Who owns Kashmir?

[Blackwater]

Kashmir is an integral part of India.

Now that the Fauj is managing to keep it violence free & doing a good job at it,

Let it be !!

In any case, the glorious Fauj of Hind is deployed there, do what anybody can! period

Jo karna hai woh kar lo

Kashmir can not be taken by force by either side, period!

LoC should be made IB.

Never say never....

i agree with NEO

keeping aside emmotions practicle solution is LOC should be made IB ,satisfy what u have, develop it

 

[Prometheus]

i agree with NEO

keeping aside emmotions practicle solution is LOC should be made IB ,satisfy what u have, develop it

Actually we should hold on to the call of the entire region should belong to us, until Pakistan in its zeal to take all of it/ or part of it, undoes itself. Remember the problem is NOT Kashmir, the problem is Pakistan. The very concept of Pakistan was created for the hatred towards India and that Muslims should rule the entire region. Pakistan just blames the issue on Kashmir to bring the worlds attention to it. We shouldn't fall for the con like the rest of the world does. Remember that Kashmir was never a part of India to begin with! it was the Pakistani govt who decided to invade an independent country and only when the territory was acceded to India, that India took military action against the invaders.

Okay lets assume for a moment that Kashmir was the issue, then why did Pakistan attack Afghanistan?. Can that be based on Kashmir as well? why did Pakistanis wage a war on Russia or western countries like US and UK is this too because of Kashmir. Why is it that the Kashmir issue didn't affect the Bangladeshi's ?. why does Pakistan have a problem with Israel ? Has Israel been holding on to Pakistani territory?

We are in an awkward situation where we are next to the most problematic state in the world, and the only way it can be resolved is by undoing what was done in 1947. Remember Pakistan would have already dissolved by now if it weren't for the American aid. Even being so, Pakistanis HATE the Americans. Its a hateful state and the only way that the world will be at peace is if it gets dissolved into smaller states. The only way that the Punjabi Pakistanis keep a hold on the state is by preaching HATE to their inhabitants!, by creating an outside threat, so people within the state are always busy fighting, instead of concentrating on real issues like the economy and corruption.

 

[Compersion]

This might be a understatement:

In view of the maldives election process perhaps india can offer the people of maldives a integration whereby it becomes a state of republic of india like Kashmir. The principle of Muslims being prosperous under a india constitution needs to be reinforced. Maldives like Kashmir will have strengthen its self determination and have the india republic protection and rights under the constitution. This would support Kashmir policy of india and further help support the viewpoint of (failed) Pakistan anti-india position and its principle of its creation.

 

[Simple_Guy]

Not just Kashmir, even Chitral is part of India, as it was under the Dogras.

 

[PredictablyMalicious]

Not just Kashmir, even Chitral is part of India, as it was under the Dogras.

This is the map of Princely state of Jammu and Kashmir

 

[PredictablyMalicious]

India is supposed to have border with Afghanistan. Congressi morons have screwed up everything. Indira Gandhi had a golden opportunity to take back POK in 1971 as part of the bargain for handing over 90,000 paki POW's.

 

[Pratap]

Not just Kashmir, even Chitral is part of India, as it was under the Dogras.

Indians lived in entire Kashmir since Mauryan age and Gilgit, Chitral all were inhabited by Indo Aryans( they are still there) in antiquity. Whether Dogras ruled it or not , Indo Aryan territory belongs to Indians as being rightful heirs to that culture. Can you expect Chinese giving up Shansi?

 

[Pratap]

India is supposed to have border with Afghanistan. Congressi morons have screwed up everything. Indira Gandhi had a golden opportunity to take back POK in 1971 as part of the bargain for handing over 90,000 paki POW's.

Wrong. India must have border with Tajik Uzbek areas of Afghanistan rather than Pashtun areas which were all inhabited by Indic people and which were swamped by brutal Pashtun expansion in post Ghaznavid era. The civilizational frontier between India and Iran was Kubha river( Kabul) not Indus as assumed by many ill informed Indians. You can not call an Indic land as Afghan at any cost.

 

[Pratap]

It maybe fine for you to have a referendum . It is also fine by me, provided, the UN resolution are implemented where Pak withdraws all Pakistanis, military and civilians.

So you want Kashmir to be gifted away to Jehadi establishment , though in an orderly manner? Do not be in any doubt, a referendum( free and fair) will see" patriotic Kashmiri Muslims" opting for Pakistan or a free nation.

