Imported Single Engine Fighter Jet Contest

AmoghaVarsha

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2016
Messages
1,372
Likes
2,093
Country flag
I agree with you that we have to import some weapons to fight a war ..But what I am saying is when single engine Tejas is available then why go for single engine f 16 , when we are developing amca then why go for f 35 , I have no problem in buying 200 rafales because we don't have anything in that class...But when indigenous product is available it should be given priority over foreign one...
AMCA is on paper.There is no timeline when it will be inducted.Shall we wait or should we be ready with F 35s to take on PLAAF?

Lets be honest,F16 block 70 is far more capable than a LCA.The LCA has got orders for 120 planes.Let that be fulfilled.In a war the capability of the plane will matter not its origin.
 

Aghore_King

Regular Member
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
460
Likes
1,121
Country flag
OK but we should not completely abandon our domestic projects for the sake of foreign fighters...Let ADA develop amca and provide them all necessary funds even if we're buying f 35..
 

Aghore_King

Regular Member
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
460
Likes
1,121
Country flag
Do you know we can flood the iaf with LCA in amount we are going to spend on 90 f 16 s and not to mention we will get first f 16 only in 2019 (maybe even latter) ...By then LCA mk 2 will be ready...
 

mendosa

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2017
Messages
382
Likes
1,402
F16 manufacturing lines are going to be shifted to India. If India opts for F16, India will cater the spare parts to the entire world.

By opting to F16, India will nullify the Pakistani advantage, we also have LCA, Su 30 MKI and Rafales.
Weapons sales are more political than technical.

Once you buy the F16, the US will start selling submarines and aircraft carriers to Pakistan so that you can then buy a bigger submarine and aircraft carrier to nullify it. In the process they will nullify India.
 

Aghore_King

Regular Member
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
460
Likes
1,121
Country flag
Weapons sales are more political than technical.

Once you buy the F16, the US will start selling submarines and aircraft carriers to Pakistan so that you can then buy a bigger submarine and aircraft carrier to nullify it. In the process they will nullify India.
Exactly , just see the track record of US on decimating its allies domestic capabilities Japan, UK , Canada, Australia
 

mendosa

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2017
Messages
382
Likes
1,402
Lets be honest,F16 block 70 is far more capable
Saying "Let's be honest" is not a suitable substitute for making a factual point.

No one here is saying that LCA is a better plane than F16. However, air fighting is not like arm wrestling. Planes don't fight it out feature versus feature. If it was, then instead of pilots, scientists would have fought wars on paper. Suddenly one scientist develops a new system, BAM! all other planes have lost the battle now!

A fighter is just one gear in a large war fighting machinery. The goal of war is not to get the most expensive gold plated gear. Planes are chosen based on doctrine and current air defense matrix, which involves ground radar, missile defense system, economic warfare, cyber warfare and diplomatic clout to shape global events.

If one gets in the business of getting the most expensive weapon every time, the budget will run out pretty soon.

@Pinky Chaudhary is right. For the price of one F16, you can have multiple LCAs. Is a single F16 better than multiple LCAs which we can replace it with? once we have many planes in the air, even the enemy gets the pressure to induct more planes to tackle our fleet. In order for this quantity war to be won, one cannot buy expensive shit all the time. Create one squadron with a long range radar Rafale leading the pack of 18 LCAs sharing radar data with them via tactical link. The LCAs can be used as missile carrying trucks.

By your logic, China should have given up its aspiration to be a world player, given that Chinese equipment is low quality and cheap. Or should China also stand in line to buy 500 F16s? The more you rely on other countries to solve your problems, the more your foreign policy becomes beholden to them. A fighter jet is not a knife. They can block access to spares whenever they want, so even if it were a better plane, it would be useless to us if it is made unavailable due to political disagreements.

This is the same country that blocked GPS signals during Kargil. People here have some short memories.
 

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
3,890
Likes
8,780
Country flag
LCA 1a, F16, Rafale, Mirage 2000 and MIG 29 have different role. None of them kills the others role. To top it all the grand Daddy of all Su30mk1 has the pivotal role in air offence.

So bear it in mind none of them is going to kill either LCA -2 or AMCA. Built on Indian technology alone AMCA is ten years away. With no hope of reviving PAK FA deal, effort should be redoubled to get F35, although US will be reluctant to give it to non NATO members.


F 16 will kill lca

F 35 will kill amca

Pak Fa will kill something else.


How are we supposed to keep the numbers and technology in IAF without buying foreign planes?AMCA is on paper while lca still lacks FOC.

Will the enemy wait till we get indigenious tech ready?

War has to be fought with weapons no matter local or imported.We are at the best 10yrs away from one.
 

AmoghaVarsha

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2016
Messages
1,372
Likes
2,093
Country flag
All this F 16 killing LCA F35 killing AmCA reminds me that since 1947 till 1991-92 this same fear mongering kept India as a closed economy and we regressed economically in respect to China.

