Will China attack India again?

[drkrn]

oh yes forgot that china doesn't care the ever increasing Indian military relations with USA, improving military hardware oh yes they don't even care for Indian stance on Tibet and let dalai lama on full throttle in INDIA.

dude don't forget India is a part of BRICS. don't about SCO and still say that china doesn't have any interests with respect to india?

 

[Ray]

Re: Will India and China fight a war again?

How incisive.

You are in the MO Directorate?

 

[Ray]

Hehe last time it is China help our distressed neighbour. And we wish we have another chance to help her again. You are welcome, LOL

You convenient forget the times that happened after what to you appears to be 'the last time'.

Indeed, that will be the 'last time', because this time, you will eat crow, as the Americans phrase goes.

Get your facts first, then you can distort them as you please.

Back to your LOLs?

Working in a Laughing Gas factory?

You are a real gas!

 

[Ankit Purohit]

choice is yours china, If china wants to talk we are ready ,but you wants something else we are ready Too

Pehale baat fir pyar aur uske baad Laat

Hindustan zindabaad

 

[sayareakd]

question is, are we going to give them fitting reply, so much so that China wont be superpower in future. If the answer is yes, then no war and if answer is no, then they might attack.

 

[SADAKHUSH]

China has to look for her economic interest and keep internal social upheaval under control than look for any external adventure. At the present time they are trying to source all the raw material and fuel supply from all over the world therefore in order to keep all the sea channels open they are unlikely to get aggressive with any of their neighbours leave alone India.

If they do than the future of their shale oil/gas fields will be in jeopardy as the key ingredient to extract the gas /oil is controlled by India to the tune of 75% of the world market. In case they do carry out the aggressive action than all the bets are off and they will be receive a befitting response from Indian Armed Forces. Rest is up them.

 

[spikey360]

question is, are we going to give them fitting reply, so much so that China wont be superpower in future. If the answer is yes, then no war and if answer is no, then they might attack.

Yes. The answer is yes, we will give them a reply fitting enough to make sure China doesn't dare harm us again.

And we're not even talking of the nuclear option. Let them come to AP like they wish to. They'll suffer an Afghan like situation hundred times over. History has taught us again and again that land invasions do not work. If they think they need to re learn history, we'll give them a lesson their communist asses will remember forever.

 

[sayareakd]

@spikey we have to hit at their economic and financial heart land, plus their sea links for trade and oil, once war start they will seek alternative long route, so we have to be ready for this.
Our deterance should be such and enemy will know that any miscalculation on their part and 80 % of industry, 70 % of military and 30-40% of population will be under direct threat. This massage shoukd be loud and clear, let them think what ever they can do to counter attack.

 

[ice berg]

LOL, why will China attack India, when China is making billions of India every year. Some people dont make sense at all.
Trade all the way, baby.

 

[roma]

That is a totally false statement
India's defence expenditure even NOW that India is building or rather strengthening up its defences against
China is still 3 % of GDP
With respect to China we did have a decent capability vis a vis China till 2007
Otherwise what has prevented China from repeating 1962

But the RAPID Chinese Build up in Tibet in the LAST FEW years
plus the road and rail infrastructure
have forced us to counter the Chinese with a renewed build up of our own

TOTALLY false ? - India is admittedly the WORLD'S LARGEST importer of military equipment .... still totally false .....ok !

if not for china's aggression that money could not have been spent in other areas ?
still totally false ? .....ok !

what you wrote in your last para is what i have been saying in my original post - it is caused by prc aggression otherwise the ( substantial amount of ) money could have gone elsewhere ( if one will read my original post accurately )

 

[roma]

LOL, why will China attack India, when China is making billions of India every year. Some people dont make sense at all.
Trade all the way, baby.

hey chicom - that's exactly what your people said in 62 before attacking - why should dragon attack a "bhai-bhai" friend eh ?

 

[sesha_maruthi27]

This time around the chinese will get a rain of pouring BRAHMOS MISSILES over them.............

