Search results

I am interested not in the nukes as weapons. I also dont believe they are controllable once started. In fact i suspect everybody knows this and that is why MAD was successful. My only real concern is about the fact that our masses are not properly educated about these issues. That may...

I respect your views about my views. I knew my views are just that... views. That is why I have put in enough caveats in the post your reply refers to. I also submit that I am not in the same class as Gen. Sunderji....The intention was never there. Boond boond se ghada bharta hai. My ideas...

What is inevitable is for god to know. Indians cannot say time out at the time the eventuality becomes Inevitability. Wiser to err on the side to safety by keeping the tools handy and ready and ready for use and getting our own (Indian Populace's) mind clear about the need and importance of...

Yes pop centers are first step (sufficient deterrent too) but it would be a lot better if PLA is wiped out and Lay Chinese lives, that gives an entirely new dimension to the whole idea. That is why perhaps the doctrine should be refined further and of course with it all that goes with it. I...

Come Antimony. You are comparing me to this guy... Are you an Indian. If you are have you not found anything in its culture about the whys and wherefores of war. Come to think of it I was considering the diaspora the reserve Indian strength (Corsham, Cheyene....) 1) Amanullah is a war...

At that time Indians had no choice. But better late then never. Thanks will read this.

Ok Antimony lets call it a day. The only intelligent Sinic is gone and the rest two arent as intelligent.

I agree Stuart is your baby. It may or may not have some bearing on Indian policy makers. Only time can tell that. One thing is sure though these policy makers are going to take a major portion of there ideas from the rough and tumble of Indian life. If we dont demand better security we wont...

I will have to read about him... What I see pratyaksh is the thing for which i seek no pramand

At an individual level even your executioner will not be cussing you. Societys, Groups of people, Countries become an all together new organism. Hindus and Muslims never hurt each other still they keep fighting in every riot. (1)About the other points you will have to look deeper into the...

Esclation (In history, in present and in future) I am saying it is inevitable. To avoid esclation we will have to change the whole universe. It would be better to let things esclate so everybody is forced to take a stake in maintaining the balance. This is what happened in history is already...

Everybody avoided it because everybody wanted to avoid it. The need to live was greater then the will to kill the other. This is how they struck balance. This is the only way balance can be struck again. Keep changing the variables. If they are so pragmatic then why did they let the...

Are we talking about an environment or many test tubes. Let everybody do what they feel is necessary and let the outcome belong to ....... If things are so disparate and disjoint then what is the point of your throwing Stuart at others forum members. They dont carry any command either...

We are all entitled to our views. As I see it Stuart is just another inequation. At least up until now.

Sir I do under the cut and thrust. I have been talking with him for well over two months. He wants to avoid it. I know it cannot be avoided (not by man alone). It would rather be a better idea to understand the environment and work accordingly. And till the time we are safe just brace for the...

Too fast for you. I know... try catching up

Weapons dont fight, Militaries do. Militaries dont fight Countries do. Countries dont fight ideas do. Desirability of attaining Military objectives are absolutely and unequivocably dependent on the these ideas. Our job is only to serve the ideal (challenging the NFU and trying to understand it...

Why would anyone risk getting his daughter/son killed if that person is only thinking of military results (that would amount just brownie points). Military is there only to do what it is told to do and to suggest ways about just how best to do it. It never decided policies in mature countries...

Right said. And I just wanted my countrymen to live and die with full knowledge of this one fact that there are no guarantees in life. Absolutely not a thing more or less. Nukes are just one of the component of the super structure. It is the balance of security, the balance of fear that counts...