Ya'll Nibbiars The India never left its socialist mindset with the auto sector. Among the G20, India probably taxes this sector the most. Add to this the heavily taxed petrol and diesel, it’s really a hat tip to the Indian consumer for still making Indian auto sector among the world’s largest.
View attachment 155525
And If Ex showroom price is 10.3 lakhs, you have to earn 30% more to save that much as Govt deducts TDS on your salary before the money comes to you.
Then on every component of the expenses/ex-showroom price breakdown there is a large part going to Govt. Overall, I can see that Govt makes more money than car manufacturer. (Car maker still have to spend a lot to make the car.
View attachment 155526
As you see above, I have to earn 13.3 lakhs to buy a car whose ex-showroom price is 8.5 lakhs. Of this 13.5 lakhs, Govt gets almost 7 lakhs in various forms and car maker/insurance company etc gets about 6.5 lakhs.
And The After purchase comes the running cost. This is proportionate to your usage- how many kms you run, how many toll gates you pass, what fuel economy your car is giving and so on. Below is an estimate, vary it as per your calculations. Here also Govt's share is more than what companies providing various automobile related services sell fuel, provide insurance, provide spares and service etc make.
View attachment 155527
New cars will cost less initial few years and more over time.
So this is the truth people. Of course, Govt is expected to provide good infrastructure (roads etc) and use these tax money for overall growth of the nation. To what extent it is happening is left to your judgment.
Even if you don't own a vehicle, these things do matter to you. A owner of a commercial vehicle will pass on these burden to his/her customers by means of increased ticket price, freight charges etc. I am not saying Govt shouldn't take tax. Taxes are primary source of income for Govt to pay its employees, manage the army, spend money on useless politicians, pay for PM's international trips and run various Govt schemes. But the point of conflict is the amount of taxation. 5 decades ago only super rich people had cars, everyone else used to walk or cycle around or take a bus. How the number of middle class people has increased and everyone wants a car, particularly post pandemic where public transport is either not there or deemed unsafe. Given the sheer increase in volume of vehicles, city infrastructures are collapsing. Increased number also means higher tax income for the Govt. Probably it is time to stop treating vehicle owners as cash cows and reduce some burden off their shoulders. If the middle class is left with more disposable cash, they will spend it on other industries such as housing, entertainment etc and boost economy. If cost of owning a vehicle is going beyond means of middle class, they will have to cut discretionary spending, dip into their savings or try reduce usage of cars. May be it is good in a sense- let only those who can afford to pay a lot of tax own a vehicle. I don't know. Do share your thoughts.