What Should India Do If China Invades Taiwan Tomorrow?

India Super Power

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Oct 3, 2020
Messages
2,190
Likes
4,378
Country flag
Kuch nahi karne wale yeh log
When Taiwan will be annexed by China we will be waiting for them to come towards us bcoz of attitude you all know
Hum wait karenge hamari gand bajane keliye
But I have strong feeling that they will defeat us before going towards Taiwan to reduce the resistance from world as producing themselves a powerful nation if its true then hamari baj chuki hai bcoz we can't do anything in that case
 

cereal killer

Senior Member
Joined
May 14, 2020
Messages
1,949
Likes
7,693
Country flag
If China invades Taiwan and the US gets involved, it is unlikely to be easy and outright victory for China. The Taiwanese forces will put up big fight and US will move in for the rescue. That is the perfect time for India to grab Akash Chin plateau and cut off Sinkiang from Tibet. ……. Yes, India can do it. It will be a big payback for 1962. India has 1.4 million troops under arms all well trained. Chinese have 1.8 million conscript Army, all busy in the east facing Chinese misadventure in Taiwan…….. Wait for Chinese misadventure and india move into Akash Chin.
There's nothing to do along Aksai Chin... If anything India should go & settle the issue with Paxtan once n for all with both of its Sugar daddies busy. PoK/Sindh take your pick. Bring International border into play as well like 1965
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
4,775
Likes
1,913
Country flag
But I have strong feeling that they will defeat us before going towards Taiwan to reduce the resistance from world as producing themselves a powerful nation if its true then hamari baj chuki hai bcoz we can't do anything in that case
Why?
No one denied that US was a powerful nation before she got herself into the Vietnam shit hole created by Soviet and China!
No one denied that USSR was a powerful nation, but still when she invaded Afghan, the whole world stand against her!
Defeat India won't help anything on Taiwan issue for Chinese but waste their resource.
 

Suryavanshi

Cheeni KLPDhokebaaz
Senior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
12,297
Likes
53,598
Country flag
Cucked: Do Nothing
Neutral: Collaborate and Give logistical Support to QUAD Nation if they attack.
Based: Attack POK and Aksai Chin.
Dangerously Based: Attack POK, Assai Chin and Tibet, Occupy Coco Island and Send Warship to SCS
China would have to shift 75% of all it's military to defend Tibet if we decide to cross the Himalaya.
 

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
2,427
Likes
4,575
Country flag
Will China Invade Taiwan?

If China invades Taiwan, which they have been threatening to do so for many years and more specifically in the past 10 months, then what will be the scenario for Taiwan?

1. Will the US permit Communist China to capture Taiwan and look the other way because they have a trillion dollar trade going between them hence not jeopardize that or,

2. US risk a fight, mostly a naval fight to keep the Communist at bay.

In scenario 1, the current political dispensation in Washington is anti-Russian. They preferably would keep the US Navy out of the fight and let the Taiwanese look after themselves. If the Taiwanese lose, it is not a big loss for the US. Their overexploited trade would continue to grow with added high-tech Taiwanese additions. After that the world would never trust US for any promises.

If scenario 2 unfolds, then the US Navy in Guam, Japan, Pearl and other places will run to save the small nation from a big bully. Although Chinese have prepared well for this scenario, still their main drawback is inferior, copied and reverse engineered Naval technology, which will fall easy prey to the American superior naval warfare expertise.

Following the first few reversals, the Chinese will end the invasion and return to the mainland... The war is over.

My question for Scenario one and two is that……. Will US apply those commercials, financials and assets sanctions on China. The democrats who control Whitehouse and Congress are... Will they agree to impose sanctions and paralyze the Chinese economy? I guess not, because American dependence on Chinese-made consumer goods will play its role. If there is a naval engagement and American servicemen body bags return to US mainland then the mood could change.

We must wait and see what happens in Taiwan and how America reacts.
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
4,775
Likes
1,913
Country flag
Cucked: Do Nothing
Neutral: Collaborate and Give logistical Support to QUAD Nation if they attack.
What logistical support can India help in IOC will help a war thousands km away?

Based: Attack POK and Aksai Chin.
Then starting to prepare a war (or local conflict) for a few rocks with a country with 5 times GDP? Certainly you can argue that Chinese will suffer some losses, but what is the benefit for you here? Making America great again?

