China objects to oil hunt, India says back off

[LETHALFORCE]

This government doesn't stand up for fellow Indians in Ladakh, how would they stand up for Vietnam in South China sea. First let's see the government become more aggressive against the Chinese intrusion into Indian territory, then we can dream about stopping intrusion into South China Sea.

petty intrusions and a naval base and gifting Prithvis and brahmos are hardly comprable.

 

[Dovah]

The point is we are not claiming moon but SCS.

Chinese claims hover on the border of absurdity, if every nation starts to tow the PRC line there won't be a political map of the world.

 

[pmaitra]

Do we care how you are gonna repsond after we cut off your exploration? No. You can send your blue navy to SCS to escort your ships if you want to, we won't mind sinking them if they show up in Chinese waters.

Compared to sinking naval ships from Vietnam who stakes claims to those waters, we would rather sink some naval ships from an irrelevant country like India. In fact, it is a much better way to demonstrate our sovereignty over SCS.

Kind to remind you guys, we don't claim the whole SCS, if you want to pass through the international waters, be our guest.

You are talking as if sinking an Indian Navy ship is a piece of cake, isn't it? You will trigger off the 3rd World War that way.

Anything can be made disputed by creating a dispute about it. I can start a dispute about the entire territory of PRC and then the whole PRC becomes disputed. These are very juvenile arguments. The way I see it, PRC will make a lot of noise but will shy away from direct confrontation. PLAN might make dangerous manoeuvers near Indian Navy ships, but they will think twice before sinking one.

 

[nimo_cn]

we are there and you can't do anything.All talk that's about it.

WPR Article | Vietnam, India Boost Naval Ties to Counter China

Not really, the presence of Indian navy in SCS is like the presence of PLAN in Indian sea, if you want to call what you are doing something breakthrough and fool yourself, that is your choice.

Next time, do something like exploring oil in the waters claimed by China, then you get something to boast.

 

[LETHALFORCE]

we are in SCS, we are gifting weapons to Vietnam,we are exploring oil, we are working on a naval base. I don't see China stopping any of this?? Minister currently in Vietnam furthering ties .

http://www.asiantribune.com/news/2011/09/14/krishna-heading-vietnam-assertive-china-mind

 

[johnee]

You are talking as if sinking an Indian Navy ship is a piece of cake, isn't it? You will trigger off the 3rd World War that way.

Anything can be made disputed by creating a dispute about it. I can start a dispute about the entire territory of PRC and then the whole PRC becomes disputed. These are very juvenile arguments. The way I see it, PRC will not make a lot of noise but will shy away from direct confrontation. PLAN might make dangerous manoeuvers near Indian Navy ships, but they will think twice before sinking one.

The point is the CCP bluffs too much and nobody knows how far is too far in regard to India. So, they may be emboldened to try this once but there is great chance it may heavily backfire. We never know.

 

[LETHALFORCE]

The point is the CCP bluffs too much and nobody knows how far is too far in regard to India. So, they may be emboldened to try this once but there is great chance it may heavily backfire. We never know.

Russians,USA and Japan are also in SCS, we are part of an anti-China alliance if it gives you comfort.

http://defenceforumindia.com/asia-p...ce/23766-india-usa-protect-vietnam-china.html

 

[nimo_cn]

Chinese claims hover on the border of absurdity, if every nation starts to tow the PRC line there won't be a political map of the world.

I am tired of discussing the legitimacy of our claims over our territories, after all none of these is your business, what matters here if we are claiming. If you think China won't cut off the ships if there is gonna be any because you have questioned our claims, send those ships there, in fact many Chinese like me are looking forward to that.

 

[LETHALFORCE]

China has not been able to implement one China policy when it comes to Taiwan ,so the world accepts it is just more hot air from China.

 

[Dovah]

I am tired of discussing the legitimacy of our claims over our territories, after all none of these is your business,

A very sane argument.

 

[sandeepdg]

Maybe soon we are gonna hear something like the cable of Indian oil exploration ship got cut off by Chinese Coast Guard,

Yeah, and we may also hear, that damn Chinese Coast guard got bashed up badly by the Vietnamese Navy for their stupid provoking actions against a friendly ally.

 

[nimo_cn]

You are talking as if sinking an Indian Navy ship is a piece of cake, isn't it? You will trigger off the 3rd World War that way..

Have you thought about the 3rd World War when you send that naval ship to waters claimed by China?

Don't threaten us with the 3rd World War, we have been threatened enough times by someone much much stronger than you. And to be honest, I don't think there is gonna be anything like 3rd World War if we sink an Indian naval ship in Chinese waters. That is something bond to happen when you send a naval ship another country's waters, everyone knows it, including Indian naval officers.

Anything can be made disputed by creating a dispute about it. I can start a dispute about the entire territory of PRC and then the whole PRC becomes disputed. These are very juvenile arguments.

That is not something India can decide.

The way I see it, PRC will make a lot of noise but will shy away from direct confrontation. PLAN might make dangerous manoeuvers near Indian Navy ships, but they will think twice before sinking one.

No, we will not shy away if it is in our waters.

 

[nimo_cn]

Yeah, and we may also hear, that damn Chinese Coast guard got bashed up badly by the Vietnamese Navy for their stupid provoking actions against a friendly ally.

We cut off them twice, nothing had happened.

 

[Iamanidiot]

Have you thought about the 3rd World War when you send that naval ship to waters claimed by China?

Don't threaten us with the 3rd World War, we have been threatened enough times by someone much much stronger than you. And to be honest, I don't think there is gonna be anything like 3rd World War if we sink an Indian naval ship in Chinese waters. That is something bond to happen when you send a naval ship another country's waters, everyone knows it, including Indian naval officers.



That is not something India can decide.



No, we will not shy away if it is in our waters.

This is a bit too imaginary.You guys will claim the whole world if geven a chance.The Nazis of the 21'st century

 

[nimo_cn]

China has not been able to implement one China policy when it comes to Taiwan ,so the world accepts it is just more hot air from China.

Keep on bolstering the morale of your men.

 

[LETHALFORCE]

http://channel6newsonline.com/2011/09/indonesia-and-vietnam-sign-joint-naval-agreement/

Indonesia and Vietnam sign joint naval agreement

Cutting China off in the South China sea seems to be the global focus??

 

[LETHALFORCE]

http://channel6newsonline.com/2011/09/indonesia-and-vietnam-sign-joint-naval-agreement/

Indonesia and Vietnam sign joint naval agreement

Cutting China off in the South China sea seems to be the global focus??

 

[sandeepdg]

You will kill our economy, you will build a base in Vietnam, "will" is the key word here.

Well, I will quote you on that !

we will cut off the cable or even sink the ship if necessary, we have done that before, and the ships being cut off were not from Vietnam.

Let's see you do that and then see what happens, sweet heart ! Some fireworks that you will find hard to digest for sure !

 

[nimo_cn]

This is a bit too imaginary.You guys will claim the whole world if geven a chance.The Nazis of the 21'st century

We don't claim the whole world, SCS isn't the whole whole world. We only claim what belongs to us, and we are not claiming the whole SCS, either.

If China can be called Nazi just because China is having territory disputes with neighbors, India is just the second Nazi,

 

[sandeepdg]

We cut off them twice, nothing had happened.

You haven't done anything to an Indian ship as yet. And SCS waters are disputed, you are not the only claimant to them. They are also claimed by the Philippines, Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam and Malaysia as well.