 

[ice berg]

hey chicom - that's exactly what your people said in 62 before attacking - why should dragon attack a "bhai-bhai" friend eh ?

Hey inchom, try not to move troops in contested areas and you are safe.

 

[Ray]

LOL, why will China attack India, when China is making billions of India every year. Some people dont make sense at all.
Trade all the way, baby.

That makes sense!

However, I will hasten to add that it is the old adage that works - once bitten, twice shy!

 

[no smoking]

hey chicom - that's exactly what your people said in 62 before attacking - why should dragon attack a "bhai-bhai" friend eh ?

A "Bhai-Bhai" friend?
This so called friend kept rejecting the suggestion of diplomatic negotiation over disputed area for a decad!
And then suddently, under the name "forward policy", sending to the troop to squeeze Chinese out of their controlled part of disputed area!
Even after sending the troop, this "friend" still reject coming to the negotiation table!

So basically, your expectation of this so called "friend" is: he must accept whatever you say!

 

[spikey360]

@spikey we have to hit at their economic and financial heart land, plus their sea links for trade and oil, once war start they will seek alternative long route, so we have to be ready for this.
Our deterance should be such and enemy will know that any miscalculation on their part and 80 % of industry, 70 % of military and 30-40% of population will be under direct threat. This massage shoukd be loud and clear, let them think what ever they can do to counter attack.

I do agree with you. I sincerely hope that is possible conventional warfare. You see, most of their population is already under direct threat of Indian nuclear missiles. Why 30-40% ? Double that number may be wiped out if we strike their densely populated regions. But, that isn't happening in the near future, imho. For all their rhetoric, both the countries are still cautious about real war due to the nuclear threat. Chinese Communists, in any case have mostly been all talks.

 

[spikey360]

Hey inchom, try not to move troops in contested areas and you are safe.

You must be daydreaming. According to the Chinese, AP is a disputed and contested area. But last time I checked, Indian Armed Forces were guarding its borders there. So either you are ill informed about the general location of Indian troops or you are plain ignorant.

 

[tharikiran]

I do foresee border skirmishes in future.Can't predict the intensity though.With the number of incursions we keep hearing in news channel, I have a feeling, there will be a tipping point.People talk about Chinese rail infrastructure in Tibet. Well, that track is built on permafrost. One bomb and the track is useless.
They are already facing issues maintaining that track.Whatever, the perceived perceptions are... it's good we are working on our roads in the north east.It will help not just the troop movement but also make life easy for people living there to travel.So, it's a win-win for public and the military.Those who complain about Indian defence expenditure should realise that our babudom are very slow at decisions unlike china. Every purchase we are currently making or which are in pipeline should have been done long time back. When did we last buy artillery ? Yes, we are purchasing, but our defence expenditure percentage in GDP is still less.And considering the size of India, the numbers we buy in military equipment is less too. Yup, India is building up for a two front war.Raising new battalions in the north-east.Placing armoured divisions and the sukhoi's there. As a layman, I can see it.

 

[Vishwarupa]

I feel attacking is the best way of defending.

Why cant we rename this thread as " Will India attack China this time to avenge 62 insult?" & discuss the possible outcomes.

The outcome might be same as discussed in the previous pages but atleast lets start projecting India as threat to china or are we still afraid of China attacking India.

 

[mikhail]

I feel attacking is the best way of defending.

Why cant we rename this thread as " Will India attack China this time to avenge 62 insult?" & discuss the possible outcomes.

The outcome might be same as discussed in the previous pages but atleast lets start projecting India as threat to china or are we still afraid of China attacking India.

mate i slightly disagree with you in this matter.we shouldn't fight a full blown conventional war with the chinis as their chicom army is twice that of ours.istead we should utilise our SFF to its full potentials,start recruiting tibetians covertly inside tibet,perform sabotage operations now and then inside tibet.in this way we'll have our revenge and it won't hurt our economy either as the chinis wouldn't have a clue regarding the perpetuators!