Dangerously Based: Attack POK, Assai Chin and Tibet, Occupy Coco Island and Send Warship to SCS
Too late, Taiwanese have been preparing the war for 80 years. No matter what period, there is one thing never changed: they have no plan to turn Taiwan into another Vietnam or Afghan. If they don't see US ships or planes join the war in one week, it is over.

China would have to shift 75% of all it's military to defend Tibet if we decide to cross the Himalaya.
Unless India decided to send at least 50% of her military force over Himalaya. But India does that, the logistic will collapse first.
 

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
2,427
Likes
4,575
Country flag
What logistical support can India help in IOC will help a war thousands km away?



Then starting to prepare a war (or local conflict) for a few rocks with a country with 5 times GDP? Certainly you can argue that Chinese will suffer some losses, but what is the benefit for you here? Making America great again?



Too late, Taiwanese have been preparing the war for 80 years. No matter what period, there is one thing never changed: they have no plan to turn Taiwan into another Vietnam or Afghan. If they don't see US ships or planes join the war in one week, it is over.



Unless India decided to send at least 50% of her military force over Himalaya. But India does that, the logistic will collapse first.
Chinese GDP and Indian GDP are 4 times apart. There is a weakness in Chinese GDP, it is based on Consumer goods manufacture. Making shirts, pants and dishwashers does not give them a high technology base. It is a smoke stack industry base. The worst for them is that 40% of their GDP is exported. Hence high GDP of China is a minor advantage to them.

Logistics for China should collapse because if they shift more men and material to Tibet then there is no way to keep them supplied. All petroleum, food, and war stores have to be sourced from 4,000 Km away. In case of India, all logistics are within 400 to 600 km away. Hence a prolonged China - India action is a disadvantage to China.
What Chinese are good at is propaganda to establish their superiority. In fact they are not.
 

THESIS THORON

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2021
Messages
6,378
Likes
31,045
Country flag
if they attack taiwan, then we should fcuk aksai chin, or if not that then we should definitely capture coco island. considering goi has given some strict conditions to lankans for loan
 

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
2,427
Likes
4,575
Country flag
Chinese invasion of Taiwan

The Russian invasion of Ukraine was neither successful nor lost. This is a great lesson for China as it prepares to invade Taiwan. The Chinese calendar was for this fall's invasion, but the reaction of the U.S. to the Russian invasion of Ukraine and all these economic sanctions against Russia has somewhat discouraged China. Russia is a fortress nation that sits on a stack of oil reserves, critical supply of metals, food grains and other chemicals. Each of these are needed, hence a temporary disruption aside these supplies would continue. In case of China which is totally dependent on the consumer goods manufacture & exports and supply chain intermediary products, the impact will be dramatic and negative.

China, as strategic analysts in the West believe that their plan is to quickly overwhelm Taiwan's defenses before any help arrives. It is only 80 miles of sea their armed forces have to cross and to land. They believe they can take Taiwan in a few days. Good thinking from their point of view, but first the Taiwan is heavily equipped with quality military hardware and second, US help can arrive in a few days from Japan and Guam. In the fight that follows, as the Taiwanese stoutly defend their homeland, the US simply prevents resupply to the Chinese forces by blocking the sea. Therefore, the pressure on the invading force is doubled, i.e. no supplies and a strong defense. One can see the beginning of retreat of Chinese forces.

If Chinese forces intensify by attacking the American fleet, then the United States could attack air and military bases on the mainland. I believe that the Chinese are not fools to escalate to a level where the US instead of defensive becomes offensive.

It will be a repeat of the Falkland War scenario in which a medium-sized British naval fleet isolated Falkland from reinforcements and was victorious.

As punishment, the U.S. could impose economic sanctions against China. Mind it that these cannot be as severe as imposed on Russia, but any sanctions which deny them external markets and money will be detrimental to Chinese export interests. They will very quickly relent. Consequently, the invasion will not succeed.

The key point is that.…….. can the United States impose sanctions similar to those it imposed on Russia, on China? The answer is no, because the United States is overly reliant on Chinese exports. This dependence will also make the United States slow down. The fighting can end in a few days, but the impact of any sanctions on an exporting country such as China will be much worse. One lesson that will emerge from this harsh diplomacy will be that the United States will be forced to consider alternatives to their needs for consumer goods. Other nations with low wage & industrious labor will be delighted to receive the US foreign direct investment and supply them products comparable or better in quality than China.

