Search results

You know, I could answer you honestly and even try to follow your thinking but I've come to realization that you're just a troll. Anything I say will matter not one bit. You'll just grab a bit of narvana to throw me off. I asked that had you've shed blood. It is obvious that you did not. I...

Neither does the UK and France and the Americans and Russians are in the process of withdrawing theirs from service.

Hardened targets required accuracy as well as high yield, ie missile silos or command centres like Cheyene Mountain. In the case of the Chinese, they got lazy and never replaced their big 3 MT warheads with smaller MIRV versions. India is not going to hit hardened targets. Too few missiles and...

I was following the conversation before this. Now? I give up. It's too early to leave work for a shot of GLENLIVET.

What? What? I presented Stuart to give you some idea about your country's nuclear decision policies. I am certainly not an Indian decision maker nor in any position to influence any Indian policy.

My whiskey tango foxtrot is more in confusion than frustration. Maybe if I took a few shots of whisky than it might start to make sense.

I have absolutely zero clue from where you're coming from. You effect the enivronment that you are in. Those outside of your environment you let go to someone else. In other words, I let those who can do their jobs better than I could do their jobs to do their jobs. To effect the nuclear...

Whiskey Tango Foxtrot.

I have absolutely no idea what you're trying to say. You're saying that you have shed blood? Like I said before, it's hard not to imagine schools being burned when it is right next door to a nuclear target. That's why nuclear war should be revolting. It is revolting. There were drills when I...

As a military result, none. Why? I've called nuclear war exactly for what it is for over 20 years - burning babies. There is no need to sugarcoat the intended effect of attacking cities. Those who cannot imagine babies burning alive should have no place discussing a nuclear exchange ... and...

*** Sigh *** Do you know the Chinese has a recessed arsenal?

There's only one way to control cholera - clean water. Anyone who tells you different haven't seen a refugee camp.

Dead is dead. What is the difference between dying by cholera or dying by radiation poisoning? The only thing I'm seeing here is that you want that Chinese baby to burn instead of starving to death.

Data changes as does policy but what Ashley has done is to come out and explain why NFU was devised and he showed that there is real thinking and real policy behind NFU as part of a deterrence package. It's not boilerplate token to be abandon at the earliest oppertunity. The purpose of the...

Can we get some semblance of reality here?

I have never addressed testing here. And in fact, I have stated that India will need to test in the future when her arsenal become an aged problem. Since India has not signed the NPT nor the CTBT, then it is clearly within her right to do so (although she should expect penalties from both the US...

Nice side stepping the issue. And obviously, you have not checked the link. Ashley J Tellis is the open source authority on Indian nuclear matters and if you have checked his footnotes, which is immaculate using open Indian sources, then it is clear how he arrives at his conclusions. And...

The fact you haven't nuked each other would suggest thinking along the same lines. Ashley J Tellis did a fantastic study in the link I provided but I am going to provide a summary of his point by another India watcher, Sumit Ganguly I had thought of that. Would the Pakistanis actually be...

Israeli nukes is a topic of hot debate, even within the IC and nuclear intel community. Just how advance is it ... or actually how primitive is it? The lack of positive yield tests would certainly put into question just how reliable is the arsenal if not the design. I could bring up a whole...

It was the Israelis who were scared sh!tless