good idea to gain some favour amongst the Gorkhas

The crux of the problem is that hill tribes, whether NE India or Nepal have a superiority complex arising from is martial races ideology. The tirades against India aren't India specific, it's also against their own plains-men, the Madhesis.

Making movies like this will only exacerbate the problem.

 

[ezsasa]

We should make a high budget movie glorifying the Gorkhas. Sounds like a good idea to gain some favour amongst the Gorkhas

Col. Lalit rai & Gorkha rifles during Kargil war in Batalik sector , there is a movie to be made here. pure war film without drama would be nice.

Script is ready, his speech on Batalik sector has all the details needed for a movie script.

 

[nick_indian]

Col. Lalit rai & Gorkha rifles during Kargil war in Batalik sector , there is a movie to be made here. pure war film without drama would be nice.

Script is ready, his speech on Batalik sector has all the details needed for a movie script.

Has to be a high budget masala drama Bollywood film like Border.

A good artsy film won't get much popularity amongst Indian masses or Nepalis.