Indian Special Forces (archived)

Status
Not open for further replies.

aystle

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2016
Messages
172
Likes
504
Country flag
Before Surgical Strikes people questioned;

Can we kill terrorists in their camps?

We know the answer now. As you know a plan was hatched to kill Dawood but is reported to have been stopped at last minute. I hope one day we get those 2 mofos but in the mean time wont underestimate our SFs capability in doing it.
Without overseas battle experience
Before Surgical Strikes people questioned;

Can we kill terrorists in their camps?

We know the answer now. As you know a plan was hatched to kill Dawood but is reported to have been stopped at last minute. I hope one day we get those 2 mofos but in the mean time wont underestimate our SFs capability in doing it.
Lack of overseas battle experience..Our government hand over Masood Azhar..Our top Army Generals failed to play any role.. and still begging to that "Country with paper tiger Army" for International sanction..
 

tejas warrior

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
1,268
Likes
3,723
Country flag
Friends, PLEASE CIRCULATE THIS IN ALL POSSIBLE WAYS.

Folks, if you think that @YouTube's decision to cancel @delhidefence's channel is unfounded, do let them know via messages on various platforms. Thank you for your support and commitment to indigenization.

 

sthf

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
2,271
Likes
5,327
Country flag
Makes me to think how they end up winning so many competitions internationally.

And the answer is simple.Save the funds to train the 0.5% and send them for competitions.

All show..No go!!
As I said, pomp and false bravado are the standard operating procedures of communist regimes. Soviets started the whole charade and Chinis and NOKOs perfected it.
 

devhensh

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
202
Likes
378
What we really need is at least 1-2 Brigades of Infantry specialised for marine warfare structured around the US marine corps...
Indeed ! Our country has a very big coastline, and Marine model is a very good model to follow.

As per me, Marines are the best all terrian, and fully self sufficient fighting force formation in the world (non SF).
They have forces like MARSOC, Scout Sniper Program,
MEU(Marine expeditionary unit)....which are the best in world and very good models to follow...

There is an unpublished saying in USA ..."If you want to learn a trade, join the Army...If you want to learn to fight..Join the Marines"..
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,118
Likes
17,834
Country flag
Indeed ! Our country has a very big coastline, and Marine model is a very good model to follow.

As per me, Marines are the best all terrian, and fully self sufficient fighting force formation in the world (non SF).
They have forces like MARSOC, Scout Sniper Program,
MEU(Marine expeditionary unit)....which are the best in world and very good models to follow...

There is an unpublished saying in USA ..."If you want to learn a trade, join the Army...If you want to learn to fight..Join the Marines"..
Firstly,you need a big budget to keep a expeditionary unit.Requires a lot of training and different equipment.The current formation is poorly trained.

Secondly,in the Indian case the Marines would never become what they are in US coz of the simple reason that we are dealing with a internal problem more than external and all of our fights are on the himalayas.

I doubt a day would come when a Infantry unit will be handing over the LOC duties to a Marine unit.

Our policies and sissy leadership including the current one can never take strong military decisions of the kind even Indra Gandhi and Rajeev Gandhi took forget about comparing with the US.

We are beggars for justice.I know i am going to hurt many people here but its a fact.We are literary begging to get justice against Hafeez Saed.

We did nothing when parliament was attacked and when IC 814 was hijacked or even 26/11.

I am apolitical.I dont do BJP and Congress shit coz i know both lack balls.The only good thing is that BJP cares for the welfare of the soldiers.

So we should aim to defend our islands properly against a growing China trying to increase its influence.

We practically need no more that 2 brigades or maximum 3 under 1 division.

It should also contain a SF and a mini AF under the Navy for CAS.

Attack helis,A 10s,other helis etc or Osprey would be welcome.

It will require a big budget which i highly doubt we are capable of.
 

Indian Sniper.001

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2016
Messages
1,454
Likes
6,737
Country flag
Makes me to think how they end up winning so many competitions internationally.

And the answer is simple.Save the funds to train the 0.5% and send them for competitions.

All show..No go!!
IIRC, we had a discussion about the same, some pages back. They win these competitions, because the tasks are based on simulations, and they train a group precisely for that, to make other forces to be in awe of their Army. But real life scenarios are a lot more different from these created scenarios, where a soldier should be ready and willing to actually spill blood, and I don't see the chinks are ready to do that. Their only point in mind is 'intimidation'.

No wonder , these guys are bunch of cowards. I wanna watch them running away with tail b/w their legs after fierce gun battle with IA.
Its a dream for every Nationalist Indian. Hope it realizes soon.
 

