Naxals/Maoists Watch

Should the Indian government use armed forces against the naxals/maoists?


  • Total voters
    426

Lost user

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
2,181
Likes
10,450
Country flag
Urban naxals are the brain behind maoist.
Who is more dangerous:
Hafeez Saeed or the foot soldiers of LeT who can be replaced easily.
Urban naxals primary role, is staying the GoIs hand, so that GOI does not go all out in crushing the insurgency.. But, it's up to the government to not take the bait.. Neither do the urban naxals organize the armed militia, hold territory, kill nor extort.. Yes, its important to identify and jail them.. but it's in reclaiming and consistently dominating the naxal infested areas, and also getting getting the tribals on our side, once we dominate it, that matters more..
 

Alfalfa

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2017
Messages
196
Likes
442
Country flag
Urban naxals are the brain behind maoist.
Who is more dangerous:
Hafeez Saeed or the foot soldiers of LeT who can be replaced easily.
I dont get this diatribe about the "vague" urban naxal... some rather decorated DFI members called me a "Libergandu and an Urban Naxal once too", fact is no one can even really tell who they are a side show... can you define an urban naxal the way you define an insurgent or a terrorist.. No... they don't raise money for them, they dont recruit from the cities... they dont transact to purchase arms... they are just convenient punching bags made up by the powers that be to deflect answerability from the core issues that are centric to an insurgency like this...
 

doreamon

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2019
Messages
3,007
Likes
15,162
Country flag
He has a point you know Sri Lanka literally finished LTTE within a year with lesser equipmented force against a better trained opposition. Compared to LTTE, moaist are not comparable
There was a genocide . They dint distinguish between Tamilian and LTTE . I dnt think same can be done with respect to tribal and naxalites
Exactly... People don't get how complicated these kind of insurgencies are... they kill at will and hide in villages dispersed around the jungle to blend in, calling in the Assam Rifles or Rashtriya Rifles isnt a magic wand.. also parallels with the LTTE are just absurd... the area around Jafna to Batticaloa is the size of one small district, most of which is urban/agrarian... the red corridor spans 30-40 times the area and all of it is largely forested... nabbing a sandalwood brigand took decades..
Army ll simply clear villages after villages out of frustration ... Kashmir is different issue . There army dont face a battalion of gorrila force who somehow vanish in to villages after the operation ... Also Its a border state . Pakistan directly involved . And kashmir is a small area with one state (now UT) involved .. Even there now CRPF is more involved . Here multiple state cooperation required . I thing CAPF can deal and is dealing with maoist effectively . Just that more technology , situational awareness required . I dnt see why army ll be more effective .
 

indus

Living in Post Truth
Senior Member
Joined
May 31, 2017
Messages
5,086
Likes
22,075
Country flag
To what extent the naxal activities have changed after the coming of Congress in the state Govt. I m sure backend communication lines between Reddies and the state govt must have become more open in the past few years.
 

Vishalreddy3

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2020
Messages
2,367
Likes
8,637
Country flag
Also to combat these m*aists in their own territory using a force not aware of the terrain is only going to lead to a bloodbath. Like maharashtra police we have to form separate force consisting of local tribals and ex-moaist in that particular state, except this force should be funded fully by the central government and arm and train them by the military. This is the only way we can combat them in their own turf on ground
 

vampyrbladez

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
10,271
Likes
26,620
Country flag
No operational, intel failure, over 25-30 Naxals killed in Bijapur encounter: DG CRPF Kuldiep Singh

Director-General of Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) Kuldiep Singh, who is in Chhattisgarh to monitor the situation following the Naxal attack, on Sunday said that there was absolutely no intelligence or operational failure in the operation. Singh informed that around 25-30 Naxals were also killed though the exact number is yet to be ascertained.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/timeso...ur-district-april-4/amp_liveblog/81895442.cms
 

Ayushraj

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2020
Messages
2,404
Likes
19,518
Country flag
No operational, intel failure, over 25-30 Naxals killed in Bijapur encounter: DG CRPF Kuldiep Singh

Director-General of Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) Kuldiep Singh, who is in Chhattisgarh to monitor the situation following the Naxal attack, on Sunday said that there was absolutely no intelligence or operational failure in the operation. Singh informed that around 25-30 Naxals were also killed though the exact number is yet to be ascertained.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/timeso...ur-district-april-4/amp_liveblog/81895442.cms
Ani quoted 16 madharch@d naxali were.
Killed and multiple were injured.
Currently crpf dg is calming 25-30 casualties.
This might be true since injured naxali wouldn't get hospitalised facility
 

Lost user

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
2,181
Likes
10,450
Country flag
Also to combat these m*aists in their own territory using a force not aware of the terrain is only going to lead to a bloodbath. Like maharashtra police we have to form separate force consisting of local tribals and ex-moaist in that particular state, except this force should be funded fully by the central government and arm and train them by the military. This is the only way we can combat them in their own turf on ground
The DRG who were part of the team killed.. are local tribals.. auxiliaries like the Salwa judum..
 

