AEROINDIA 2019

Enquirer

New Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
3,567
Likes
9,357

I thought they were using a homegrown diesel engine we saw at Defexpo 2018?

@porky_kicker @Enquirer
I don't think he knows what he's talking about.
Anyone who gives one look at the picture will know that it's not a turboprop but an IC engine!!

Turboprop's main shaft runs in the center (or mostly to the center) of the engine. IC engines always have the crankshaft on one end of the block!

That's generic info anyways. Specifically the engine on Tapas is definitely not NPO-36MT (whose shaft is definitely in the dead center)

Also, it's obvious that the Tapas on display is not using the old IC engine, but the (more powerful) indigenous IC engine as you can see that the air vents are different from before and matches that of the desi diesel engine!!!!
 
Last edited:

Enquirer

New Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
3,567
Likes
9,357
View attachment 32494

View attachment 32495

View attachment 32496

View attachment 32497

View attachment 32498

Compare the engine cowl on Rustom 2 and the same on the DRDO diesel engine above.

drdo engine shape including air intakes , blades etc is exactly same as the one on the Rustom 2 , so do your own conclusion

View attachment 32499

View attachment 32500

View attachment 32501

And lastly pictures of Rustom 2 flying with the new engines.

I seriously don't understand the Indian journalists
Yep. I can't believe that he'd miss something so obvious!!

He normally posts a link to additional documents in his tweets, when you click on it you realize you need his permission to access them. I clicked on the button seeking access, next thing I see I have an email from him that I have to pay him a fee to see the docs. I replied 'no thanks'. Can't believe he charges money to give out this crappy info
 

Enquirer

New Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
3,567
Likes
9,357
He is an ex jag Pilot of IAF who also flew marut briefly. He had a lot if misgivings against Marut - hence HAL initially and wrote frequently against both of them in early version of website/blog he maintained(now no longer available) I think it was called as thumkaunata something like that or I could be wrong on name(I am not referring to current blogspot version http://thumkar.blogspot.com/).

I would not discount his writings. Sometime I think he has his own biases, but still his articles in some areas are well worthy of reading
Oh! I didn't know Vijainder Thakur manages the Thumkar blogspot!!
I think it was Thumkar that propagated the fake Helina pictures several years ago (the quad rack of Israeli LAHAT missiles had 'Helina' name photoshopped on the missile body).
I've lost count of the number of time I had to correct fanboys that it's not Helina!!!
 

porky_kicker

New Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2016
Messages
6,030
Likes
44,621
Country flag
I'm bit a noob when it comes to such stuff, can you elaborate on its functions? Thank you!
IFF identification friend or foe

99% of time targets cannot be identified visually due to distance and fog of war etc

So each vehicle has a transponder which beams a coded signal.

Each vehicle also has a interrogator which sends a signal to be received by any vehicle equipped with a transponder within its range.

Basically the transponder listens for an interrogation signal from an interrogator on another vehicle and then sends a response consisting of a unique signal from it's own transponder that identifies itself to the other vehicle as friendly.

If no signal or noise is received than that aircraft is deemed hostile.

For details you can google
 

Jackd

New Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2018
Messages
741
Likes
804
IFF identification friend or foe

99% of time targets cannot be identified visually due to distance and fog of war etc

So each vehicle has a transponder which beams a coded signal.

Each vehicle also has a interrogator which sends a signal to be received by any vehicle equipped with a transponder within its range.

Basically the transponder listens for an interrogation signal from an interrogator and then sends a response consisting of a unique signal from it's own transponder that identifies the aircraft as friendly.

If no signal or noise is received than that aircraft is deemed hostile.

For details you can google
Oh IFF.. I know about IFF but didn't know how the machines worked. Thank you!
 

torque456

New Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2017
Messages
59
Likes
78
Well his observations on LCA mk2 and Rustom 2 are in conflict with official Info.

Neither did he post any pictures of brochures , posters from the developers etc in support of his claims.

Most of what he said is better taken as his personal opinions or observations untill confirmed via other sources or official sources

And ultimately it also depends on who you want to believe.
He is extremely critical of everything designed or produced by any government agency. He is critical of basically everything Indian in non defense areas too. Stopped following him after that.
 

AnantS

New Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
5,890
Likes
15,774
Country flag
Oh! I didn't know Vijainder Thakur manages the Thumkar blogspot!!
I think it was Thumkar that propagated the fake Helina pictures several years ago (the quad rack of Israeli LAHAT missiles had 'Helina' name photoshopped on the missile body).
I've lost count of the number of time I had to correct fanboys that it's not Helina!!!
Indian Defence Web Space was wild wild west more than a decade back. And making mistake in identification of weapon system was not uncommon as most online/news sources you would read originally from - might have got it wrong altogether in first place. Heck Indian defence PSU were piss poor in PR dept back then - though now - its much better than before - but still leaves a lot to be desired. Those were the days when Vivek Raguvanshi, Rajat Pundit, ruled the professional defence news circle. Prasun K Sengupta was having tiff with Arun. S over former's alleged plagiarism. When Uneven Cohen & Christine who was then Unfair use to bitch against India while exonerated Pakistan

V.K was an ex Pilot & did some s/w business after retirement(if I read that info correctly somewhere), but I doubt that would have qualified him a regular update from DRDO/DRDL etc about various programs they were working on - with accurate Brochures. So quite possibly he could have got it wrong. It will surprise you when you meet/talk def personal be it India or elsewhere - often they are NOT walking encyclopedia on number, stats, Weapon Make types in existence - Barring the narrow domain field they worked in.
 

Articles

Top