Search results

Are we close to a breakthrough ?

What is the current state of art regarding OIT when it comes to genetics ? @asaffronladoftherisingsun

A paper from 1989 ? "AIT happened bRUh", you must believe me. Even the fiercest academic proponents of AIT have now switched to AMT. How hard is it to accept that we simply lack the data and evidences to make final conclusions about AMT or OIT or AIT ?

LOL, "muH ubermensch guJarat" is a thing now on this thread. Guy with obvious patel surname sitting in burgerland thinks Gujarat is not India 👏👏👏. The kind of lunatics we have stumbled upon on DFI has never failed to impress me.

Pray tell what were we importing from them before the Islamic invasions ? There must be some limit to your stupidity, no ? We built our own steel, our own clothes and our own ships and they were the best in the world. Trade and exports were massive part of our economy. The only thing we imported...

Not entirely true. Shiva, Hanuman and Durga are the most worshipped gods in the belt stretching from Purvanchal in UP to Bengal including Bihar in middle. The resurgence of Shri Ram is a much recent phenomena in these parts and it has completely separate reasons behind it.

I think some people are just way too proud to accept their ignorance. No wonder this country is in such a dismal state.

Yes, the people parroting my narrative is certainly the mainstream, amirite lol ? Yup, dude just like that IVC skeleton that rose up from the dead and whispered into my ears "blonde and blue eyed Aryans invaded and destroyed IVC on 1st April 1500 BC and imposed Vedas on everybody". Totally...

If I boil down your arguments it's basically "Hurr dUrr iTs MaiNsTreaM". Come on mitra, don't try to capture the moral high ground here.

This guy, wants to learn about AIT, in absence of any Indian genetic data :playball: Anyway, read my post above, and accept your ignorance ( difficult to do if you are middle aged guy, but still try).

This is not going anywhere. We have again come full circle. As members have already seen, there is massive lack of data for this entire theory. Doesn't make it wrong or right, but certainly points out towards need of thorough research. Also, the ancient Indian DNA is unknown, how effed up is...

I accept this noble homage. Remember, I am not the one pointing to a very specific date, you are. So, obviously it's upto you to prove any point or furnish any evidence. Sadly, you haven't presented any data corroborating your claim. Don't blame me for your own failures, mitra. Not fair. As I...

Translation: Your pearls of wisdom have made our day. We are very grateful.

Inn bhaisahab ko history or opinion mein farak nahi pata chalta hai. Paragraphs aise likhte hai maano aankhon dekhi ho. Jankaari to inki bhi humari jaisi zlich hai.

What new horizons are they really exploring nowadays ?

Not even the invasion theory, but untenable timelines muddle this even more. When asked about data, people outright try to shift the goal posts. If we do not accept our ignorance, then how will we gain any knowledge.

Except the 1500BC bs AMT event, Steppe migration is fine with me. Human migration has happened since we exited Africa and still happens today. They are a crucial part of our history.

You sure ? Do you even have any idea how a R1a gene carrier looks like ? I think not. As I said R1a peaks in Brahmins (and to some degree Kshatriya) of UP, Bihar and Bengal. That's why data is needed from these high frequency regions. If genetic data prior to 1500 BC finds no R1a in this...

I asked for any data, and you furnished none. Joke is on you buddy. The R1a and R1b split happened 25000 years ago, right during the last Ice age. Did the R1a people hunkered down in modern day Turkey under ice sheets for 20000 years and then suddenly decided to sprint in all possible...

Good luck doing that given that it basically worships a river that has been dead since last 4000 years. Here, ladies and gentlemen, we see a fine move of mental gymnastics. Applause should keep coming.