First you called me a "Fraud" now I have received a new tag "pathological liar" like Pakistanis" just because I called Naxalite supporters as Marxists
You did not call Naxalites supporters as Marxists. You said, "Leftists/Marxists start anti-govt. campaign to support Naxals."
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
What you did there was pure BS while this thread title still makes sense. There are levels of generalization where the meaning of the message still remains intact. Marxism, leftism, maoism, communism are all different levels of similar stupidity for ordinary persons(obviously in the high chambers they may disagree), the same way as BJP and Bajrang Dal are equally loathed by the sickulars. Only someone like you would cry over and over again and derail the whole thread. OTOH, the other thread you made had no remote connection with Modi or BJP. Are you telling me Marxism and Maoism have no remote connection between them?
Nothing I did is BS. You saying so does not make it BS. You have been called out in
this post, you have nothing to counter that, so just pass it off as BS.
I told you,
if you are going to use some standard to make a point, I can use the same standard to counter your point. I just did that.
If anyone is tossing obfuscations and incoherent twaddle, it is you, right from the very first post.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
Is CPI(M) sole guardian of Marxism in India?
-No
Does all Marxist support naxals?
-No
Does a large number of Marxist support naxals?
-yes
leftist=marxist=communist=maoist etc.
"You can even say airplane = helicopter = submarine = rifle. "
You can say anything. Depends on what level of generalization you are talking about. While different leftists and Marxists are very close to reach other, the example you posted has its elements very far from each other.
For some reason you think that people should answer your stupid rants which don't make sense. CPI(M) is not a thekedar of Marxism and so your first post on this thread makes little sense for justification of your position.
Just answer-
Are all CPI(M) members Marxists?
- may be
Are all Marxists CPI(M) members?
- no
Btw next time you post on dfi, just say rifle on a submarine thread and I am sure people will not understand a thing and will call you senile. But I can choose any word Marxist, commie, leftist, leftard etc. to communicate and people would get the meaning.
So stop making hill out of a mole.
Sent from my MI 3W using Tapatalk
There is nothing in your post that justifies broadbrushing Marxists.
Saying "I would extend it further to say: leftist=marxist=communist=maoist etc," is no different from saying "ISIS=BJP."
Why am I saying this? Well, ISIS has been beheading people and one BJP leader threatened to behead the Karnataka CM. So, "ISIS=BJP." (
I do not hold this view, but I am writing this to imitate your logic, and because I am debating you.)
BJP leader threatens to behead Karnataka CM if he eats beef
Some fringe elements from CPI(M)
left the party and became Naxalites, and you took the liberty to broadbrush all Marxists. By the same token, one fringe BJP leader,
still in the party, threatens to behead someone, so I can take the liberty to broadbrush all BJP supporters. (
I am doing this because I am debating you.)
A majority of the Marxists have been against the Naxalites for decades, but you chose to ignore it. Similarly, a majority of BJP leaders would not threaten to behead anyone, but I chose to ignore it. (
I am doing this because I am debating you.)
See, for the second time,
if you are going to use some standard to make a point, I can use the same standard to counter your point. I just did that.
This thread keeps getting better and better.
Btw next time you post on dfi, just say rifle on a submarine thread and I am sure people will not understand a thing and will call you senile. But I can choose any word Marxist, commie, leftist, leftard etc. to communicate and people would get the meaning.
So stop making hill out of a mole.
Sent from my MI 3W using Tapatalk
Next time you generalize to make a point, generalization could be used to counter your point (just like I ripped apart your arguments using your own logic in this thread). Then you will probably say, "stop making hill out of a mole," or invoke some abstract "levels of generalization," which frankly, is just a weasel word to wiggle out of the knot you have tied yourself into.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
@Sakal Gharelu Ustad, see the post below? This applies to you as well. You don't want to know. In other words you stubbornly choose to remain ignorant. This is exactly why you should not be commenting in this thread. Leave it to the people who know a thing or two about it.
Personally, I don't want to know and don't care about the different flavours of leftists. Marxists, Leninists, Maoists, Leftists, Communists, Stalinists, etc. etc. Same difference.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
@Sakal Gharelu Ustad, anyway, since you brought it up, might as well respond to
this post?