India wants license to produce Iron Dome - report

nirmal

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Messages
40
Likes
1
Country flag
Sometime back I saw a report in this forum that India's Phase-I BMD shield development programme is over and that it will be in place by 2012. This was probably stated by Dr.Saraswat.
Why then this new development of buying Iron Dome?
 

p2prada

Senior Member
Joined
May 25, 2009
Messages
10,234
Likes
4,015
The AAD will get expensive if it is used to counter small range BMs rather than the Agni II class of missiles it is meant to stop. Iron Dome would be a good buy until our own MRSAMs are ready in a few years.

Goodbye Nasr.
 

debasree

Regular Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2011
Messages
819
Likes
86
Country flag
hope the deciesion not again be the victim of red tapism.
 
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
29,909
Likes
48,642
Country flag
So far almost every single missle developed by Israel has been bought by India,why should this be an exception?? If iron dome and SPYDER can tie down Pakistan then we can use Akash etc.. against the Chinese.
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
I don't think there is any threat of LeT usin rockets against Indian cities. India is a very big country.

But I am certain that this system is purely targetted against the Nasr and India will acquire a few batteries that Indian IBGs will take along in any future war using cold start doctrine.

This will totally blunt the tactical nuclear threat and raise the stakes and costs for Pakistan.

Iron Dome ki Jai!
___________________________

NEW DELHI: As Fajr V rockets rained down on Israel from battleground Gaza for a week, many Indian defense planners were keeping a close watch on the performance of Israel's Iron Dome, which is probably the only deterrent to these homegrown short-range missiles.

It was not just out of curiosity regarding one of the most effective systems against rockets, but also because of the possibility of India acquiring an indigenous version of Iron Dome.

Several months ago, the military scientists in the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) had suggested that India look at a joint development programme with Israeli firms to develop an Indian version of Iron Dome, which is touted as the most effective system against short-range missiles such as Fajr V rockets. The Indian scientists believe Israel's plight has several parallels to its threat from Pakistan as well as the vulnerability of its cities from terrorists.

The Iron Dome, according to reports, intercepted 87% of the rockets fired at Israel by the Hamas. The system, produced by Israel's Rafael Advanced Defense Systems and at work since 2011, is believed to have the capability to shoot down rockets and artillery shells with ranges of up to 70 km. The system has been shown to be effective against rockets or shells that might target populated areas.

In the Indian military establishment, the temptation for acquiring this new toy is explained by the fact that India is ringed by hostile neighbours. Pakistani terror groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) could well acquire similar capability that would threaten large groups of Indian population. Even otherwise, the strategic planners have for long been worried about the deadly effect of short-range rockets fired at Indian cities or from across the border.

Unlike ballistic missiles, against which DRDO claims to have a fairly good anti-ballistic missile shield, there is almost no protection against short-range rockets or artillery fire. DRDO is currently collaborating with Israeli firms to develop medium range surface to air missiles (MRSAMs) and LRSAMs. However, Iron Dome is in a different class all together, Israeli diplomatic sources here argue.

One of the reasons why some Indian defence planners is pushing for it is the possibility of another conflict with Pakistan, where a system like the Iron Dome might be useful to deter even conventional artillery attacks. In addition, Pakistan has developed a tactical nuclear weapon like the Nasr, which is a solid fuelled battlefield range ballistic missile. While Pakistani analysts say this was developed in anticipation of India's supposed Cold Start doctrine, some Indian sources say the Iron Dome might be an effective deterrent against this new weapon.

On the other hand, acquiring such defensive systems in anticipation of similar attacks might prove to be too much a temptation for groups like LeT. While they haven't yet developed rockets like the ones the Hamas has been using, the lure of such home-grown weaponry should not be under-estimated, say diplomatic sources.

According to sources, there have been some discussions between DRDO and their Israeli counterparts for a possible joint development of Iron Dome for India. "The Israeli team comes and works in our laboratories. Our team goes and works in their laboratories and industries. There is a learning that is taking place which was not there when we buy things and integrate with existing products... In directed energy weapons — we are focusing on fibre laser, high powered micro-waves, etc. We have also started discussions with Iron Dome for co-development (in India)," Dr W Selvamurthy, Chief Controller looking after international cooperation, told the Economic Times recently.

