Taliban Takeover of Afghanistan 2021: Impact on India

Hari Sud

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
3,945
Likes
8,862
Country flag
US lost its mind and hastily decided to withdraw from Afghanistan. It left $10 billion in military hardware on ground straight as a gift for Taliban. That fiasco of untold proportions is unfolding in Afghanistan. Now there is good possibility of civil war with each armed group with American hardware vying for power in Kabul. Total blame for it is American and more appropriately Biden Administration for a sudden decision to leave. Although Trump was preparing to leave but it is Biden to be blamed for lack of experience to manage withdrawal over a period of time and let Taliban into Kabul slowly as an ultimate political force.

That type of sudden withdrawal from Vietnam in 1975 resulted in American public dumping Gerald Ford. It is time for US public to question Biden and party for this fiasco and if constitutionally permitted then dump him also.
 

Suryavanshi

Cheeni KLPDhokebaaz
Senior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
16,330
Likes
70,185
There's a quote in Hindi, my angrez fwend- "Jungle mein more nacha, kisne dekha?"
(A peacock danced in the forest but who saw?)
Every nation has to cleanse itself a few years lest it's forever changed, fragmented or lose it's soul.

Do I want India to have a banana republic with death squads?
Yes, if they're on our side and for a limited time period.
I consider Indian republic to already be a banana republic in many ways.
Different laws for different religions, regions, tribes, landmarks, everything.

Which "sane" republic allows literally hundreds of insurgent groups to rear their ugly head every few decades?

Let's consider this comparison to SA. South American countries don't have that level of enmity, hatred, fragments and crisis among them.
They're all agnostic/christians who speak Spanish barring Brazil that speaks Portugueuse and French Guiana where the official language is French, although the common man still speaks Spanish.

What are we?
The last pagan civilization standing.
Every rival neighbor of ours stands in wild and extreme contrast to our culture, people and country.
A Bolivian invasion of Chile is a conflict of flags and leaders. Not of language, culture, religion and way of life.

Ours is the conflict of our soul.
It all sounds very sentimental but it's true.

If they (The South Americans) can take such extreme measures for a trivial pursuit (from a civilizational point of view), ours is a much bigger bet.

Let me embody the cringey raging emo teenager in me by quoting Joker-
View attachment 105991

Dare I say, if you still followed the religion of the Celtic tribes and there were nutty Christian hordes raging at your borders (I know I know, just humor me here) , you'd know the extreme paranoia that sometimes grips us if we get mildly pessimistic about the future.

Consider UK getting invaded by France lol. You wouldn't feel the same fear as... Say... The packies invading UK (Although I hear they already are doing so in which case, y'all will feel the heat soon enough. Not looking forward to it. The gods know I'd never wish a plague like that upon my worst enemy except my WORST enemy.)

Feel my pain brah. Feel it in the most non sexual, non homoerotic, non creepy way.
Just the emotions.
Don't be feeling up my pants unless you're a girl. :rage:
In mathematical term in some cases a point can't be reach and ideal point. So we do with limits around that points neighbourhood.

Same way an ideal society can't be reached we can come close to it but we won't reach it, closer we go farther it becomes.
Applying ideal case will give u false result.

Western society dream too much of a ideal society so much that they ignore practical life.





Try creating this it's almost impossible u will end up wasting your time.
Why bother too much with ideal concept like justice and human rights at some point u have to say we did as much as we could.
 

Romediablo

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2020
Messages
193
Likes
784
Country flag
Iam curious , If Afghanistan is not an homogeneous entity but tribal controlled lands with diverse groups , than why each of them wants full control of state .What is the need to keep it as single entity and why not break it? For eg in the region where NA ( Hazara community is dominant there i guess) is currently why not choose the favourable border country and take control of regions surrounding it and thus consolidate it (culturally , ideologically etc) first ,before moving towards the other end. Whats the point in moving forward and capturing new region then suddenly loosing the regions behind you?
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top