Because on that thread no proper discussion was going on.....People were just making stories there.....Even the long post you quoted was very very badly written....Those were just speculations, support balochis, TTP, etc etc....It was like, if India supports balochis we can separate them, nothing more than that...nothing people didn't already knew....In short, it added no value and added lots of heartburn...
Actually, the thread topic was a "question". He wanted suggestions. And though his introductory statements were somewhat "emotional", he did provide some good pointers later on.
If you felt that the thread did not get good responses, then you should have gone in to the thread and provided some solid points to answer the thread starter's question.
Let me tell you - any Indian who thinks that the de-nuking and/or breakup/neutering of Pakistan is
not in Indian interest is stupid. Plain stupid.
There are no two ways about this.
And you said in the other thread, that "India should look at its own interests, and not those of Western think-tanks who advocate breakup of Pakistan". So there you were implying that breakup of Pakistan is not in Indian interest!! And now you have changed your stance. Why?
Your initial point was that we should not start such "stupid threads" so that we don't "offend the Pakis".
Hardly in line with what you're saying now, eh?
You contradict yourself quite a lot, did you realize that?