How it works:

* The system detects launches of rockets and quickly determines their flight path. If it is headed toward populated areas or sensitive targets, it fires an interceptor with a special warhead that strikes the incoming rocket within seconds. Rockets headed toward open areas area allowed to land.

* Currently, five Iron Dome batteries are deployed in Israel. Most are located in the south near Gaza. A fifth battery was deployed outside Tel Aviv on Saturday, two months ahead of schedule. Hours later, it shot down a rocket headed toward Tel Aviv.

*Missiles cost around $40,000 a piece. In 2010, the US provided $200 million to expand development. Additional funding is currently being considered, with $70 million already allocated for this fiscal year.

*The system is part of what Israel calls its "multilayer missile defense". It is meant to protect against the tens of thousands of short-range rockets possessed by militants in the Gaza Strip and Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon. Israel has also deployed its "Arrow" missile defense systems for long-range threats from Iran. The military says its new "David's Sling" system, being developed by Rafael to stop medium-range missiles, will be activated by 2014.


India eyes Israel's Iron Dome to counter Pak, puppets - The Times of India on Mobile
 

datguy79

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2012
Messages
702
Likes
945
A few batteries? You will need at least 100 considering the size of Israel vs India.
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
hahaha!
First we say, disproportionate use of force is unacceptable and then shamelessly ask Israelis for Iron Dome, WTF is going on ?... I think our foreign policy is becoming worst than paki's.
You don't have a clue about international diplomacy do you?
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
A few batteries? You will need at least 100 considering the size of Israel vs India.
We don't need iron dome to protect open areas. How many major cities are there within 70 kms of Pak border that can be under barrage of LeT rocket attacks?

This move is purely to negate the threat of the tactial nuke threat of Pakistan.
 

opesys

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2012
Messages
279
Likes
138
You don't have a clue about international diplomacy do you?
If you call this as diplomacy then yeah I have no clue...

India could have simply made a statement asking both of them to maintain restraint and then asked for Iron dome, no ? Doesn't this sound better ?
 

mayfair

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2010
Messages
6,032
Likes
13,109
Will USA allow the transfer even if Israel agrees? Remember Arrow II?
 

Yusuf

GUARDIAN
Super Mod
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
24,324
Likes
11,757
Country flag
If you call this as diplomacy then yeah I have no clue...

India could have simply made a statement asking both of them to maintain restraint and then asked for Iron dome, no ? Doesn't this sound better ?
Refer the thread on this topic. Those are all empty words. In all likelihood India would have told Israel in advance that we are going to say this. Dont take it to heart.
 

ganesh177

Senior Member
Joined
May 18, 2009
Messages
1,308
Likes
1,657
Country flag
Some say this latest episode of israel and gaza was a the stage for show casing Iron dome.
And here we have first potential customer.
 

opesys

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2012
Messages
279
Likes
138
Refer the thread on this topic. Those are all empty words.
Yes, I understand India is just looking into this as of now...Remember Israel is the second largest defense vendor for India so it is very likely that deal might happen if our requirements and what Iron dome has to offer matches (assuming Uncle Sam doesn't interfere)....

In all likelihood India would have told Israel in advance that we are going to say this. Dont take it to heart.
hahaha! this is the cutest thing I have ever heard :rofl:
 

lcatejas

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2010
Messages
710
Likes
256
Wts funny in this getting new tech buying or developing its don't matter if you are planned something good for the country...
 
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
29,909
Likes
48,642
Country flag
Some say this latest episode of israel and gaza was a the stage for show casing Iron dome.
And here we have first potential customer.
The negotiations for iron dome have been going on for long time before this took place.
 

drkrn

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
2,455
Likes
902
If you call this as diplomacy then yeah I have no clue...

India could have simply made a statement asking both of them to maintain restraint and then asked for Iron dome, no ? Doesn't this sound better ?
india literally give a damn about Palestine and middle east,even when we supported them muslim nations surrounding it supports pakistan only
why should we fight for the ones who supports our enemy against us?
why should we disturb our relations with israel when we need them so much today?


remeber israel & india share common problems common threats bringing them closer day by day
 

Armand2REP

CHINI EXPERT
Senior Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2009
Messages
13,811
Likes
6,734
Country flag
Don't you mean America's Iron Dome? They are paying for it.
 

