FireStar
New Member
- Joined
- May 31, 2022
- Messages
- 201
- Likes
- 295
Will there be no FCR for AA gun in the case of IA?
Last year, in a similar requirement, Indian private defence conglomerate Larsen & Toubro emerged as the L1 (lowest bidder) for the Indian Air Force contract for about 240 air defence gun systems.
In this case, the indigenous air defence system also required a full-fledged air defence system which included the search radar to track radar with fire controls command control and electro-optics.
While the air defence guns for the IAF were a more complex system with two radars, the new RFP for the Indian army is rather simpler without radar.
Last year, in a similar requirement, Indian private defence conglomerate Larsen & Toubro emerged as the L1 (lowest bidder) for the Indian Air Force contract for about 240 air defence gun systems.
In this case, the indigenous air defence system also required a full-fledged air defence system which included the search radar to track radar with fire controls command control and electro-optics.
While the air defence guns for the IAF were a more complex system with two radars, the new RFP for the Indian army is rather simpler without radar.
Thanks for showing the example of the soft spot some members have for Defence PSUs on this forum.This project is a total failure of HAL. Indian AF has also bought Hawks which nobody has objected.
Nobody criticises UN generals without any reason.
There was time when HAL was criticised for all wrong reasons but PSUs has improved significantly but Armed forces remain the same.
UN Generals are like Indian judiciary who criticise others day and night but can’t see dirt on their face.
Similarly we can ask what is your opinion on following?
1) endless trials or Indigenous weapons?
2) where is order to LCH, ATAGs, LUH, Nag, SRSAM, many others?
3) Why armed forces come with New RFI when indigenous products reach maturity
4) Years of Negative propaganda for Tejas, Arjun,
5) rejected Arjun on grounds that IA do not have supporting bridges in Punjab. Didn’t IA know this fact when Arjun was built?
6) Buying foreign weapons in 5-10 numbers
7) Changing goal posts in mid way
8) why foreign weapons complete trials within 2-3 months without hu-halla.?
Please understand PSUs are companies but Armed forces are institutions. Armed forces are responsible for countries security so need to behave more sincerity rather behaving arrogantly.
Indigenisation is the key for country’s defence and independent foreign policy but our armed forces led us just in opposite direction.
Armed Forces =/= UN Genrols. There are bad apples and corrupt babus in every sector, defense included.Nobody criticises UN generals without any reason.
Armed forces have improved, or shall I say, forced to improve after 2014. Good, aatmanirbhartha supporting leaders were chosen as CDS and Chief of respective branches of Armed Forces.There was time when HAL was criticised for all wrong reasons but PSUs has improved significantly but Armed forces remain the same.
DRDO : Post firing target damage assessment capability. Combustible cartridge & proximity/programmable fuze based ammo. Digitally operated & all electric drive & actuation. EO/IR & radar based target detection & tracking. AI based autonomous target engagement. Camouflage, concealment, firing signature management. Detection avoidance & stealth operation. Multi role operation using same or different ammo. Capable of 360° traverse. Thermal management. Sensor to shooter logic. Revolving feed & firing management, misfire management
IMO, this will be the likely offering from the AWEIL.
Sounds more like a wet dream, if you ask me. I mean, do you seriously believe DRDO can pull off even half of that Wishlist??DRDO : Post firing target damage assessment capability. Combustible cartridge & proximity/programmable fuze based ammo. Digitally operated & all electric drive & actuation. EO/IR & radar based target detection & tracking. AI based autonomous target engagement. Camouflage, concealment, firing signature management. Detection avoidance & stealth operation. Multi role operation using same or different ammo. Capable of 360° traverse. Thermal management. Sensor to shooter logic. Revolving feed & firing management, misfire management
मैं इस संज्ञान में माननीय न्यालय का ध्यान पृष्ट संख्या २५३००१३ की ओर आकृष्ट करना चाहूंगाSounds more like a wet dream, if you ask me. I mean, do you seriously believe DRDO can pull off even half of that Wishlist??
> No prior experience in any kind of auto-cannon R&D let alone Gatling
> No prior experience in gun fired proximity fuze let alone miniaturizing it enough for 20-30mm
> No prior experience in programming while firing rounds let alone doing it when the RPM is extremely high; coz Gatling
> No prior experience in combustible cartridge for small arms let alone making one for such a high rate of fire weapon where chamber temperature will cause cook-offs
> God knows what they mean by camouflage, concealment, firing signature management on a 20-30mm Gatling gun
> Just like everyone is now throwing around AI because of ChatGPT so...AI based autonomous target engagement
> What kind of unique capability is this post firing target damage assessment capability?
In short
Phavda, great nameOur country has too many exfarts :
Be it Chawda or Phavda...end of the day it rhymes best with just one very specific wordPhavda, great name
Na pata
@Lonewarrior kia he ye ?
needs an Instagram boom sound effect tooOur country has too many exfarts :
Oh I just realised it rhymes with " la*da" , an informal word for male phallus used in various North Indian languages.Be it Chawda or Phavda...end of the day it rhymes best with just one very specific word