- Joined
- May 26, 2010
- Messages
- 31,122
- Likes
- 41,042
Re: Manohar Parrikar clears proposal to acquire 814 artillery guns for
Dhanush over BEML Heavy Tatra would be a good alternative ..
Dhanush over BEML Heavy Tatra would be a good alternative ..
Do you have any idea of the scale of Tata? Likely you have no idea.there is no company on earth that can dole out 1000 guns a year.
Is there a possibility that if anyone of the company looses out they can still be in the game by encouraging outsourcing
eg. say TAT wins the order BF can provide metallurgy related help and so on... does MoD forbids such agreement can be debated.
The reach of an operation without stop or a pause which would commence at the border generally depends on the range of artillery that is supporting that operation.Explain saar.
The earlier assumptions may not hold. War plans can change.The reach of an operation without stop or a pause which would commence at the border generally depends on the range of artillery that is supporting that operation.
The first or initial set of Indian operation probably would be planned for 30 kms as Indian medium guns bulk of which is 130 mm would be able to provide fire support upto 25 -30 km.
What is CSD after all ? I hope it does not aim at crossing the Indus river !!!
They can declare themselves independent without a military push from India. That is a futile arguments as we were discussing the present artillery capability to support the CSD. On what account and due to what Pakistan can breakup is a different subject and military action is but part of that.The earlier assumptions may not hold. War plans can change.
India does not have to cross the Indus in the plains. Any push in North Punjab and Kashmir that is strong enough will do the trick. If Islamabad falls, Sindh and Baluchistan will declare independence in no time. You will see.
I cannot agree to your statement as it serves no purpose. Why would you "bash" Paki generals without taking territory. They will come back with even more strength.CSD is just to convey to the Paki generals that we will bash you up !! And bash you hard ... !!
That we will discuss in the CSD thread but before that be educated on theories of war and aims of wars.I cannot agree to your statement as it serves no purpose. Why would you "bash" Paki generals without taking territory. They will come back with even more strength.
The purpose of war is to take territory. Otherwise just put CSD in dustbin and talk of peace a-la Manmohan Singh.
I agree with you. However OFB is struggling with the current order for towed guns. The small order may take them three-four years.Dhanush over BEML Heavy Tatra would be a good alternative ..
stick to replying to my post and dont worry as to where I live.Do you have any idea of the scale of Tata? Likely you have no idea.
No DPSU is even a shadow of Tata.
You live in a dream world.
Why not. A company having a capacity of building more than 100K medium and heavy trucks can definitely build 1000 guns a year.stick to replying to my post and dont worry as to where I live.
no i dont.. but 1000 guns a year... please!!
anyways if u have any source to back your claim.. happy to stand corrected.
in short it is an assumption based on their vehicle production. Interesting.Why not. A company having a capacity of building more than 100K medium and heavy trucks can definitely build 1000 guns a year.
The manufacturing processes for heavy vehicles and artillery guns have lot in common.
Tata could build artillery guns that it showed to the world because it has the facilities. These facilities were NOT BUILT FOR ONE GUN.
Have you ever seen a factory in your entire life? What do you understand about industrial processes? Some posters on this forum brandish their ignorance as a weapon.in short it is an assumption based on their vehicle production. Interesting.
anyways I stand corrected on production.
This weird ignorant rants starts again!For those who understand Hindi well: The motto of the Indian MNCs (including TATA)
Iski Topi Uske Sar
That is why the government fears them more than it fears the foreigners.
same old method... go personal instead of discussing the issue in civility.Have you ever seen a factory in your entire life? What do you understand about industrial processes? Some posters on this forum brandish their ignorance as a weapon.
And this is the goddamn problem with this country's army. The army has been kept shielded from civilian life. These people live in their own sweet world of fabricated reality.
My friend, accept the truth that DPSUs are surviving purely because the government continues to throw money at them, not because they have any qualities.
No sermons. prove your point, or else STOP.same old method... go personal instead of discussing the issue in civility.
What I have seen in my life is none of your business.
please spare me your sermons- dont need them.
Most of India's economy is dependent on small enterprises , MSMEs, thank them for keeping the Indian economy afloat.This weird ignorant rants starts again!
Can you take even one example and prove.
Companies have built their credibility in the domestic market as well as international market on sheer hard work and innovation.
Come out of your well, and see the progress this country has made. Find the per capita in 1990 when India was about to default on its international obligations and find the per capita in 2013-14. Ask yourself how that happened? It did not happen by passing the "topis".