Bornubus

Chodi Bhakt & BJPig Hunter
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2015
Messages
7,494
Likes
17,198





,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
 

aditya g

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2014
Messages
1,962
Likes
4,651
Country flag
Direct FB embeds don't display correctly o mobile .... Not sure if this is only for me or everyone. If you can also post the link to te story.

Furthermore, my recommendation is you post content on a blog rather than FB.


@reddevil9




''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''
 

Vinod DX9

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2017
Messages
1,356
Likes
4,410
Country flag
received_1242206209245850.jpeg

#INDRAexclusive #BallisticHelmets
#MakeInIndia #MadeInIndia
#SundaySpecial
Types of Modern Helmets in India
(1) Viper P2 Helmets : In service with SG , Navy , Patna ATS and similar will be issued to officers & commanders
(2) Advance Combat Helmet ACH of CAPFs issued by MHA
(3) TATA made ACH of PARA SF with more protection at the back side
(4) Highcut ACH of PARA SF used in special missions
(5) MKU Mukut ACH : 1.5 L ordered 50000 of them will have communication , rails & NVG mount
(6) Isreali Orlite Helmet of Para commandos
(7) PASGT helmet
(8) LWH ( Light Weight Helmet ) of CAPFs they bought few years back
(9) SRG Company made ACH with Attached rails in service with NSG
 

reddevil9

शत्रुजीत
Regular Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2016
Messages
244
Likes
1,281
#Shatrujeet_photography

#Exclusive high res Photo of Combat Free Faller (CFF) badge taken by us. This coveted badge is earned and worn by select few warriors out of 1.3 million strong Indian Army.

We will also make a separate detailed post on Combat Free Fallers


Sent from my Redmi Note 4 using Tapatalk
 

rkhanna

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2014
Messages
3,274
Likes
12,187
Country flag
View attachment 22060
#INDRAexclusive #BallisticHelmets
#MakeInIndia #MadeInIndia
#SundaySpecial
Types of Modern Helmets in India
(1) Viper P2 Helmets : In service with SG , Navy , Patna ATS and similar will be issued to officers & commanders
(2) Advance Combat Helmet ACH of CAPFs issued by MHA
(3) TATA made ACH of PARA SF with more protection at the back side
(4) Highcut ACH of PARA SF used in special missions
(5) MKU Mukut ACH : 1.5 L ordered 50000 of them will have communication , rails & NVG mount
(6) Isreali Orlite Helmet of Para commandos
(7) PASGT helmet
(8) LWH ( Light Weight Helmet ) of CAPFs they bought few years back
(9) SRG Company made ACH with Attached rails in service with NSG
IMO between 1 / 2 / 5
1 -> Navy (VBSS + MARCOS) + Mech Soldiers + Tank Crews + SG and other SMU + Urban CT (NSG/ATS etc)
2 -> For all SOF units - SHould have the picatinny rails added on and fabric camo (not the stupid condoms we have on now)
5 -> All Line Infantry + CAPF units
 

aditya g

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2014
Messages
1,962
Likes
4,651
Country flag
Just read this critique (rant?) by Saikat Datta on the handling of building intervention at EDI Pampore in 2016:

https://scroll.in/article/804082/de...n-raise-urgent-questions-about-tactics-vision

In February 21, three men from the India Army’s elite Special Forces lost their lives while trying to evict two terrorists from Pampore’s Entrepreneurship Development Institute in the Kashmir valley. The deaths of Captain Pawan Kumar, Captain Tushar Mahajan and Lance Naik Om Prakash are tragic, but also raises several questions that urgently need answers.

Officers among the Rashtriya Rifles formations, a force that is permanently situated in Jammu and Kashmir for counter insurgency operations, said that several inexplicable decisions were taken during the Pampore operation that led to the sudden rise in casualties.

“In any hostage rescue operation in a multi-storied building, it is key that the commandos enter the building from multiple entry points simultaneously to achieve surprise,” said a senior Special Forces army officer in the area. “In this case the team commander of 10 Para (SF) had requested for time to plan the operation and ensure a simultaneous multiple entry into the EID building, but this was denied by the senior commanders.” The officer requested anonymity since he is not authorised to speak.

An officer in the Rashtriya Rifles formation deployed under Victor Force (the formation dedicated for operation in the Kashmir Valley region) confirmed this. “Ideally, the men should have cordoned the area and conducted the operation in day light,” he said. The rush into the building at night, he contended, “can be dangerous and this probably cost Pawan his life”.

