LCA TEJAS MK1 & MK1A: News and Discussion

sakalasiva

New Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2020
Messages
58
Likes
115
Country flag
SH never flown from an operational STOBAR carrier. Rafale-M can't even fold its wings. Both are experimental w.r.t. INS Vikrant.
MiG-29K was something IN paid to develop, meaning it was an experimental aircraft when it was purchased by IN. Same with Su-30MKI that didn't have canards when IAF asked for it and bought it.
This nonsense about "experimental designs" is unwarranted. Malaysians are free to go for MiG-29 if they want "operational aircraft only".
.
None of the offerings that fit Malaysian requirements are "finished products". Deal with it. We don't got to put down Tejas because its not "finished". Currently, its far more mature than the FA-50.
Why everyone forgetting the fact that kickbacks by defence lobbies for defence orders. Since HAL is a public sector company they can't indulge in kickbacks. Only practical reason I see for selecting fa50 over Tejas which is superior than fa50 in any count. One other reason may be cheap Price if news is true that price is 3.2 million than Tejas which is offered for 3.7 million.
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
Why everyone forgetting the fact that kickbacks by defence lobbies for defence orders. Since HAL is a public sector company they can't indulge in kickbacks. Only practical reason I see for selecting fa50 over Tejas which is superior than fa50 in any count. One other reason may be cheap Price if news is true that price is 3.2 million than Tejas which is offered for 3.7 million.
The defence industry is notoriously dirty the world over but let’s not get hung up on that.

RMAF asked for a LIFT, KAI offered them a LIFT, it’s really not shocking that they won. In the Indian context the outcome would be the same because of the L1 model.

If you are shocked it’s because you let yourself believe reports from the Indian media that LCA was in the lead based on ‘anonymous sources’. You shouldn’t even trust the Indian media to tell you the time of day is and whatever they say is usually the exact opposite to reality.

LCA was always the outsider for RMAF and so it transpired. No shame in trying and I’m sure that HAL gained experience from competing, that said I’m 100% convinced LCA won’t be exported unless it’s a GTG deal. India just doesn’t take defence exports seriously and this industry is almost solely backed by national lobbying. That the Koreans are more successful defence exporters than India tells you how seriously GoI is at this game
 

Okabe Rintarou

New Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
2,338
Likes
11,996
Country flag
The defence industry is notoriously dirty the world over but let’s not get hung up on that.

RMAF asked for a LIFT, KAI offered them a LIFT, it’s really not shocking that they won. In the Indian context the outcome would be the same because of the L1 model.

If you are shocked it’s because you let yourself believe reports from the Indian media that LCA was in the lead based on ‘anonymous sources’. You shouldn’t even trust the Indian media to tell you the time of day is and whatever they say is usually the exact opposite to reality.

LCA was always the outsider for RMAF and so it transpired. No shame in trying and I’m sure that HAL gained experience from competing, that said I’m 100% convinced LCA won’t be exported unless it’s a GTG deal. India just doesn’t take defence exports seriously and this industry is almost solely backed by national lobbying. That the Koreans are more successful defence exporters than India tells you how seriously GoI is at this game
Are you John Titor?



How else could you have known that Tejas has lost to FA-50 in Malaysian jet deal? Nobody on Earth knows that yet!
 

abingdonboy

New Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,084
Likes
33,803
Country flag
Are you John Titor?



How else could you have known that Tejas has lost to FA-50 in Malaysian jet deal? Nobody on Earth knows that yet!
If Korean media are reporting it then I’ll take their world for it.

like I said, LCA was always the underdog in this context, it’s massively over spec’d for what RMAF wanted, if it comes down to a L1 decision how could LCA ever hope to win?

LCA has a chance only for countries that want an actual combat platform
 

Okabe Rintarou

New Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2018
Messages
2,338
Likes
11,996
Country flag
If Korean media are reporting it then I’ll take their world for it.

like I said, LCA was always the underdog in this context, it’s massively over spec’d for what RMAF wanted, if it comes down to a L1 decision how could LCA ever hope to win?

LCA has a chance only for countries that want an actual combat platform
I agree that Tejas is the underdog here, but I don't trust the Koreans reporting it. SoKo has corruption even at its highest echelons. Why would its media be trustworthy?
 

Anibesh acharya

New Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2022
Messages
145
Likes
928
If Korean media are reporting it then I’ll take their world for it.

like I said, LCA was always the underdog in this context, it’s massively over spec’d for what RMAF wanted, if it comes down to a L1 decision how could LCA ever hope to win?