The above scenario of invasion, regardless of how you look, is wrong for China. Smart Chinese leaders will put Taiwan's integration on the back burner. Hence, possibly no invasion.
 

Tshering22

Sikkimese Saber
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
6,322
Likes
12,521
Country flag
Cucked: Do Nothing
Neutral: Collaborate and Give logistical Support to QUAD Nation if they attack.
Based: Attack POK and Aksai Chin.
Dangerously Based: Attack POK, Assai Chin and Tibet, Occupy Coco Island and Send Warship to SCS
China would have to shift 75% of all it's military to defend Tibet if we decide to cross the Himalayas.
This one cracked me up. :lol: Come on, man!

We will never strike PoK and that's almost accepted, forget eastern Ladakh. That requires crossing the Himalayas and descending into the occupied Tibet plateau.

Indian people have no appetite for opportunistic war and will protest against the government. Imagine if an Indian loses his ability to buy the latest smartphone, or miss out that new nightclub.
 

Rassil Krishnan

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2019
Messages
1,489
Likes
5,834
Country flag
This one cracked me up. :lol: Come on, man!

We will never strike PoK and that's almost accepted, forget eastern Ladakh. That requires crossing the Himalayas and descending into the occupied Tibet plateau.

Indian people have no appetite for opportunistic war and will protest against the government. Imagine if an Indian loses his ability to buy the latest smartphone, or miss out that new nightclub.
not really,i think we are imperialistic enough to take back pok,everyone already knows the script except for anti-nationals on what must be done about pok.

the perfect scenario must be where we lightning fast destroy most of pak military starting with their navy and take back Pok area and then position most of our troops and to block any pla action from the himalayas so that they can never take any terrirtory from us for bargaining,do anything to achieve and sacrifice anything as we must not let china get anything to bargain on paks behalf for any part of pok.

after that position the military near the China frontier permenantly asthe pakis will be completely neutered as a result of our actions(we must deal with their economy and military in such a way that they become at best like bangladesh,never being able to threaten militarily and economically).

dont make any serious moves into tibet as our objective is to permenantly neuter pakistan and remove one 1 front from the 2.5 front scenario.

alsodeal with the antinationals inside too as it might be a window where we can achieve this.
 

R1TTER

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2022
Messages
67
Likes
128
Country flag
China will never invade Taiwan at least not the way Russia effed up their Ukraine invasion, between Taiwanese & Chinese manufacturers there's at least a trillion dollars worth of electronic goods exports & most of them simply cannot be replaced anywhere else in the world. You think oil prices shooting towards $200 is a possibility now? If China ever tried to invade Taiwan & the West attempts to stop/block it the world economy would collapse literally overnight :rofl:
 

no smoking

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
4,775
Likes
1,913
Country flag
China will never invade Taiwan at least not the way Russia effed up their Ukraine invasion, between Taiwanese & Chinese manufacturers there's at least a trillion dollars worth of electronic goods exports & most of them simply cannot be replaced anywhere else in the world. You think oil prices shooting towards $200 is a possibility now? If China ever tried to invade Taiwan & the West attempts to stop/block it the world economy would collapse literally overnight :rofl:
So, who will back down?
To China, Taiwan has strategically importance, or the way Chinese like to put "it is related to the national fate".
To west, Taiwan is an effective tool to block or slow Chinese advancement. Without Taiwan, they still have Korea, Japan, Australia, or even India.
Who do you think is more willing to take the risk or pain?
 

R1TTER

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2022
Messages
67
Likes
128
Country flag
China maybe stupid but not Putinesque stupid, they're already making trillions by just claiming Taiwan as a part of China - for all intents & purposes it is because no major country in the world recognizes it as a separate nation! Not to mention using Taiwan, or the West, they are gaining a lot in the semiconductor space as well.
 

Samaritan

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2016
Messages
42
Likes
158
Country flag
There's nothing to do along Aksai Chin... If anything India should go & settle the issue with Paxtan once n for all with both of its Sugar daddies busy. PoK/Sindh take your pick. Bring International border into play as well like 1965
First set right internal house. Delhi burning, Bangle burning, Kerala -j & K need focus . Internal law and order situation is worrisome.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top