Advaidhya Tiwari
New Member
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2018
- Messages
- 1,579
- Likes
- 1,443
Do you have the data?You are assuming too many things. You have no idea of Astra production vs BVR requirement. You have no idea of plus/minus of Astra vs other missiles. This local/imported logic goes nowhere because you do not have reliable data.
The data says that Iderby-ER was rejected as it was found suitable due to some vibration issue. Despite this you recommend Iderby-ER! How logical is that? Also, Astra has cleared user-trials which show that it is suitable for India. It also has active radar seeker which makes it quite jam proofI am sure Astra will become a primary BVR missile for IAF fighters one day. I doubt that is the case today.
As new aircrafts come, older ones are retired. Aircrafts like MiG21 which also uses R77 are retiring. I don't see large enough aircraft induction that warrants buying any imported missile when Astra is already ready. First give data to prove otherwise and then we can speakI have no idea how many lots of R77 were bought and when. You need to ask IAF.
Fair to assume some lots have expired or expiring which need to be replaced.
Plus additional missiles are needed for new build aircraft.