Nonsense. People can choose which country they want to live in. People are not inventions and discoveries.
they can.but one should never forgot what they are.there origin
LOL. You don't know your own history. Even the people in your country are not the actual indigenous people of the land.
I will quote one famous line from pashto
Rund pa akhpala kheena sha payezhi na stargawar de bal pa kheena
In urdu
Andha(blind) apne room ko sahi samajhta hay naa k anjaan normal person
Hence we know our history very well.the problem is that your still not getting that pakistan never was a part of india and neither were the pakistani ever indian(except few likes the mahajir).
IVC is the birthplace of early Hinduism. IVC postdated Buddhism by a 1000 years. Gautam Buddha was born in modern day Nepal or at least in modern India.
Shakya - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Buddha is also considered an avatar of Vishnu.
Pakistan, Bangladesh, even Bhutan and Nepal were merely part of a greater India.
IVC was limited to the local religions of pakistan.and mostly limited to the punjabi and sindhi of pakistan.both of them had hinduism in minority only.
Indeed pakistan was merged with india somehow but thsi doesnt mean we gave up our identity everything to india.pak was merged with india but foriegn invaders.but the period was not long.and onwards MBQ invasion.pakistanis had mostly ruled the whole of south asia for a very longer period.
Naturally, the river system and the limitations of migration. Eventually the IVC people migrated as Ganges and the lower rivers were colonized over the course of hundreds of years.
Pakistan today is composed of people who migrated from central and west asia. Meaning, all of you today don't have anything to do with IVC or the people of IVC. They are a different people. You have merely occupied the region after something like 1000-1500 years.
Really?Punjabi people are in Punjab from the past 3000 to 5000 years
so does the sindhi
Pashtun were in KPK/Afghanistan for the past 5000 years.
Baloch yes they are a new race and were iranian in the past.
Pakistanis lived in the present day pakistan since there origin
Mostly the subcontinent, small parts of Central Asia and maybe even small parts of Southeast Asia. You will find Vishnu temples even in Indonesia.
you will find mosque in kerela even when Muhammad(pbuh) was alove does it mean islam originated or ruled upto south india?
Depends on what the Kabba really is. It is an idol though. But I don't believe in conspiracy theories.
Only the religions of Christianity, Islam and a few other religions don't believe in the Sun God and Moon God. Most of the other religions worship the Sun and the Moon.
and those religion again accounts for 2/3rd of the world population,
Shows you don't know anything about Buddhism and IVC. God they are not even in the same region. Buddhism spread to Hindu Kingdoms of the region that was occupied by IVC. They are not even in the same timeline.
IVC disappeared before Buddhism was born. Buddhism was created by a Hindu prince.
Let's not forget IVC was the birthplace of the Rig Veda, the oldest Sanskrit Hindu book.
IVC was between 3300 BC and 1200 BC. Buddhism was born in North and Northwestern India in 500BC. Rig Veda was written in 1700-1100 BC. The same time as the IVC existed. More importantly, Rig Veda and IVC are interrelated. This was
Rigveda - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
do you have evidence that Rig veda is a hinduism holybook?it could be of buddhism and Birth of Buddha is a mystery and is not exactly known
The same type of pottery continued to flourish in the Ganges plains under the Indo-Gangetic tradition. This was immediately after IVC was declared dead in 1200-1300BC.
List of Rigvedic tribes - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is the list of Rig Vedic tribes that flourished in the regions between Afghanistan and India. These people were the earliest Hindus. They are semi-migratory, intermingled with various tribes of the time and then settled down in the Gangetic plain because it was much more plentiful comparared to the more dangerous IVC areas which saw invasions. Much later, after the formation of the Persian civilization, there were invasions and other forms of migration which saw the Rig Vedic tribes that created the IVC move to richer plains down south.
dont have much knowlegde about hinduism.but limited knoweldge i know that Hinduism was only limited to central india and south india
even north india had its own smaller indigenous religion as per the communities.until the past 2000-2500 years when the hinduism spread upto north india
This is something that you need to know about "our" history.
Battle of the Ten Kings - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This war is considered to have shaped our history.
The above information will show how hopelessly wrong you are.
