This is not comparable to Igla. VSHORADS is a tripod-truck mounted one. Igla is purely shoulder launched. We still have to advance in miniaturising the actuators, propulsion and other sub components
Vshorads is of heavier category.
We can't miniaturise actuators & subcomponents they are already miniaturised. Its just we made a bigger system..
IGLA & stinger weights 17.9 kg & 15.7 kg.
Both have 70mm diameter. Both have length of 1.5metre stinger has range of 4.5km IGLA has 5km &6km variants.
Compare it to vshorad & mistral..
Both weight 20kg diameter of 90mm.
Length 2m of vshorad & 1.86 of mistral..
Vshorads has mechanical actuators as well as reaction controls too for very high munuevrability .. vshorad is balanced tradeoff design with alot of gains but only compromise on length & weight.
Vshorad has proximity fuse which IGLA ,stinger lacks . So even if is defeated by flares if it is in close proximity it can do significant damage. Unlike stinger who has impact fuse..
We can't say 2m length will be an issue or not...
But 20.5 kg might be in high altitudes..
Mistral has 7km range & vshorad has 7-8km..
The seeker of vshorad is superior to others as it has uncooled dual band ir seeker.. I have read, material which are used makes it more sensitive..
With increased weight & length vshorad gives advantage.. proximity fuse, reaction thrust controls, more fuel -longer range,
We should make a bigger system based on it like mistral 3..
& A smaller system too for portability.
Like 90mm diameter with 1.5 metre will give best combo of capabilities.. having 5km range will be more than enough it will be even more in higher altitudes..
With including Proximity fuse, reaction controls.
Reaction controls