DRDO, PSU and Private Defence Sector News

Azaad

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2022
Messages
7,361
Likes
27,605
Country flag
$hit happens, don't go about extrapolating to infer that the whole system is crap.
in real world conditions, they won't send one, they send more than one to minimise this risk.
What a Hi IQ response to a < 82 IQ question !! Been on the forum for 2 yrs yet doesn't know basic protocol of ADS in such situations.
 

karn

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
3,674
Likes
15,637
Country flag
*theory* . Fuse failures are more common cause live fire trials are done less frequently as compared to simulated targets ..
This is not limited to our case .
Fuse / warhead detonation failures have happened in many shooting wars .. Falklands war many exocet missiles did not explode .. Most of the Argentinian bombs did not explode cause of a safety feature .
As far back as ww2 US torpedoes where multiple hits were recorded without detonation of the warhead.
Hopefully laser proximity fuses in astra have solved this issue but can't tell for sure.
 

patriots

Defense lover
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2017
Messages
5,687
Likes
21,760
Country flag
Till now gagan Shakti is not exciting

Only helina and Samar ad are 2 new system s fired


1. Tejas fired r73 like last gagan Shakti
2. Alh rudra fired 70 mm rockets like last gagan Shakti
3. Akash fired like last gagan Shakti


No mrsam , Spyder firing

No helina firing
No , python v or asraam ,firing
 

jai jaganath

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2022
Messages
5,574
Likes
9,675
Country flag

Two R73 fuse failures on the day 🤔?
This should make us think how can r-73 be effective against drones
Coz samar systems were essentially made for anti drone purpose although they are using missiles of retired aircrafts which have enough shelf life
But ig these things are beyond the mental capacity of other dimwit(IQ<50) members of the forum
 

karn

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
3,674
Likes
15,637
Country flag
Till now gagan Shakti is not exciting

Only helina and Samar ad are 2 new system s fired


1. Tejas fired r73 like last gagan Shakti
2. Alh rudra fired 70 mm rockets like last gagan Shakti
3. Akash fired like last gagan Shakti


No mrsam , Spyder firing

No helina firing
No , python v or asraam ,firing
Any helina firing video?
 

Narasimh

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2016
Messages
1,089
Likes
3,757
Country flag
This should make us think how can r-73 be effective against drones
Coz samar systems were essentially made for anti drone purpose although they are using missiles of retired aircrafts which have enough shelf life
But ig these things are beyond the mental capacity of other dimwit(IQ<50) members of the forum
R-73 is a 80s design with little upgrades.. It is not designed to target small drones since inception.. it cannot and should not be thought of as a drone hard kill system. Also it is way more expensive than the things they will shoot down.. Airforce showcases Samar as an in-house innovation item but when it comes to drones it does not fit, we need cheaper and effective solution
 

jai jaganath

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2022
Messages
5,574
Likes
9,675
Country flag
R-73 is a 80s design with little upgrades.. It is not designed to target small drones since inception.. it cannot and should not be thought of as a drone hard kill system. Also it is way more expensive than the things they will shoot down.. Airforce showcases Samar as an in-house innovation item but when it comes to drones it does not fit, we need cheaper and effective solution
Yeah
But I remember few journalists quoting military said these are specifically made for anti drone purpose likes of tb-2 and shahed
That's why air force has to rethink wrt it
And obviously these are air to air missiles so they are costly but their aircrafts have been retired and they have some shelf life too
But during rehearsal samar system did hit the target
So we have to wait for some more info on why both(tejas and samar) the r73 failed yesterday
 

Covfefe

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2021
Messages
4,041
Likes
27,596
Country flag
To the serious enthusiasts on the forum-

Is there any sub-assembly level quality testing protocol that's available? Like the seeker assembly is working as intended? Asking, more specifically for imported missiles like R73s and Meteors
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top