LCA has a chance only for countries that want an actual combat platform
How tejas looses in L1 decision . Is not T50 deal more expensive ? Korean deal is RM 4.2 billion , tejas RM 3.75 billion .
 

omaebakabaka

New Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
4,945
Likes
13,835
SH never flown from an operational STOBAR carrier. Rafale-M can't even fold its wings. Both are experimental w.r.t. INS Vikrant.
MiG-29K was something IN paid to develop, meaning it was an experimental aircraft when it was purchased by IN. Same with Su-30MKI that didn't have canards when IAF asked for it and bought it.
This nonsense about "experimental designs" is unwarranted. Malaysians are free to go for MiG-29 if they want "operational aircraft only".
.
None of the offerings that fit Malaysian requirements are "finished products". Deal with it. We don't got to put down Tejas because its not "finished". Currently, its far more mature than the FA-50.
Not that almost impossible odds don't get realized as they happen more frequently but to be honest we are not US or Russia or France to get the benefit of doubt. We do not have legacy in making or selling aircraft especially fighters. So if I were the customer I would think twice but if priced correctly then I may give it a shot depending on how important reliability is for me. Some things are not quantifiable as you make your decisions based on established presence and brand value.....very hard to break into new markets especially with new products. with no presence in that field. HAL is correct in trying regardless of result as it gives a good boost.

Tejas line is on the cusp of breaking out putting us into a small league countries and hopefully our traitors don't sabotage the program or its followups.
 

LondonParisTokyo

New Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,971
Likes
8,238
Country flag
Yeah bro Brazil does it but they don't make any 4+ or 4.5 gen aircrafts which us way more critical than transport planes and ground attack planes
Expecting export when u r competing fa-50 is not bad as its far more superior than it if decision going other way round either they are being offered better kickbacks or better foreign policy than us
How many 3 generation planes does India make lol
 

LondonParisTokyo

New Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,971
Likes
8,238
Country flag
India makes 4+ that's good enough
India makes 4+ generation? Which plane? How many squadrons of Mk1A have been ordered? There's not even a full squadron of Mk1A and people are clamoring for Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, AMCA, BMCA, ChamchaCA lol. I'm trying to put in a dose of realism here but people are way too idealistic about it.
 

NoobWannaLearn

New Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
8,978
Likes
29,244
Country flag
India makes 4+ generation? Which plane? How many squadrons of Mk1A have been ordered? There's not even a full squadron of Mk1A and people are clamoring for Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, AMCA, BMCA, ChamchaCA lol. I'm trying to put in a dose of realism here but people are way too idealistic about it.
2 mk1 squadron already in service
And 73 mk1a on order now pls stop crying like a Lil bitch
 

Super Flanker

Aviation and Defence Enthusiast
New Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2021
Messages
5,106
Likes
12,244
Country flag
There's two squadrons of Mk1 that are in what airbases? Sulur, far from any potential combat zone. Replaced the MiG21 all the way in Tamil Nadu, yet the combat zones on the border are still with Mig21s.
Currently there are two squadrons of Tejas Mk-1, Flying Daggers and Flying Bullets. Squadron flying daggers is based at Sulur AFS, Tamil Nadu. Not sure about Flying Bullets, I think so that it too is stationed in Sulur but I will have to confirm further later on.
It's seriously embarrassing. And I don't know how to make it any clearer. I have a product I want to sell you. It will do your job better, hell it can do my job better, but I'm not using it. Why aren't I using it? I don't want to tell you, but it can do your job better than anything else on the market, just trust me.
Coming to Tejas being deployed near a potential Combat zone then there were reports dating back to August of 2020 which said that Tejas was deployed on the border with Pakistan. You cab search up the articles. All this will change with Tejas MK-1A, they will definitely deploy it more frequently near the border areas in my POV when Tejas MK-1A arrives. Also this year itself Squadron Flying Daggers was reportedly moved to the LAC Border in order to tackle the scrambles of Chinese Jets.
It's seriously embarrassing man. I've been following the Tejas saga since 2008 from Bharat Rakshak. It feels like in 14 years, literally nothing has changed except a few planes made here-and-there. Now people want to "be prod" of exporting it when there's hardly any domestic squadrons? It's a joke.
In what Way is it embarrassing? A lot has changed in Tejas program over these years, now Tejas MK-1A will be coming to numbers of more than 80+. See the Developments of Tejas post 2015, you will see how the much foreward the program has come today.
 

LondonParisTokyo

New Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,971
Likes
8,238
Country flag
Currently there are two squadrons of Tejas Mk-1, Flying Daggers and Flying Bullets. Squadron flying daggers is based at Sulur AFS, Tamil Nadu. Not sure about Flying Bullets, I think so that it too is stationed in Sulur but I will have to confirm further later on.

