Indian Special Forces (archived)

Status
Not open for further replies.

rkhanna

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2014
Messages
3,274
Likes
12,187
Country flag
These SFs never send their top notch operators or gear for such exercises.
Correct. the Americans treat us today as an FID force as part of a diplomatic strategy. We are not a partner force. Though the quality of operators are the same. There is no ranking of operators within units. And the Americans are not sending National guard SF units but SOCOM units.


Partner force will be built up to operate alongside them in the future. The orientation of those exercises are different.
 

avknight1408

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2015
Messages
1,099
Likes
5,014
Country flag
Not sure about that, but SAG, SRG & SCG all of them are getting MPX in limited numbers as of now. NSG 2019-20 procurement plan has additional MP5 & it's accessories mentioned. So I doubt the replacement.
Just curious. Now that NSG is withdrawn from VVIP protection, what will happen to SRG?
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,118
Likes
17,834
Country flag
Correct. the Americans treat us today as an FID force as part of a diplomatic strategy. We are not a partner force. Though the quality of operators are the same. There is no ranking of operators within units. And the Americans are not sending National guard SF units but SOCOM units.


Partner force will be built up to operate alongside them in the future. The orientation of those exercises are different.
Thats true but i am talking about the rank of officers and their experience plus the gear they bring which is nothing.

Most of the times our SF is training with their airborne infantry.
 

ALBY

Section Moderator
Mod
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,570
Likes
6,921
Country flag
Thats true but i am talking about the rank of officers and their experience plus the gear they bring which is nothing.

Most of the times our SF is training with their airborne infantry.
Eg:para SF training with VDV when Russia have a dozen Spetsnaz units of various tiers like Alfa, Vympel, Gru, MVD, Omon, SSO🤦‍♀️
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,118
Likes
17,834
Country flag
Eg:para SF training with VDV when Russia have a dozen Spetsnaz units of various tiers like Alfa, Vympel, Gru, MVD, Omon, SSO🤦‍♀️
despite being the closest allies we have never trained with Spetsnaz..thats the attitude of foreign sf.

We are too infantry with our brain sometimes i think.

Anyway i really liked Indonesian SF training with 9..Both are the best in their country.
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,039
Likes
33,588
Country flag
I was going through live insta videos of these former Para/SF operatives.When Major Nirmith asks them whatbare the equipment deficiencies faced by our SF eveyone says our SF dont have any and are on par with the western ones.Is it we the arm chair generals only aware of the inadequacies or our officers and men not aware of the developments happening around the world 😝😋
yeah that was embarrassing and shows how insular these guys can be when all they have ever seen is the fauj

I would hope it’s just a generational thing considering that he was commissioned in the 90s so grew up in a very different India/world. The officers coming up now will likely have far more exposure to the equipment and tactics of their contemporaries thanks to widespread access video games and entertainment from the West.


+Interesting tidbits about the conversion of 4 PARA into a SF battalion and confirms what I’ve been saying on the matter for years- it wasn’t a simple re-badging ceremony, all the PARA members had to re-qualify as SF operators and there was quite a bit of washout as a result.

Correct. the Americans treat us today as an FID force as part of a diplomatic strategy. We are not a partner force. Though the quality of operators are the same. There is no ranking of operators within units. And the Americans are not sending National guard SF units but SOCOM units.


Partner force will be built up to operate alongside them in the future. The orientation of those exercises are different.
Exactly this, they treat it as a FID mission and treat Indian SF as a local force like Afghans or Iraqis that need training up

if you listen to American SFs who have done FID deployments they don’t hide the fact that they keep most of their high end stuff at home and focus on the basics.

when you see Vajra Prahar you can notice this for yourself- basic room clearing, some static shooting drills and maybe a joint ex is as much as they do- it’s not highly complex high value missions that you see them doing with Partner nations. It’s basically just a diplomatic box ticking ex, not much more than an army equivalent of a PASSEX. There’s not a whole lot of cross pollination going on
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,039
Likes
33,588
Country flag
Eg:para SF training with VDV when Russia have a dozen Spetsnaz units of various tiers like Alfa, Vympel, Gru, MVD, Omon, SSO🤦‍♀️
MARCOs training with USN VBSS teams, Royal Marines and Russian marines

Garuds training with RAF regiment

bizarre that Indian leadership is willing to keep sending its SF teams to operate alongside non-SF units from foreign countries


despite being the closest allies we have never trained with Spetsnaz..thats the attitude of foreign sf.
.
There are actually pictures of SPETSNAZ in India in the 80s but there’s not much indication of this in recent times. Certainly it hasn’t happened since the Russian SFs got their slew of equipment upgrades

+ US SFOD-D (CAG) has trained with Indian units but it’s unclear which, my guess would be SG
 

ALBY

Section Moderator
Mod
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,570
Likes
6,921
Country flag
My Story: 'After Half An Hour Of Unconsciousness, I Led An Assault On Zulu Top And Defeated The Enemy In Kargil War'
On Kargil Vijay Diwas, Major Prince Jose shares his unforgettable experiences after being tasked to plan a special mission to cut the enemy lines of maintenance during the 1999 Kargil War.

https://thelogicalindian.com/amp/my-story/kargil-vijay-diwas-22556
 

ALBY

Section Moderator
Mod
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,570
Likes
6,921
Country flag
Found the following transcript from a decade old post from BR archives posted by some Gaurav.Thought it was worth sharing.
"Had another interaction with a former PARA SF personnel whom I had mentioned earlier.
Some interesting observations that I think are OK to share.

