Rushil51
New Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2014
- Messages
- 471
- Likes
- 314
In 2012 Rafale was selected over Eurofighter Typhoon as the winner of MMRCA. Reason cited for it's victory was it's lower bid compared to Typhoon. At that time deal was worth $11 billion.
"Unit-wise, the French plane is much cheaper than the Eurofighter. Moreover, the Indian air force, which is well equipped with French fighters, is favouring the French," An Indian source said in 2012
But there were many other reasons which led to the Rafale victory :-
1.)France maintains good relations with India. Unlike USA, which placed an arms embargo on India in 1998,France was the only western nation not to impose any sanctions. France fighter aircrafts also have a good reputation with IAF pilots and has been supplying weapons to India for a long time
2)In case of war, German law prohibits deliveries of weapons and spares, Italian law and public opinions would demand an embargo, while Spanish legislation is murky.What if after buying the Eurofighter we went to war? Would spares and weapons be forthcoming, or would we be embargoed?
3.)Weapons also played a significant role for us to opt for Rafale: not only is its weapons range mostly French-made, and thus not subject to a third-party embargo, but so are all of its sensors. Eurofighter, whose air-to-air missiles include the US-made AIM-120 Amraam and the German-led IRIS-T, and whose primary air-to-ground weapon is the US-made Paveway, was obviously at a competitive disadvantage in this respect.
4.)As this aircraft is produced by a consortium of four nations, each with different foreign policies and different attitudes and tolerances to arms exports. This meant India had to deal with 4 different nations in the case of Typhoon instead of 1
{Source for above 4 points (The Real Reasons for Rafale's Indian Victory)
Now It is 2014 and the deal costs $20 billion. One Rafale costs around $120 million compared to $80 million for one Eurofighter Typhoon. Britain tried to persuade Modi to opt for Typhoon and according to few rumours same thing will have in Modi's trip to Germany
Keeping in mind that Typhoon now costs less than Rafale and the above points, does Eurofighter Typhoon have a chance to become part of the Indian airforce?
(Rafale cost source dna exclusive: 100% price escalation on Rafale fighter aircraft to Rs 1.75 lakh crore likely to dent IAF's strike capability | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis)
(Eurofighter Typhoon cost source
India's M-MRCA Fighter Competition: Order Cut Coming?)
"Unit-wise, the French plane is much cheaper than the Eurofighter. Moreover, the Indian air force, which is well equipped with French fighters, is favouring the French," An Indian source said in 2012
But there were many other reasons which led to the Rafale victory :-
1.)France maintains good relations with India. Unlike USA, which placed an arms embargo on India in 1998,France was the only western nation not to impose any sanctions. France fighter aircrafts also have a good reputation with IAF pilots and has been supplying weapons to India for a long time
2)In case of war, German law prohibits deliveries of weapons and spares, Italian law and public opinions would demand an embargo, while Spanish legislation is murky.What if after buying the Eurofighter we went to war? Would spares and weapons be forthcoming, or would we be embargoed?
3.)Weapons also played a significant role for us to opt for Rafale: not only is its weapons range mostly French-made, and thus not subject to a third-party embargo, but so are all of its sensors. Eurofighter, whose air-to-air missiles include the US-made AIM-120 Amraam and the German-led IRIS-T, and whose primary air-to-ground weapon is the US-made Paveway, was obviously at a competitive disadvantage in this respect.
4.)As this aircraft is produced by a consortium of four nations, each with different foreign policies and different attitudes and tolerances to arms exports. This meant India had to deal with 4 different nations in the case of Typhoon instead of 1
{Source for above 4 points (The Real Reasons for Rafale's Indian Victory)
Now It is 2014 and the deal costs $20 billion. One Rafale costs around $120 million compared to $80 million for one Eurofighter Typhoon. Britain tried to persuade Modi to opt for Typhoon and according to few rumours same thing will have in Modi's trip to Germany
Keeping in mind that Typhoon now costs less than Rafale and the above points, does Eurofighter Typhoon have a chance to become part of the Indian airforce?
(Rafale cost source dna exclusive: 100% price escalation on Rafale fighter aircraft to Rs 1.75 lakh crore likely to dent IAF's strike capability | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis)
(Eurofighter Typhoon cost source
India's M-MRCA Fighter Competition: Order Cut Coming?)
Last edited:
