Taliban Takeover of Afghanistan 2021: Impact on India

aystle

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2016
Messages
173
Likes
505
Country flag
As per sources, neighbouring countries are going to help the resistance. They are giving confidence to the resistance leaders to not to give up.

As per reports the ethnic passions have erupted on the ground. We may see paradropping of soldiers into Panjshir.
I think Air Support will be enough...
 

doreamon

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2019
Messages
3,007
Likes
15,164
Country flag
For all those who wanted India to take a more active role in Afghanistan - glad no one listened to any of you.

Afg is a clusterFuck. The whole country is still living in middle ages & believes in a book that came out of the AsHole of a pedophile.

You can't do much about people whose sole aim is to die in the brutal way possible to get virgins in afterlife.
And the biggest of all Afganistan dnt share border with us .. Any military intervention ll require complete dependence of another country . In crucial times all supply lines can be choked . And truth be told Afgan hate foreign boots in their land ... It wont take much time before u become from a friendly Army to kafir army .... And wht ll be economic cost ?? Can we effort it ..

Let pakistan have its strategic depth or whtev .. We can focus on building capacity of our Army ..In case of Any adverse event we have found our solution in Balakot .. Pakistan souverginty sd be violated with reckless attitude ..
 

jackprince

Turning into a frog
Senior Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2009
Messages
5,149
Likes
17,916
Country flag
To dear members,

What the fck do you want India to do?

Some here want India to get in a full blown war with Pak and China to open a supply route to Afghanistan through GB. As if Northern Alliance is trapped in Wakhan territory and not in Panjshir! Why the hell should India spend upwards of $10-12 billion at minimum in an uncertain war to reach a region that too is under Taliban control and get embroiled in a unconventional war against an enemy that has mastered the tactics in last 2 decades? Not to mention our own supply line will remain under constant threat through a hostile newly conquered territory by one of the major military powers of the world as well as another strong conventional force and its irregulars. And don't forget that the infrastructure in PoK and GB is so rudimentary, that even if we manage to win the area and hold it, we will face uphill battle to send sufficient amount of supply through that region from India.

And, all that to create a supply line to support a resistance in Panjshir at Afghanistan where the situation remain fluid?

I mean I have seen my share of craziness in this forum, but it definitely takes the cake?

As for Tazik airbase. India most likely doesn't maintain any fighter fleet there and even if they did, that fleet can't swoop in to support Panjshir where the airspace is owned by PAF now. Again, to deter PAF from attacking our fighter fleet in Afghanistan, we would have to assault PAF in our IB, which would again see all international player wetting themselves for fear of Nuclear fall out and India would be forced again, to restrain itself. India would lose face and would have to pay in diplomatic coins and for what gain?

If India attacks Pakistan, it will be a bloody battle and when I am in all support for that, the reason can't be for trivial reason as supporting Afghanistan resistance. It is September here and in a few months, winter will set in. If you think Indian Army will start a campaign in mountains of PoK and GB in September, you gave to be crazy!
 

FalconSlayers

धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः
Senior Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2020
Messages
28,260
Likes
195,910
Country flag
To dear members,

What the fck do you want India to do?

Some here want India to get in a full blown war with Pak and China to open a supply route to Afghanistan through GB. As if Northern Alliance is trapped in Wakhan territory and not in Panjshir! Why the hell should India spend upwards of $10-12 billion at minimum in an uncertain war to reach a region that too is under Taliban control and get embroiled in a unconventional war against an enemy that has mastered the tactics in last 2 decades? Not to mention our own supply line will remain under constant threat through a hostile newly conquered territory by one of the major military powers of the world as well as another strong conventional force and its irregulars. And don't forget that the infrastructure in PoK and GB is so rudimentary, that even if we manage to win the area and hold it, we will face uphill battle to send sufficient amount of supply through that region from India.

And, all that to create a supply line to support a resistance in Panjshir at Afghanistan where the situation remain fluid?

I mean I have seen my share of craziness in this forum, but it definitely takes the cake?

As for Tazik airbase. India most likely doesn't maintain any fighter fleet there and even if they did, that fleet can't swoop in to support Panjshir where the airspace is owned by PAF now. Again, to deter PAF from attacking our fighter fleet in Afghanistan, we would have to assault PAF in our IB, which would again see all international player wetting themselves for fear of Nuclear fall out and India would be forced again, to restrain itself. India would lose face and would have to pay in diplomatic coins and for what gain?