Vishwarupa

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
2,438
Likes
3,600
Country flag
NEW DELHI: As Fajr V rockets rained down on Israel from battleground Gaza for a week, many Indian defense planners were keeping a close watch on the performance of Israel's Iron Dome, which is probably the only deterrent to these homegrown short-range missiles.

It was not just out of curiosity regarding one of the most effective systems against rockets, but also because of the possibility of India acquiring an indigenous version of Iron Dome.

Several months ago, the military scientists in the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) had suggested that India look at a joint development programme with Israeli firms to develop an Indian version of Iron Dome, which is touted as the most effective system against short-range missiles such as Fajr V rockets. The Indian scientists believe Israel's plight has several parallels to its threat from Pakistan as well as the vulnerability of its cities from terrorists.

The Iron Dome, according to reports, intercepted 87% of the rockets fired at Israel by the Hamas. The system, produced by Israel's Rafael Advanced Defense Systems and at work since 2011, is believed to have the capability to shoot down rockets and artillery shells with ranges of up to 70 km. The system has been shown to be effective against rockets or shells that might target populated areas.

In the Indian military establishment, the temptation for acquiring this new toy is explained by the fact that India is ringed by hostile neighbours. Pakistani terror groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) could well acquire similar capability that would threaten large groups of Indian population. Even otherwise, the strategic planners have for long been worried about the deadly effect of short-range rockets fired at Indian cities or from across the border.

Unlike ballistic missiles, against which DRDO claims to have a fairly good anti-ballistic missile shield, there is almost no protection against short-range rockets or artillery fire. DRDO is currently collaborating with Israeli firms to develop medium range surface to air missiles (MRSAMs) and LRSAMs. However, Iron Dome is in a different class all together, Israeli diplomatic sources here argue.

One of the reasons why some Indian defence planners is pushing for it is the possibility of another conflict with Pakistan, where a system like the Iron Dome might be useful to deter even conventional artillery attacks. In addition, Pakistan has developed a tactical nuclear weapon like the Nasr, which is a solid fuelled battlefield range ballistic missile. While Pakistani analysts say this was developed in anticipation of India's supposed Cold Start doctrine, some Indian sources say the Iron Dome might be an effective deterrent against this new weapon.

On the other hand, acquiring such defensive systems in anticipation of similar attacks might prove to be too much a temptation for groups like LeT. While they haven't yet developed rockets like the ones the Hamas has been using, the lure of such home-grown weaponry should not be under-estimated, say diplomatic sources.

According to sources, there have been some discussions between DRDO and their Israeli counterparts for a possible joint development of Iron Dome for India. "The Israeli team comes and works in our laboratories. Our team goes and works in their laboratories and industries. There is a learning that is taking place which was not there when we buy things and integrate with existing products... In directed energy weapons — we are focusing on fibre laser, high powered micro-waves, etc. We have also started discussions with Iron Dome for co-development (in India)," Dr W Selvamurthy, Chief Controller looking after international cooperation, told the Economic Times recently.

How it works:

* The system detects launches of rockets and quickly determines their flight path. If it is headed toward populated areas or sensitive targets, it fires an interceptor with a special warhead that strikes the incoming rocket within seconds. Rockets headed toward open areas area allowed to land.

* Currently, five Iron Dome batteries are deployed in Israel. Most are located in the south near Gaza. A fifth battery was deployed outside Tel Aviv on Saturday, two months ahead of schedule. Hours later, it shot down a rocket headed toward Tel Aviv.

*Missiles cost around $40,000 a piece. In 2010, the US provided $200 million to expand development. Additional funding is currently being considered, with $70 million already allocated for this fiscal year.

*The system is part of what Israel calls its "multilayer missile defense". It is meant to protect against the tens of thousands of short-range rockets possessed by militants in the Gaza Strip and Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon. Israel has also deployed its " Arrow" missile defense systems for long-range threats from Iran. The military says its new "David's Sling" system, being developed by Rafael to stop medium-range missiles, will be activated by 2014.

(Source: AP)

India eyes Israel's Iron Dome to counter Pak, puppets - The Times of India
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top