Again this same thinking will kill our armed forces in comparision to China.Ultimately JVs between Indian and foreign manufacturers will strenthen our defence industry.
 

lcafanboy

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2013
Messages
5,866
Likes
37,781
Country flag
Do you know we can flood the iaf with LCA in amount we are going to spend on 90 f 16 s and not to mention we will get first f 16 only in 2019 (maybe even latter) ...By then LCA mk 2 will be ready...
May I Know...........HOW?

And will that LCA have advance AESA radar maybe with GaN, CFT, Internat EW suit, Range, Weapons load capacity and several other things?

Please add these things to LCA and see the cost of LCA and then say this. Do you know SU30mki made in India by HAL costs more than direct import? Now compare & say what you said again......
 

square

Strategic Issues
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2016
Messages
1,636
Likes
1,464
so basically , india want f35 and US pushing for f16.....and this logic of gradual shift is just bullshit coz if we buy f16 then next purchase will take another 20 year later....

but one intresting observation ,...

if iaf looking for f35 , then its confirm that fgfa with russia is completly writeoff...
 
Last edited:

Filtercoffee

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
615
Likes
214
Country flag
so basically , india want f35 and US pushing for f16.....and this logic of gradual shift is just bullshit coz if we buy f16 then next purchase will take another 20 year later....

but one intresting observation ,...

if iaf looking for f35 , then its confirm that fgfa with russia is completly writeoff...
The hypersonic MIG 41 is better option over LM and Sukhoi.
 

SanjeevM

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2017
Messages
1,631
Likes
4,503
Country flag
so basically , india want f35 and US pushing for f16.....and this logic of gradual shift is just bullshit coz if we buy f16 then next purchase will take another 20 year later....

but one intresting observation ,...

if iaf looking for f35 , then its confirm that fgfa with russia is completly writeoff...
But it makes one thing clear that Modi asked for F35 production lines but was asked to start with f16, then move to F35.

It's a total dependence contingent upon India working with U.S. against common enemy. In case India doesn't, F35 may not come. We stop working with Russia on FGFA, don't work on AMCA, we are gone. We need to have all the options open. Continue on war scale on Tejas, AMCA and other options.
 

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
3,890
Likes
8,780
Country flag
so basically , india want f35 and US pushing for f16.....and this logic of gradual shift is just bullshit coz if we buy f16 then next purchase will take another 20 year later....

but one intresting observation ,...

if iaf looking for f35 , then its confirm that fgfa with russia is completly writeoff...

I feel gradual shift is a better option than sudden F35 purchase at triple the cost and with no certainty that plane will be ready to be operational in three years, software troubles apart.
 

airtel

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2015
Messages
3,430
Likes
7,815
Country flag
I feel gradual shift is a better option than sudden F35 purchase at triple the cost and with no certainty that plane will be ready to be operational in three years, software troubles apart.
LOL for gradual shift we will have to spend billions of $ on F-16 .
and F-35 is a Good Plane dont believe on propaganda .
 

hit&run

United States of Hindu Empire
Mod
Joined
May 29, 2009
Messages
14,104
Likes
63,374
Was MRCA tender issued to kill LCA ?

Why people are conflating two separate procurements ?
 

square

Strategic Issues
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2016
Messages
1,636
Likes
1,464
I feel gradual shift is a better option than sudden F35 purchase at triple the cost and with no certainty that plane will be ready to be operational in three years, software troubles apart.
this f35 couid also be a denial tectics by govt to make any perchase at all ....one this clear , tejas will be the only single engine as of now...
 

square

Strategic Issues
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2016
Messages
1,636
Likes
1,464
But it makes one thing clear that Modi asked for F35 production lines but was asked to start with f16, then move to F35.

It's a total dependence contingent upon India working with U.S. against common enemy. In case India doesn't, F35 may not come. We stop working with Russia on FGFA, don't work on AMCA, we are gone. We need to have all the options open. Continue on war scale on Tejas, AMCA and other options.
fighter aircrafts are expensive , and those who produce them are unwilling to share tech ,...export versions are highly downgraded......

tejas and amca are THE only option ....

tajas is almost there....

presently what we looking is the 5g tech for amca and tejas m2 , either from russis ,US or france.....and willing to spend too.......seem everybody is just playing a wait and watch presently....
 
Last edited:

smestarz

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
1,929
Likes
1,056
Country flag
We would prefer the technology, not the plane (F-16)
India's best bet for MAKE IN INDIA, is Tejas, But importantly we have to get an engine which we can put on any plane and export to any country we want to without any restrictions. That will truly be Make in India as it should be,

Let us for a moment assume that we take F-16 Block 70.. would we be able to sell to countries like Vietnam, Taiwan or other countries without restriction? We cannot. The Americans have themselves avoided giving Taiwan F-16 because they dont want to upset China. Also any plane we export will be needing USA permission. Thus F-16 will only bring planes for IAF and potential overhaul hub for other users and cheaper spares. But importantly .. WE CANNOT EXPORT IT.
On other hand, Tejas with our own Kaveri engine, and UTTAM AESA, we can export it to Friendly countries and make defence pact with these countries. Thus becoming stronger as a force.
 

Aghore_King

Regular Member
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
460
Likes
1,121
Country flag
Americans will eat up our own indigenous aircraft industry... better buy 200 plus rafales from France....
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top