Regarding 3 months probation:
He said that it was enough. He says it is not as if the volunteer goes for 3 months probation and the training gets any less afterwards. Even after the 3 months, the physical training remains of the same level for the rest of the time he spends in SF. The volunteer knows it. So, if he feels that he will not be able to endure this for years, he will quit himself (there are such cases). And even if the volunteer somehow clears the probation but it is felt that he is not able to keep his fitness..say after 8 months..he will be sent back his parent regiment. But this rarely happens as the guy who is able to endure the probation for 3 months generally gets into the rhythm and acquires the fitness to carry on. So, there is lowering of standards on that count. PARA units do not compromise on that.

Regarding conversion of PARA to PARA SF without Govt sanction
He says this is impossible. This is army and everything (specially this big) has to be done according to the procedure and through the proper channels. He says that it is very likely that the rest of PARA battalions will also be converted to SF but it is impossible that it will be done without proper approval.

Regarding lowering of standards when converting PARA to PARA SF:
He says that is not the case. He says that there is no difference b/n the physical fitness of PARA and PARA SF. There is a small difference of course. Some courses are not available to PARA (I think he mentioned Combat diving as one such course, but I am not 100% sure). Also, there is a small difference in equipment. But in his opinion, this is a very good decision. He says that some SF personnel feel superior to non SF and may say that there is a difference, but it is not the case (note that the person is from SF himself).

More regarding selection procedure and training:
He says that the volunteer cannot volunteer for a particular unit. He cannot even volunteer for SF. He can only volunteer for Parachute Regiment. Then he is given to any para unit depending upon the vacancies. Of course, a chap who has cleared the probation for say..5 PARA, may chose to convert to 1 PARA SF and again go for probation there. But this is rarely done. In fact, this is even looked down upon because of unit loyalty.

Also, regarding free fall jumps like HALO and HAHO. He says that paratroopers from both SF and non SF units can go through them. He says that there are various courses available and the personnel keep on doing different courses for a long time. This is generally done according to one's specialty. Like a person who is natural with demolition will first do courses related to it before going for others.

Regarding SFF and SG
He says that the PARA SF does not have any particular respect for SFF. It is not that they are not good, but it is not enough to impress PARA. Regarding SG, he says that he knows very little regarding the operations of SFF & SG so he cannot comment about that but he told me that the majority of SG come from PARA SF. And it is not as if some radical training is imparted to them there. In fact, he says that no CO likes parting from good men (let alone the best). He says that the men sent to NSG SAG and SG are generally done because of compulsion. He says that going to SG is like just another posting (even though he was using the word "posting", he was almost making it sound as if it was a holiday
:-o
).



PS: Misc stuff. The person says that the environment and culture of PARA is totally different from the rest of the army. For one, the people are much more close to each other. Eg: When any para (current, former or retired) sees another person wearing Maroon beret he always goes and introduces himself. In fact, it is considered extremely rude not to do so. It does not have to be long lengthy discussion, but a brief introduction is very important.
Also, once a person is from PARA, he is welcomed there even after retirement ( this is true for the regular army as well, but it is totally on a different level for PARACUTE regiment.) They is more like a family. Eg: It has sometimes happened that a retired officer has sent his son to his parent PARA unit during the child's school holidays..just for the purpose of making him fit and disciplined!!!


Regarding 21 PARA SF, he again repeated that only the CO and a young officer were able to clear the probation. Apart from them, there was only the unfortunate 2IC who had volunteered. He said that no one from the rest of the MLI unit had volunteered. They had given a choice to do so but they had declined.
However, it is worth noting that the person telling me all this was not from 21 SF."
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,118
Likes
17,834
Country flag
MARCOs training with USN VBSS teams, Royal Marines and Russian marines

Garuds training with RAF regiment

bizarre that Indian leadership is willing to keep sending its SF teams to operate alongside non-SF units from foreign countries



There are actually pictures of SPETSNAZ in India in the 80s but there’s not much indication of this in recent times. Certainly it hasn’t happened since the Russian SFs got their slew of equipment upgrades

+ US SFOD-D (CAG) has trained with Indian units but it’s unclear which, my guess would be SG
I highly doubt that.In the 80s we only trained with Israelis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top