Coming to Tejas being deployed near a potential Combat zone then there were reports dating back to August of 2020 which said that Tejas was deployed on the border with Pakistan. You cab search up the articles. All this will change with Tejas MK-1A, they will definitely deploy it more frequently near the border areas in my POV when Tejas MK-1A arrives. Also this year itself Squadron Flying Daggers was reportedly moved to the LAC Border in order to tackle the scrambles of Chinese Jets.

In what Way is it embarrassing? A lot has changed in Tejas program over these years, now Tejas MK-1A will be coming to numbers of more than 80+. See the Developments of Tejas post 2015, you will see how the much foreward the program has come today.
Mk1A has been in production for 0 months. Literally the first test flight occurred 3 months ago (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_Tejas#Tejas_Mark_1A). People are excited about the plane being exported when India isn't even mass producing it for itself. You people are entirely missing the point. How far is Sulur from a combat zone? Any Tejas will need to be refueled before it can be deployed on the front line so what then, is the purpose of stationing it so far away? Just think it through
 

LondonParisTokyo

New Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2015
Messages
2,971
Likes
8,238
Country flag
2 mk1 squadron already in service
And 73 mk1a on order now pls stop crying like a Lil bitch
Lol. You and I both know how long it will be before a single Mk1A enters "FOC". Probably another decade at least, and by then people will be clamoring for ChamchawallahMCA, a 20++++ generation plane lol. Reality bites, you will catch up soon.
 

NoobWannaLearn

New Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
8,978
Likes
29,244
Country flag
Lol. You and I both know how long it will be before a single Mk1A enters "FOC". Probably another decade at least, and by then people will be clamoring for ChamchawallahMCA, a 20++++ generation plane lol. Reality bites, you will catch up soon.
First you say we haven't made 4 gen plane then when guys give you proof you start singing another tone.

bc-ajeeb-chutiya.jpg
 

Super Flanker

Aviation and Defence Enthusiast
New Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2021
Messages
5,106
Likes
12,244
Country flag
Mk1A has been in production for 0 months. Literally the first test flight occurred 3 months ago (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_Tejas#Tejas_Mark_1A).
Tejas Mk-A will start it's production from 2024 onwards, after which all the Mk-1As will be delivered to the Indian Airforce before 2029-30.
People are excited about the plane being exported when India isn't even mass producing it for itself
What exactly is your Definition of mass production? Like a large number? Like what type of quantity? 40 Tejas mk-1 already in service with the 83 Mk-1A on order come to a total of 123 Tejas. Isn't that a large enough number for you? By the way you don't simply mass produce something. You do it depending on the order given to me you.
You people are entirely missing the point.
Which point of yours am I missing? Please elaborate.
How far is Sulur from a combat zone? Any Tejas will need to be refueled before it can be deployed on the front line so what then, is the purpose of stationing it so far away? Just think it through
Tejas is an LCA, and it is meant as a point defence fighter as far as I know. By the way how many Tejas have achieved FOC and how many have achieved IOC? You will get your answer in my opinion.
 

skunk works

New Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2022
Messages
1,955
Likes
9,139
Country flag
Why everyone forgetting the fact that kickbacks by defence lobbies for defence orders. Since HAL is a public sector company they can't indulge in kickbacks. Only practical reason I see for selecting fa50 over Tejas which is superior than fa50 in any count. One other reason may be cheap Price if news is true that price is 3.2 million than Tejas which is offered for 3.7 million.
A lot of western defense companies that indulge in kickbacks are atleast partly state owned (see: Westland Affair) so this is not an excuse for losing the contract.
HAL, the government of India, or LCA subcontractors were not born yesterday.
 

omaebakabaka

New Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
4,945
Likes
13,835
A lot of western defense companies that indulge in kickbacks are atleast partly state owned (see: Westland Affair) so this is not an excuse for losing the contract.
HAL, the government of India, or LCA subcontractors were not born yesterday.
GOI and corruption lol...biggest hoarders of black money on the planet probably are/were politicians and businessmen from India. Money alone doesn't pull the strings in every case.
 

omaebakabaka

New Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
4,945
Likes
13,835
Lol. You and I both know how long it will be before a single Mk1A enters "FOC". Probably another decade at least, and by then people will be clamoring for ChamchawallahMCA, a 20++++ generation plane lol. Reality bites, you will catch up soon.
I am not sure what juice you are drinking but Tejas is well received and deployed in Sulur does not mean it is not fit for combat. May be base logistics are not ready and may be they want to wait till the 1a....you are being ludicrous. Aircraft is actively taking part in airshows around the world. That's the whole point of having domestic one, you can choose to pace the deployment optimally assuming lobbyists influence can't reach the RM and PM, COAS level
 

Articles

Top