S&P cuts India, China GDP growth forecast, U.S. sentiment hit

huaxia rox

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2011
Messages
1,401
Likes
103
S&P cuts India, China GDP growth forecast, U.S. sentiment hit | Real Time News, India

Global credit rating agency Standard & Poor's has cut its GDP growth estimate for India by 1 percentage point to 5.5% and for China by 0.5 percentage point to 7.5%.

The cut in India's outlook was prompted by poor monsoon and negative investor sentiment, while in China's case, it was caused by the Central Government's decision not to pump money into the Chinese economy to stimulate growth.

"The lack of monsoon rains has affected India, for which agriculture still forms a substantial part of the economy. Additionally, the more cautious investor sentiment globally has seen potential investors become more critical of India's policy and infrastructure shortcomings," S&P said in a report on the Asia Pacific today.

India has one of the worst infrastructure in the world, making the movement of people and goods across the country inefficient and expensive. The Indian government is yet to make big investments in building roads and ports, unlike in China.

India's infrastructure challenges was recently highlighted by the power outage in early August that affected 20 of India's 28 states, S&P said.

India has also been grappling with negative investor sentiment after former finance minister Pranab Mukherjee brought in a 'retrospective' law to tax foreign companies for capital gains on their assets in the country.

S&P, however, expects growth to pick up to 6.5% in 2013 and to 7% in 2014 (see chart above.)

India used to have growth in the range of 9% before the global recession hit.

S&P also revised the growth estimates for several other countries in the region. China is now seen growing at 7.5% this year and by 8.2% in the next and in 2014.

"Our lower forecast for China recognizes that the central government had elected not to inject an economic stimulus of a size and speed necessary for an 8% growth rate. It appears that the approach by the Chinese authorities remains influenced by the unpleasant experience of the inflationary effect, particularly on real estate prices, of the stimulus they initiated in late 2008-2009 to counter the global economic slowdown following the Lehman's collapse," it said.

As a result of the Chinese slowdown, export-oriented Asian economies of Japan, Korea and Taiwan, and the trading port cities of Hong Kong (in particular) and Singapore will also see slower growth, it said.

It also revised its sentiment for Europe and the United States downward.

"In Europe our base case GDP scenario for the Eurozone as a whole is that GDP will decline by 0.6% in 2012 and grow by just 0.4% in 2013, compared with zero and 1% growth, respectively, in our previous base case scenario," it said.

It now sees a 25% chance for the U.S. economy to slip back into recession
within the next year--up from 20% in February.

"Economic activity has downshifted sharply from earlier this year, with hiring and consumer spending growth slowing in the spring. Public sector retrenchment is continuing to drag down growth as well.

"And while the U.S. housing sector has shown signs of bottoming out, we don't expect home prices to recover strongly soon. At the same time, possible contagion from the European debt crisis, the potential so-called "fiscal cliff" (the collection of expiration of Bush-era tax cuts, payroll tax cut, and other tax relief programs), and the risk of a hard landing for China's economy have added greater uncertainty to U.S. economic prospects in upcoming months," it said.

It's estimate for U.S. GDP growth is about 2.1% for this year and 1.8% for 2013.
 

Bangalorean

Ambassador
Joined
Nov 28, 2010
Messages
6,233
Likes
6,854
Country flag
I've said this before, and I am saying it again - these credit rating agencies are the biggest bullshitters around. After all, it is so easy to "revise" the figure ever so often.

IMF forecasts India's growth at 4.9%, World bank forecasts 6% and S&P forecasts it at 5.5% now. What a lot of nonsense, really.

If India grows at 6.1% in the first quarter of next year, all three agencies will scramble to "revise" their forecasts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nrj

huaxia rox

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2011
Messages
1,401
Likes
103
these days its surely hard to make predictions......

and interestingly prcs economy is getting forecasted to embrace its Doom and Gloom for long in this forum pridicted by many of my intellengent indian friends here.....and i cant see any revisions so far......
 

p2prada

Senior Member
Joined
May 25, 2009
Messages
10,234
Likes
4,015
We need an actual govt estimate on growth rate. Only MoF has been consistent with their estimates. But it is fine for external agencies to be 0.5-1% off from actual figures, higher or lower. The calculation depends on a lot of factors. It is no big deal.