Good for you.but as i earlier said hindu only were in power when there were very less or non other religious communities around
we know what happened when Muhammad bin qasim at the age of 17 started the invasion of south asia by uniting with sindhi pakistani against the rest of the india
Politics of present day don't change history.
That's the ting you have rejected South Asian civilizations for Persian and now Arab civilization. You have nothing to do with IVC. You are not a Rig Vedic tribe. You are foreign to the region.
lol.as earlier said we never were part of south asia.pakistan was a identity of its own.indigenous culture,religion and people under the umbrella of IVC.
we might be different to our indigenous IVC culture/religion now because of Islam but this doesnt mean we should forgot what we are.
We are the indigenous people of IVC
Not all Urdu speakers left to Pakistan. As a matter of fact, there are more muslims in India who are actual Urdu speakers compared to Pakistan which has a lot of Pashtuns and central asian tribes infesting the region.
Indian muslim has given up urdu for hindi.
yes not all the urdu speaker left for pakistan but majority did.and majority is the authority.
Pakistan pashtun can speak now urdu well than indian muslims of UP
Puru is a Rig Vedic tribe.
If you open the link to the Battle Of The Ten Kings you will find Porus's ancestors being part of the fight.
Puru (Vedic tribe) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Afghan sources claim that the guy who fought with Alexender in jhelum was a pashtun not a punjabi.
poru might sound similar to porus but this doesnt mean because of name similarity he was from poru tribe
Let me repeat. Nonsense. Ashoka is PROVEN top have his capital in Patna. It was called Patliputra. Go read actual history. Not the madrasa history you were taught.
Ashoka (emperor of India) -- Encyclopedia Britannica
Mauryan empire (ancient state, India) -- Encyclopedia Britannica
but he has his capital in Taxila aswell.the time when he accepted the buddhism
NONSENSE. Hindusim was born in IVC. Read up on Rig Veda.
Hinduism's origin was IVC. Rig Veda. Read up.
Porus was from a Rig Vedic tribe called Puru and is an Indo-Aryan tribe which was also called a Vedic tribe.
Puru (Vedic tribe) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
What if one doesnt believe in Rig veda?like me.
your history is all bright and has many heroes.
Abrahmic religions claim that Adam(pbuh) was born in today South india/Sri lanka.does it mean South asia or india first religon was Islam?
if you dont believe in this than why do you want me to belive in Rig veda claiming that a pakistani of pakistani religon was a hindu indian?
But for God sake please dont take pride of pakistani heroes.leave them to us
Islam isn't your claim either. Islam belongs to the Arabs. You are not Arabs.
Urdu, you can speak it, not claim it. And no, there are a lot of Urdu speakers in India that did not migrate.
Islam certainly is a different religon than the rest of all.
A religion of equality.
even if anyone from india accept Islam.he would become a human like the rest of the world.and would be equal to them including the Arab and the childrens of israel/Bani israel
It is just a dress, you can all wear mankinis if you want.
Yes even though sari has its origin in pakistna.but since most of them migrated to india we now dont claim sari to be our own.
Same is the case with shalwar kameez.our dress and we dont want indian copying our culture
Which Vedic tribe do you all belong to? Today's Pakistan has nothing to do with the ancient Vedic tribes that are more prevalent in modern day India. You all merely migrated to the region at a much much later date through muslim invasions. If you have no links to any ancient Hindu Vedic tribes that created the Rig Veda, you have no claim on IVC.
Hahahaha.Should i start again from zero?
the confusion here is that you consider pakistan as once a part of india.which is as false as pakistani/pakistan from latin america
LOL. Take it out and then we will talk. Minority religions are on the rise in India, in decline in Pakistan. Change your laws and then we can talk about other religion in Pakistan.
Minroty on the rise in india?Lol than why each day a kashmiri is killed and curfew is still declared in kashmir.
What i dont undetstand is that why the hell indian claim our history and cultural part as there
We never claim that Hindu were muslims before even though when the Adam(pbuh) was from South india/Sri lanka
we also dont claim that sanskrit or hindi as our own language
we also never claim that sari is our culture dress
than why indians claim pakistani urdu as there own
Shalwal kameez as a part of indian culture
Pakistani present day land as once part of india