 

[shinoj]

Kashmir was an Integral part of India since Ages and it should remain so. Heck even Most of the Pakistan was India's Space but that is another part of discussion.

It pains me to see the Civilization which we nourished and cultivated since thousands of year is at the hand of Pakis and they are ruining it.

 

[Soumya1989]

In my opinion whatever it is but status quo should be maintained.

 

[Pratap]

Kashmir was an Integral part of India since Ages and it should remain so. Heck even Most of the Pakistan was India's Space but that is another part of discussion.

It pains me to see the Civilization which we nourished and cultivated since thousands of year is at the hand of Pakis and they are ruining it.

Sharada peeth is now in POK . What a sad moment for us. It is time to take back POK. The bastards who tell us that land of Kashyap is a disputed territory should be expelled from India( Arundhati Roy, Prafull Bidwai etc.).

 

[shinoj]

Sharada peeth is now in POK . What a sad moment for us. It is time to take back POK. The bastards who tell us that land of Kashyap is a disputed territory should be expelled from India( Arundhati Roy, Prafull Bidwai etc.).

Kashmir was one of the centres of Hinduism and Sanskrit from Ages. And No way it is going to Pakis. Honestly, what the heck do the Pakis know to Govern. They cant even manage the land which is given to them and they want Kashmir. Any Indian Ruler worth his true salt would kick the Pakis out of Kashmir forever.

 

[Pratap]

I think kashmir actually Belongs to Pak (60-70% Majority muslims)......... but some how our historians decided or wanna show WHO IS THE BOSS by Holding KASHMIR CROWN

2) They know it is gate way for central asia,7 Rivers originated here

3) They think these paki's will attack India so better change battle field from plains to HILLS (J&k) because in hills AGGRESSOR ALWAYS LOSER (min 7:1 ratio needed) & Human casualties are minimum,if battle field is in plains Human casualties are maximum and Economy will be doomed.........HIndu Baniyas

Should every muslim slum where muslims are 100 percent be given to Pakistan?

 

[Blackwater]

no boss ........ kashmir is a PROVINCE headed by King and 2 nation theory is Hindu Majority provinces to India Muslim province to Pak

Than give Palestine , Central Asia, Indonesia ,Malaysia ,Arab to Pakistan too

 

[Simple_Guy]

Hindu Majority provinces to India Muslim province to Pak

Then why muslim majority Bangladesh separated from paki?

 

[rock127]

I think kashmir actually Belongs to Pak (60-70% Majority muslims)......... but some how our historians decided or wanna show WHO IS THE BOSS by Holding KASHMIR CROWN

2) They know it is gate way for central asia,7 Rivers originated here

3) They think these paki's will attack India so better change battle field from plains to HILLS (J&k) because in hills AGGRESSOR ALWAYS LOSER (min 7:1 ratio needed) & Human casualties are minimum,if battle field is in plains Human casualties are maximum and Economy will be doomed.........HIndu Baniyas

You are a Paki but by having a Paki flag you accepted that Pakistan belongs to India.

You have taken a good initiative by not choosing Paki flag.... also lot of Pakis in foreign pose as Indians already.

 

[roma]

Sharada peeth is now in POK . What a sad moment for us. It is time to take back POK. The bastards who tell us that land of Kashyap is a disputed territory should be expelled from India( Arundhati Roy, Prafull Bidwai etc.).

i like your post but i agreed only with the part about arundati and others like her

As for taking all of Kashmir back - it's a bit late after our great visionary gave those parts away as POK

The only way that can happen is for India to be at a level of technology and military organization
which is a few paradigm levels higher than BOTH packland and dragonland ...and unfortunately that is hardly the case . we need to have the kind of edge the USA has over China and well that just isnt so . .

We will need many more Pranav Mistry's and people like him for that to happen and not working for Samsung
but actually in the DRDO working for India..... not that it's impossible,

but until that happens and given all the 2G scams and coalgate scams, naval chief resigning. mig 21 still in service and all the other mismanagement, in fact ; India has had it good to even hang to what we have.

Military force is not the way to solve this matter, it will have to be "something else"

 

[Kunal Biswas]

If anyone claiming something too far ..

Provide some links to back up claims ..

 

[Agustya]

Why does so much infiltration happen anyways? Isn't there supposed to be an impenetrable electric fence there? Landmines? If there aren't any jihadis crossing over, there will be no problem.