Underground Soldier

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2020
Messages
226
Likes
1,186
Country flag
"The security forces personnel, especially CoBRA commandos, fought very bravely and ensured that the Naxals could not prolong the ambush despite being at an advantage," the officer said.
 

Shredder

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2009
Messages
685
Likes
1,856
Country flag
Please go through this once. I never knew it's magnitude. Deaths / mass murders / genocide caused by Communism and it's offshoots.

1617551800885.png


History is truly written by the victors. 100 million plus deaths attributed to this devil's ideology. Apologies for the shabby copy-paste job.

Om Shanthi, to our fallen brothers. May they and their families find peace and closure.

Commie ideology is like islamism, we cannot consider these vermin saying bs like "they are our own people" etc. They are scum of the planet. It's ideology is a cancer which erodes all ethos of society. Just look at Russia today, you cannot come across a more depressing and sad country / people.
 

Vishalreddy3

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2020
Messages
2,367
Likes
8,637
Country flag
CRPF should have their own air wing ASAP. I know it's laughable since we don't have enough money to improve our infantry units, but here it goes. Arm them with
*Loitering Munition Drones (Indegenous/ Isreali), bad news is that India doesn't have its own project in this field.
Screenshot_20210404_211703.jpg

* HAL cheetah, and arm them with hardpoints. Since they are small they can be used as infantry support like AH-1 cobra, except smaller.
*HAL LUH and modify them as a gunship.
* Swamp drones (kamakaze) which are armed and used to inflict bigger damage when the adversary are large in numbers.
*Fixed wing drones for surveillance of the area since they have better endurance than rotary drones.
These can be used in their Air Wing if they are formed with budget allocations.
 

Cheran

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2019
Messages
9,086
Likes
79,634
Country flag
Please read full by Maj Manik M Jolly,SM

Twitter handle - @Manik_M_Jolly


1
Since all ‘experts’ are very excited to talk about why we should review the training, tactics, formation, counter ambush drills etc now, I thought let me give a counter to those who’ve never sat down in an ambush and thankfully never suffered any. Firstly, if you

2.

end up being ambushed upon, by even a mid level tactician, that too an opportunity ambush, you’ll rarely live to tell the tale. Forget about a well planned one by a good planner. There are many types of ambushes. But for a layman, let’s say you choose the location, site the

3.

Weapons, place your troops, cut off all exit grounds, place mines, bombard the area with lead and grenades and fill the entire kill zone with everything you have. Now try walking out of that ! Yes, the best counter is to fight back. But when you’re suddenly bombarded with so much

4.

lethal firepower and you see people getting hit all around you, the first reaction is to take cover. And from the other side, the enemy will plan an ambush where you have least cover. I speak from experience of being part of unit that killed 102 terrorists in just fifteen

5.

months. Highly skilled and motivated troops. And we had only one ambush on us and we lost an officer and few more injured. The team couldn’t kill anyone in retaliation that time. Later we got back, is a different story. The impact of being fired upon can’t be effectively put

6.

in words. It’s stunning, numbing and very shocking. Takes a second for everyone to regain composure. And if in that first couple of seconds, you and others have been hit, you really can’t do much. What anti Naxal forces need is very solid EW systems. They need great Int networks

7.

, and most importantly this mindless patrolling has to stop. You don’t gain much by bunching together and walking around the jungle to prove area is dominated. It isn’t ! They need better leadership and focused operations. They need new weapons and equipment. They need freedom

8.

to operate and strike. It’s when all these are available, then talk about tactics and drills. Don’t expect soldiers to deliver when they aren’t commanded or equipped properly. Red corridor is one of the biggest internal threats in India and by not addressing it, we are not only

9.

enabling the enemy but also losing brave and competent soldiers regularly. Prayers for every soldiers who lost his life and those recovering from injuries. May this be the last of such incidents and gov wakes up to take this menace head on. Jai Hind
 

IndianYonko

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2020
Messages
1,813
Likes
7,918
Country flag
Please go through this once. I never knew it's magnitude. Deaths / mass murders / genocide caused by Communism and it's offshoots.

View attachment 83968

History is truly written by the victors. 100 million plus deaths attributed to this devil's ideology. Apologies for the shabby copy-paste job.

Om Shanthi, to our fallen brothers. May they and their families find peace and closure.

Commie ideology is like islamism, we cannot consider these vermin saying bs like "they are our own people" etc. They are scum of the planet. It's ideology is a cancer which erodes all ethos of society. Just look at Russia today, you cannot come across a more depressing and sad country / people.
But no one is born Islamist or commie. They are nurtured by the ecosystem.
And commie. Ecosystem in India is well preserved by courts so, I don't see any solution for this near future.
 

New threads

Articles

Top