If India attacks Pakistan, it will be a bloody battle and when I am in all support for that, the reason can't be for trivial reason as supporting Afghanistan resistance. It is September here and in a few months, winter will set in. If you think Indian Army will start a campaign in mountains of PoK and GB in September, you gave to be crazy!
1. Fuck porkis and cause economical damage as world will never do that due to nukes which pakis have.
2. Radicalise a few talibunny factions and use them against china in east turkestan aka xinjiang
3. Support the northern alliance as they claim they’re intact.
1630906753265.jpeg
 

Covfefe

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2021
Messages
4,214
Likes
28,467
Country flag
To dear members,

What the fck do you want India to do?

Some here want India to get in a full blown war with Pak and China to open a supply route to Afghanistan through GB. As if Northern Alliance is trapped in Wakhan territory and not in Panjshir! Why the hell should India spend upwards of $10-12 billion at minimum in an uncertain war to reach a region that too is under Taliban control and get embroiled in a unconventional war against an enemy that has mastered the tactics in last 2 decades? Not to mention our own supply line will remain under constant threat through a hostile newly conquered territory by one of the major military powers of the world as well as another strong conventional force and its irregulars. And don't forget that the infrastructure in PoK and GB is so rudimentary, that even if we manage to win the area and hold it, we will face uphill battle to send sufficient amount of supply through that region from India.

And, all that to create a supply line to support a resistance in Panjshir at Afghanistan where the situation remain fluid?

I mean I have seen my share of craziness in this forum, but it definitely takes the cake?

As for Tazik airbase. India most likely doesn't maintain any fighter fleet there and even if they did, that fleet can't swoop in to support Panjshir where the airspace is owned by PAF now. Again, to deter PAF from attacking our fighter fleet in Afghanistan, we would have to assault PAF in our IB, which would again see all international player wetting themselves for fear of Nuclear fall out and India would be forced again, to restrain itself. India would lose face and would have to pay in diplomatic coins and for what gain?

If India attacks Pakistan, it will be a bloody battle and when I am in all support for that, the reason can't be for trivial reason as supporting Afghanistan resistance. It is September here and in a few months, winter will set in. If you think Indian Army will start a campaign in mountains of PoK and GB in September, you gave to be crazy!
And to support who? There has been no organic movement within Afghanistan for its future. Talibs are propped up by Pakis, NA was propped up by Russia, Iran and India, the democratic government under the US shadow didn't even try to reach out to it's own people. They are mostly tribal people who want to live by their customary Islamic laws without much care about who sits in Kabul. All this US-China-Pak-Russia-Iran-India hoopla runs only on Twitter by outsiders and a few elites. Any military action would be something like India's action in SL. Tried to help Tamil rebels fight against SL govt and later SL govt against Tamil rebels- now both of them hate India.
 

DownWithCCP

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2020
Messages
2,056
Likes
8,785
Country flag
The talk through the grapevine is that the Taliban has captured Panjshir province, Amrullah Saleh has fled to Tajikistan and Ahmad Massoud is still in hiding somewhere in Panjshir.
The world expected ANA to act like how Saleh's forces acted in Panjshir, the takeover by taliban was a given but it wouldn't have been easy at all, like it was for Taliban to take Panjshir.
 

shashankk

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2018
Messages
835
Likes
4,135
Country flag
One this is for sure than they hardly had few thousand fighters in Panjshir not the 20 k plus that people were claiming. 20 k of well entrenched fighters are not that easy to dislodge. Hope Masood junior and Saleh survive to fight for another day. I am sure of infighting between Talibunnies in coming days for control over power.
 

chetan_chpd

Desi Homelander
Regular Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2019
Messages
183
Likes
1,087
Country flag
Funny how Pakistanis say, Bangladesh would have been separated from us with or without 1971 indo-pak war since it was so far away...
still consider fall of small valley-panjshir IN AGHANISTAN SURROUNDED BY TWO COUNTRIES (TALIFAGS AND PAKIFAGS) as defeat of India and RAW
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top