Iamanidiot
Senior Member
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2009
- Messages
- 5,325
- Likes
- 1,504
Sir will the Chinese War Zone Campaign work wrt to IndiaI never said that we will enter Tibet...you just assumed.
Sir will the Chinese War Zone Campaign work wrt to IndiaI never said that we will enter Tibet...you just assumed.
That is exactly what I said in starting only.Galaxy,
You must remember the deploybility factor in those areas. We can have formations bunched up like sardines in a can.
When you mention strike corps - then you must have all the assets that go with it.
But why do we need a strike corps in Arunachal? What is our military aim? A strike corps strikes into the enemy - do we have the overall ability and political will to take a fight into China. No.
Our aim is to ensure "no PLA invasion". For this we have holding formations and strategic assets in place.
Stupid OPOBJ the only thing that will happen is blood shed.to even partly achieve that we need to pump our economy and infra drasticallyThat is exactly what I said in starting only.
Our Defence in N-E is based on defensive strategy and to defend A.P., It's all due to political reason which i agree.
I am sure, we can defend in N-E with current capability and my only point was "We should work on offensive strategy to enter Tibet and try for win" and as per next 5 year plan, Our defence will be quite strong enough to actually implement such strategy of course if backed with political will.
If India can live with Kashmir and maoists, I am sure China can live with a couple monks burning themselves from time to time.We haven't even fired a shot and your Tibetian province is in unrest
There are a thousand ways to cook a goose and all do not need a fire Sun Tzu might not have taught you this nor Confucius
India largely does not get international attention for its deeds can't say the same for China..Burning monks screw the psyche of the population and he is a good symbol of protest against the corrupt CCP official who raped one's only daughter or illegally organ farmed someones father .The kashmiri infiltrator does not inspire Romanticism of the burning monk in the peoples hearts nor the Maoists who do not hurt Civilians.All it takes is a division to wipe out the Maoists the only thing stopping is Human Rights and humanity.If India can live with Kashmir and maoists, I am sure China can live with a couple monks burning themselves from time to time.
(Not learned from Sun Zi or Kongfuzi).
Sir,Its just for the Chinese ears. We have been doing everything including planning and preparing for a 2 front war and raising mountain divisions, acquiring light artillery and stationing front line fighters to fight against China. For the first time ever we are preparing for offensive role. So i dont think MMS is giving a clean chit like Nehru.
I dont need to..the Indian service personal on this forum know what I am referring to. You dont need to know.Could you elaborate little more on your claim, what is exactly India's capability to launch an offensive attack on a country that has:
So are we a nuclear power.(1)been a nuclear power for half a century
You cannot deploy all of them against us. So chill.(2)a standing army of 2.3 million people with a 50 million strong militia as backup (in the past probably fewer thse days)
Making knock-offs for the western markets - of no consequence in a war.(3)likely world's largest manufacturer this year
We count in the top 10 too and we are a trillion dollar economy also.(4)world's 2nd largest economy
So was the US by the Vietnamese beat them eh!(5)world's largest energy producer/consumer
So are we. We produce alomost same amount of food as China.(6)world's largest food producer
So was the US, but did that defeat the Viet Cong?(7)by far the world's largest steel producing country with 600 million tons annually
That's a joke, you already have someone shouting East Turkmainistan and Tibet.(8) a very homogenous population of 1.3 billion people
Irrelevant to and Sino-Indian conflict.(9)a huge strategic depth measureing 5000km from east to west and 5000km from north to south
The US had the best arms industry, but did that defeat the Viet Cong?(10)a vast indigenous defence industry
It worked in 1962.Sir will the Chinese War Zone Campaign work wrt to India
Even if China attacks from GB/Aksai Chin into Uttrakhand/H.P./J&K or from east front into Sikkim/A.P., Then also there will be lots of blood shed and we will suffer major loss in air-strike.Stupid OPOBJ the only thing that will happen is blood shed.to even partly achieve that we need to pump our economy and infra drastically
Neither Kashmiries nor the Maoists are fighting for separation. But Tibetans are fighting for independence and succession. There is lot of difference my boy !If India can live with Kashmir and maoists, I am sure China can live with a couple monks burning themselves from time to time.
(Not learned from Sun Zi or Kongfuzi).
Even if China attacks from GB/Aksai Chin into Uttrakhand/H.P./J&K or from east front into Sikkim/A.P., Then also there will be lots of blood shed and we will have suffer major loss in air-strike.
What we do ?? Attack into 300 Km empty land of Tibet ?
This is 2011 and not 1962 or 1967.
That was because Nehru believed Zhou Enlai's assurances and 1962 is basis of WZC. Will WZC work again?.The Japanese Pearl harbour act is also something similar to WZC sir looking in hindsightIt worked in 1962.
No, We cannot as of now. I didn't even said we can. It's simply not possible.Type anything here keeping logistics in mind."Can we pull this act with our current capacity?" Professionals think logistics
This will happen largely due to their own actions and Chinese aren't the only smart people on EarthIn order to deal with China, India will not attack at their strengths but weaknesses. so Tibet will contineu to fester and there will be incresing levels of insurgency in Tibet and Xinjiang.
Pakistan, the proxy of China in the subcontinent will be decimated.
India will win over Nepal, BD and Myanmar besides SL and Maldives.
All efforts of China to bypass Malacca strait, their weakness, through Pakistan will be thwarted or held hostage.
China's soft belly, the SCS will be contested.
China will be consigned to the status of an Asian Land Force but not a competing air and Neval power.
If one could achieve that, China will be fus fus...
and pray, I say why not, since we are in South Tibet as Chinese say.I never said that we will enter Tibet...you just assumed.
To my mind, if India can frustrate Chinese efforts to link with Bangladesh through Siliguri Corridor in a high intensity war scenarios and therby open routes of supply through bay of Bengal, we would have thwarted major Chinese land threat.This will happen largely due to their own actions and Chinese aren't the only smart people on Earth
Zhou Enlai did not give any assurances, Nehru was trying to appease the Chinese Primier. It was the forward movement of placing border out posts and constant patrol clashes that prompted the Chinese to "teach India a lesson".That was because Nehru believed Zhou Enlai's assurances and 1962 is basis of WZC. Will WZC work again?.The Japanese Pearl harbour act is also something similar to WZC sir looking in hindsight