Chinese troops intrude into Arunachal Pradesh, stay for over two days

[arnabmit]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

The other threads are about intrusion in the Chaglagam Sector. This one is about Tawang Sector.

Can we merge threads on this same topic running parallel.

 

[sayareakd]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

Yes i watched the 21 min tape..
My question is to the elites in DFI that-
Why don't our govt consider deploying troops on LAC, like in LoC?.. I feel our nation has bowed down to all our neighbour's under this govt

China want us to make a mistake and then they will get an excuse to attack us. Please remember we are not ready for war yet, they are ready and next war will not be like 1962, this will be war of missiles and they are the one who will raining on missiles on us. They have lots and lots of long range cruise missile, it can come down to Delhi on no time. They can scare Delhi politicians by taking out hindon air base with cruise missile launched from Tibet. They can reach their border in few hours, they have got 6 lane world class road. We have hardly single lane road. We will find very hard to reach our border when war start, they will have very heavy deployment in no time.

War should be fight at our time, place and when we are ready for war. We need about 2000 nirbhay other would say 4000 nirbhay would be comfort zone. We have not even completed its development or first successful flight. 300 or so Brahmos wont do much damage to them.

Expect Pakistan to jump in if we go war with China.

So lets delay as long as we can, fight we will but now is not the right time. Wont mind ATV with K15 on active duty we go to war.

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

If you look carefully the Chinese soldiers are looking bewildered and
are looking totally unsure of themselves and the situation that they are in

OTOH The Indian commander was airing lots of confidence

In one frame the Indian commander is standing all alone Confidently dictating his terms
to around 25 odd Chinese men AND the Chinese soldiers are looking at his
face quietly

I really liked the confidence and Body Language of the Indian Army commander

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

This video confirms what many analysts have been saying

The Chinese are only blowing Hot air

They do come in but they DONT want a fire fight

The Chinese have NOT seen active combat for a very long tine now

They dont want casualties

If it really comes down to a " shooting war " as compared to the cold war it is now
the Chinese would be pathetically exposed

 

[hit&run]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

If you look carefully the Chinese soldiers are looking bewildered and
are looking totally unsure of themselves and the situation that they are in

OTOH The Indian commander was airing lots of confidence

In one frame the Indian commander is standing all alone Confidently dictating his terms
to around 25 odd Chinese men AND the Chinese soldiers are looking at his
face quietly

I really liked the confidence and Body Language of the Indian Army commander

Yes you are right, I liked the way Indian soldiers acted brave. I have no words to explain their confidence.

Having done plenty of hand on hand fighting during college days against groups of students I can fairly tell that things can go out of control in no time.

Having said that one must pay attention on how PLA activity and number of soldiers along LAC has increased and God knows how many forward defences have gone to them. This time they pretended to be bewildered and erratic to see our soldiers intervening to their surprise.

Be ready for Kargil like situation this winters.

 

[arya]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

we have to be realx , close all the pending work as soon as possible

what the hell our officer and govt doing , they should close the pipeline deals as soon as possible .

war is on our door we have to buy time

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

Yes you are right, I liked the way Indian soldiers acted brave. I have no words to explain their confidence.

Having done plenty of hand on hand fighting during college days against groups of students I can fairly tell that things can go out of control in no time.

Having said that one must pay attention on how PLA activity and number of soldiers along LAC has increased and God knows how many forward defences have gone to them. This time they pretended to be bewildered and erratic to see our soldiers intervening to their surprise.

Be ready for Kargil like situation this winters.

I am telling you This Chinese show of aggression is Nothing

It is what is called SHOW and TELL

They dont have the guts for either a Handfight or gun fight

And that is why they have been asking India not to TAIL their patrols

What are they afraid of

 

[arya]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

I am telling you This Chinese show of aggression is Nothing

It is what is called SHOW and TELL

They dont have the guts for either a Handfight or gun fight

And that is why they have been asking India not to TAIL their patrols

What are they afraid of

i hope now you are out of your dream , they are doing with a action plan .

 

[hit&run]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

I am telling you This Chinese show of aggression is Nothing

It is what is called SHOW and TELL

They dont have the guts for either a Handfight or gun fight

And that is why they have been asking India not to TAIL their patrols

What are they afraid of

They will out tail you, out scout you, out power you, You need to cut few hands so that they do not dare to enter your borders. They enter, they stay, you shoot. There should't be anything in between.

They have mocked and reduced your forward defence deterrence to man handling !!

Is there any nation on this planet which allow such nonsense at their borders ?

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

Mate please stop what is called " Dhoti Shivering " on BR

Ie Indian Public getting scared easily

When our troops are confident as can be seen clearly in the video what
are you afraid of

The most important thing is CAPABILITY we are improving and strenghtening our capabilities
ALL the time

And above all It is China which is PRESSING India for a
Border Defence cooperation Agreement

The IA is patrolling and tailing the Chinese in a agressive manner
which has unnerved the Chinese PLA

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

They will out tail you, out scout you, out power you, You need to cut few hands so that they do not dare to enter your borders. They enter, they stay, you shoot. There should't be anything in between.

