DEFEXPO-2022

AnantS

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,740
Likes
15,332
Country flag
Just layman's glance at Archer gives you a feel about how the overall thing may be PTA driving in mountains but atleast it reduces the number of people and for all we know internally it may be no complex than exposed ones....at the rate of fire 5 to 6 rpm, automation may not be worth it in my opinion (atleast if it requires same crew level and so on). Just look at the elbit one that abing posted, its so much nimble and fast
mate more the complex closedbox automation, the more the things can go wrong and do go wrong. Most grunt wont be able fiddle with such systems - if they go kaput. Check with this video why archer hasnt been widely adopted
 

omaebakabaka

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
4,945
Likes
13,835
mate more the complex closedbox automation, the more the things can go wrong and do go wrong. Most grunt wont be able fiddle with such systems - if they go kaput. Check with this video why archer hasnt been widely adopted
It is no different than autoloaders in tank....there are service doors and obviously any deep breakdowns whether its exposed or inside may have to go to shop. When you automate, you have to reduce humans or simplify some aspects. What is caesar achieving? Its still 4 to 6 rpm. Other than wheeled mobility, there are no clear objectives in other parameters.....I like the elbit's simplicity to drive and 4 dudes firing and scooting...none of these contraptions that still require an army
 

AnantS

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,740
Likes
15,332
Country flag
It is no different than autoloaders in tank....there are service doors and obviously any deep breakdowns whether its exposed or inside may have to go to shop. When you automate, you have to reduce humans or simplify some aspects. What is caesar achieving? Its still 4 to rpm
sure thats why you have Tracked Artillery to cover that area. See Archer is being pitched as something that can be a alternative to Tracked SPH(why? because Its costly). A cheap reliable Mounted Artillery in numbers shall be more effective than few gold plated archers.
 

omaebakabaka

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
4,945
Likes
13,835
sure thats why you have Tracked Artillery to cover that area. See Archer is being pitched as something that can be a alternative to Tracked SPH(why? because Its costly). A cheap reliable Mounted Artillery in numbers shall be more effective than few gold plated archers.
Correct then keep that simple with wheeled chasis like this elbit atmos and no half baked automation that still require same amount of people and added complexity.

https://defenceforumindia.com/threads/defexpo-2022.83578/post-2367334

May be its just everyone trying to outcompete others with no added increase in value.
 

AnantS

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,740
Likes
15,332
Country flag
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
H Defexpo 2020 Defence & Strategy 655
Pandora Questions to be asked during Defexpo 2018 Defence & Strategy 11
sayareakd Defexpo 2018 Defence & Strategy 446
cobra commando Defexpo India 2016 Defence & Strategy 215
Similar threads




Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top