Tactical error

Most Special Forces veterans who are familiar with such operations pointed out that entering a building from the top is a standard precaution that is taken along with a simultaneous multiple-entry to gain tactical advantage. “If take the higher ground, you have the tactical advantage and as you rush in using multiple entry points, you overwhelm the enemy,” said a former SF veteran, who retired as a Lieutenant General a few years ago.

The fact that a helicopter was not used to land the SF team on the roof has also perplexed many SF veterans. “A dedicated squadron of Advanced Light Helicopters is usually kept at the disposal of the SF teams in Udhampur,” the former General pointed out. ”They could have been used to land the team on the roof. This was done during the 26/11 operations in Mumbai at Chabad House.”

Several other officers who are familiar with the Pampore operation agreed that the lives of Captain Kumar, Mahajan and Lance Naik Om Prakash could have been saved if these tactics had been followed. While 10 Para (SF) took the lead in trying to flush out the terrorists, a team from 9 Para (SF) was rushed in to aid their operations. This team also did not intervene from the roof or use multiple entry points, leading to another casualty.

....​
 

COLDHEARTED AVIATOR

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2016
Messages
4,118
Likes
17,834
Country flag
Just read this critique (rant?) by Saikat Datta on the handling of building intervention at EDI Pampore in 2016:

https://scroll.in/article/804082/de...n-raise-urgent-questions-about-tactics-vision

In February 21, three men from the India Army’s elite Special Forces lost their lives while trying to evict two terrorists from Pampore’s Entrepreneurship Development Institute in the Kashmir valley. The deaths of Captain Pawan Kumar, Captain Tushar Mahajan and Lance Naik Om Prakash are tragic, but also raises several questions that urgently need answers.

Officers among the Rashtriya Rifles formations, a force that is permanently situated in Jammu and Kashmir for counter insurgency operations, said that several inexplicable decisions were taken during the Pampore operation that led to the sudden rise in casualties.

“In any hostage rescue operation in a multi-storied building, it is key that the commandos enter the building from multiple entry points simultaneously to achieve surprise,” said a senior Special Forces army officer in the area. “In this case the team commander of 10 Para (SF) had requested for time to plan the operation and ensure a simultaneous multiple entry into the EID building, but this was denied by the senior commanders.” The officer requested anonymity since he is not authorised to speak.

An officer in the Rashtriya Rifles formation deployed under Victor Force (the formation dedicated for operation in the Kashmir Valley region) confirmed this. “Ideally, the men should have cordoned the area and conducted the operation in day light,” he said. The rush into the building at night, he contended, “can be dangerous and this probably cost Pawan his life”.

Tactical error

Most Special Forces veterans who are familiar with such operations pointed out that entering a building from the top is a standard precaution that is taken along with a simultaneous multiple-entry to gain tactical advantage. “If take the higher ground, you have the tactical advantage and as you rush in using multiple entry points, you overwhelm the enemy,” said a former SF veteran, who retired as a Lieutenant General a few years ago.

The fact that a helicopter was not used to land the SF team on the roof has also perplexed many SF veterans. “A dedicated squadron of Advanced Light Helicopters is usually kept at the disposal of the SF teams in Udhampur,” the former General pointed out. ”They could have been used to land the team on the roof. This was done during the 26/11 operations in Mumbai at Chabad House.”

Several other officers who are familiar with the Pampore operation agreed that the lives of Captain Kumar, Mahajan and Lance Naik Om Prakash could have been saved if these tactics had been followed. While 10 Para (SF) took the lead in trying to flush out the terrorists, a team from 9 Para (SF) was rushed in to aid their operations. This team also did not intervene from the roof or use multiple entry points, leading to another casualty.

....​
Its not a rant.

Its the truth.Higher ups are to be blammed.I have written about this many times here as some people always bring this op to criticise Para SF.

After this op there was a big change in the tactics of dealing with such ops.
 

abingdonboy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
8,039
Likes
33,588
Country flag
Its not a rant.

Its the truth.Higher ups are to be blammed.I have written about this many times here as some people always bring this op to criticise Para SF.

After this op there was a big change in the tactics of dealing with such ops.
But don't you think this incident highlights a worrying element- the complete "night blindness" of Indian forces, particuarly of the SFs. The RR officer says the ops should've been conducted in the day light, surely this gives an equal advantadge to the terrorists?

Western SFs almost exclusively operate at night, during 2003 Iraq investigations top tier NATO SF teams would go "hunting" conducting dozens of raids in the darkness only and would rest during the day. We've seen many times that security forces in J&K call off operations during the night time this gives the enemy time to slip away and it's concerning that Indian SFs aren't getting up to speed in night time CQB, this should be the ideal time to carry out ops.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top