Search results

Q: what exactly has pakistan won since 1999? A: Nothing

It was not a convincing test. Too many claims of the thermonuclear device having not met yield. Some claims of the thermonuclear device not triggered at all. These doubts have to be demonstrably clarified.

Stop talking nonsense man. You gave bogus numbers abt the Tsar boba, I refuted with correct numbers and you conveniently avoided addressing it and went off on a different tangent. And what scientific proof are you talking about? Your only ability in a debate is making stories and claiming...

Your wisdom is awesome, you command over math is stunning ... The P5, who amongst them have in excess of 1000 megaton warheads are nothing but ego maniacs as per you wisdom. Good night. I keep asking myself why I even pick up a conversation with you?

You need to stop smoking the peace pipe. Villages 60 KM away from the TSAR Bomba were reduced to rubble, not from fires, but shattered by the blast waves. The Tsar bomba immediate kill area is close to 10,000 sq km. The Tsar would have caused 3rd degree burns at more than 100km. DO YOUR...

Do your research kid, Im not gonna babysit you ass. 5 megatons cause 3rd degree burns at a 30 km radius. Even if you take everyone beyond 20 km radius survives with 3rd degree or worse burns, 20 km radius still translates to 1256 sq km. Elementary math. Pankaj, we do not have demonstrated...

1) We dont have demonstrated capability of 200KT 2) We dont have demonstrated capability of delivery systems more than 3.5K km. Once A5 is demonstrated, we are 5 years away from operational deployment 3) We dont have demonstrated capability of MIRV. Once MIRV is demonstrated, we are 5 years away...

All the superpower still have an active and large arsenel of megaton weapons and these are not just drop bombs but missile warheads. Lets stop fooling ourselves. I find it difficult to go with the limited wisdom of our strategists against the combined wisdom of the P-5 strategists regarding...

What I posted on the MIRV thread These are serious numbers. A 5 megatonne nuke will clean up the entire NCR region. A 200 KT nuke wont even destroy Bejing.

You are wrong Yusuf, China has megatonne warheads pointed at India as of now. Not in the past, but as of now. Please check their declared megatonne warhead estimates and the missiles they are deployed on. I have posted this before too.

It is never a question of capability. It is always a question of power projection. Google the US analysis of our tests. As per their analysis our yield from the thermonuke could not have exceeded 15 - 20 KT. Their conclusions even bordered on the fact that our thermonuke was a joke. Read this...

1) We absolutely should have. 2) We absolutely should, within the next 5 years Why? Defacto Nuclear Weapons State. More weight on the world bargaining stage. Faster UNSC reforms. Dilution of NPT / CTBT and NSG in its current discriminatory form.

So basically what you are saying is - China will do what it feels like and India cannot do squat. Thank you, you just made my whole argument credible. India's nuclear doctrine is flawed. It needs to be more aggressive.

The only way to megaton warheads is thermonuclear capability. The only way Pakistan will ever get that is if the CCP gift wraps one for them. If our intelligence confirms that, we should consider it as an act of war on part of China. Regarding arming Vietnam, my assessment is that India is just...

I'd feel safer if I knew what our readiness was in terms of timeframe.

Lol. Ok Sure, If you say so.

How do you know a Chinese state secret Yusuf. I find that extremely difficult to believe. The whole purpose of solid propellant Ballistic missiles are hot nukes in silos and submarines.

Ah, good with cliches I see. Where have I veered from the topic? Stop talking nonsense. Of course not arming Vietnam has to do a lot to do with conscience. A tit for tat is long due, but we refrain from it because as a nation we have don't need other countries to fight our wars. We gave the...

As long as CCP chooses to arm Pakistan, there is nothing India can do (except maybe arm Vietnam, but I think our country has a cleaner conscience that the Chinese). However, a high yield device will send a message of total annihilation of Pakistan should they choose to go the way of nuclear...

Yes. I dont plagiarize. And I was seething when I read the news that day.