They have mocked and reduced your forward defence deterrence to man handling !!

Is there any nation on this planet which allow such nonsense at their borders ?

It is a GOOD thing that we have Chinese experts and a China study group
which has concluded that WHY China is behaving the way it does on our
borders

It is because they have accumulated LOTS of Money and LOTS of Hardware

SO they want to throw around their weight

The Chinese ego has become too big which is natural considering
their new found strength

There is NO need for India to escalate matters

Let them start the shooting war

If you have seen that terrain on the LAC
there are huge mountains; deep valleys and gorges and rivers and forests

It is not an easy place to live or move about

If the Chinese want to continue such DRAMAS let them do it

They are NOT going to gain anything out of it

We must ONLY be concerned with increasing our Fire power

If they have the guts and the courage let them start the " shooting war "

 

[trackwhack]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

If we are not going to fire a shot then the only logical response to this is to intrude and set up camps on their side. Why aren't we doing that? Lhasa is only 500 km away.

 

[sayareakd]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

PLA looks like Jhugi wala, who want to get into others land. Red army in blue and white look funny and stupid.

 

[pankaj nema]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

If we are not going to fire a shot then the only logical response to this is to intrude and set up camps on their side. Why aren't we doing that? Lhasa is only 500 km away.

Mate we are also patrolling aggressively

It is just that we have NOT set up tents and camps but our patrols are also
moving in their territory

That is why the Chinese are hankering for a BDCA

DBO incursion was a very good thing because that sector needed More attention and manpower
which it has now started receiving

This Chagalgam incursion was from the Eastern Arunachal side ie Lohit valley

This means that Northern side has been totally walled up

 

[hit&run]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

It is a GOOD thing that we have Chinese experts and a China study group
which has concluded that WHY China is behaving the way it does on our
borders

It is because they have accumulated LOTS of Money and LOTS of Hardware

SO they want to throw around their weight

The Chinese ego has become too big which is natural considering
their new found strength

There is NO need for India to escalate matters

Let them start the shooting war

If you have seen that terrain on the LAC
there are huge mountains; deep valleys and gorges and rivers and forests

It is not an easy place to live or move about

If the Chinese want to continue such DRAMAS let them do it

They are NOT going to gain anything out of it

We must ONLY be concerned with increasing our Fire power

If they have the guts and the courage let them start the " shooting war "

Things are not same for China like they were during 1962. Once they capture any of your territory it would be difficult to us to get it back. They are not going leave it like they did during 1962. It has become more pressing a concern for us to not take it lightly following the philosophy of ''Parbat wo sab se ucha samsaya asman ka wo santri hamara wo pasban hamara''.

 

[roma]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

This video confirms what many analysts have been saying

The Chinese are only blowing Hot air

They do come in but they DONT want a fire fight

The Chinese have NOT seen active combat for a very long tine now

They dont want casualties

If it really comes down to a " shooting war " as compared to the cold war it is now
the Chinese would be pathetically exposed

i would advise to re-read this post below which i feel is the more accurate assessment of the situation

China want us to make a mistake and then they will get an excuse to attack us. Please remember we are not ready for war yet, they are ready and next war will not be like 1962, this will be war of missiles and they are the one who will raining on missiles on us. They have lots and lots of long range cruise missile, it can come down to Delhi on no time. They can scare Delhi politicians by taking out hindon air base with cruise missile launched from Tibet. They can reach their border in few hours, they have got 6 lane world class road. We have hardly single lane road. We will find very hard to reach our border when war start, they will have very heavy deployment in no time.

War should be fight at our time, place and when we are ready for war. We need about 2000 nirbhay other would say 4000 nirbhay would be comfort zone. We have not even completed its development or first successful flight. 300 or so Brahmos wont do much damage to them.

Expect Pakistan to jump in if we go war with China.

So lets delay as long as we can, fight we will but now is not the right time. Wont mind ATV with K15 on active duty we go to war.

 

[hit&run]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

@Ray; @lemontree; Sir,

Have you seen this video? This is what we have been reduced to defend our borders by pushing PLA out with Hands, Trunks and Legs? What our military surveillance could have been doing, not able to see such large company of armed PLA soldiers approaching our forward defences ?

 

[Kunal Biswas]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

Ask Government, How our own Gov is interfering with national security ..

 

[Kunal Biswas]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

=====================

Chinese Marine Type 97 blue/green camouflage

Btw, anyone noticed the camo PLA were wearing ? looks like they are Marine units deployed in mountain areas..

 

[hit&run]

Re: Chinese incursion in Arunachal: Caught on tape

Ask Government, How our own Gov is interfering with national security ..

Those were troops from Assam Riffles and they showed PLA who is the boss. Now this Government is using Indo-Tibetan police to guard our borders ?

Not saying ITBP is not a brave organization but a police force against PLA is no match. We know what happened in DBO area, ITBP struggled to out scout, chase out PLA unit for 2-3 day but they were too aggressive for them.