What affects India is the credit ratings given by banks.
 

sob

Mod
Joined
May 4, 2009
Messages
6,425
Likes
3,805
Country flag
p2p, some of the data being touted by the Government is pure bomkus. Somebody must have been in Grassland when they compiled the data, or it may be a case of figures being padded.

There are two points to be noted about these figures,

1. Figures for 11/12 are finalised almost a year later i.e it will be done around February March 2013, so the data is provisional.

2. As I wrote above the export data is very fishy. Once last year the Govt. had to write off almost US $ 9 Billion from the figures, but it seems that figure has again come back.

Interesting article on a research done by a team from Kotak Mahindr on these figures,

Export golmaal: Now, auto data show funny numbers | Firstpost

Ever heard of Tokelau Islands? Here's a terrific story of Indian export triumph in these sparsely populated islands. In 2010-11, India managed to export approximately 2,000 cars (roughly worth $15 million) when the islands had a population of 1,400.

Maybe, those folks there (the islands are part of New Zealand in the south Pacific) bought more than one car each. But, unsurprisingly, in the year after that, exports went down from 2,000 to zero.

End of a fairy tale export success or the beginning of another dubious story by the compilers of our export figures?

In both 2010-11 and 2011-12, the government appears to have been juggling export figures to paper over what looks more and more like an unexplained overinvoicing scam.

The story begins in October 2011, when three smart cookies at Kotak Securities smelt something fishy in the government's export data for 2010-11. The three – Sanjeev Prasad, Sunita Baldawa and Amit Kumar – said: "Our study of exports data of major engineering companies (including automobiles and metals) shows that the increase in their exports does not reconcile with the steep increase in official exports data. In fact, the gap is quite substantial."

According to them the official export data showed a 79 percent year-on-year export growth in 2010-11. Exports by engineering companies in the BSE 500 (the cream of India Inc) showed just 11 percent growth. In dollars, the engineering export jump accounts for $30 billion (up from $38 billion to $68 billion), while the figures for the BSE 500 showed a rise of just around $1.38 billion. (All approximate figures due to rupee-dollar conversion at fixed rates).

The then Commerce Secretary announced that exports in April-October 2011 had been overstated by $9.4 billion. But as Firstpost noted then, the real goof-up was bigger, with engineering exports being overstated by $15 billion and a $12 billion underestimation in the case of petroleum and gems and jewellery exports, apart from other goofups.

Khullar then waved it off with a casual statement: "Mistakes take place. Every number for the last seven months was revised. This notion that the government is deliberately cooking up (data) and telling you lies has got to stop," The Economic Times quoted Khullar as saying.

There was only one small problem: the Kotak trio had talked of misleading numbers for 2010-11, but the government corrected data for 2011-12.

But the Kotak folks have continued to run a beady eye on the data and have discovered that government has juggled its 2010-11 figures too. That's where the suspicious car exports to Tokelau Islands come in.

Belatedly, it seems, the government has prettified the 2010-11 numbers, but the final figures remain unconvincing.
 

Bangalorean

Ambassador
Joined
Nov 28, 2010
Messages
6,233
Likes
6,854
Country flag
I've said this before, and I am saying it again - these credit rating agencies are the biggest bullshitters around. After all, it is so easy to "revise" the figure ever so often.

IMF forecasts India's growth at 4.9%, World bank forecasts 6% and S&P forecasts it at 5.5% now. What a lot of nonsense, really.

If India grows at 6.1% in the first quarter of next year, all three agencies will scramble to "revise" their forecasts.
Here you go, yet another "growth forecast", this time by the UN: Indian economy to grow 5.9%: UN

UN says 5.9% next year, and 6.5% the year after that.

These growth forecasts are a real joke.
 

Raj30

Senior Member
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
1,325
Likes
1,603
Usually rating agencies are used to arm twist the government as we have seen in the case of FDI
 

shiphone

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2009
Messages
2,163
Likes
2,479
Country flag
the chart from the latest news about Q3 GDP growth of China ... by Sep 2012
the last 3 figure (the first 3 quarters of 2012):
Q1. 8.1
Q2: 7.6
Q3: 7.4




the another chart from Indian web about the 2012-12 Q1 GDP growth of india...by June 2012



------------------------
the future is uncertain ...but we could talk more about the reality...

if you call such growth forecast from the rating agency a 'joke'... I thought there was a much big joker there...I do remember those Brave Words from some ranter like ' we will keep growing at the 2 digital rate for next 10 years' bla ...bla ...bla
 
Last edited:

nimo_cn

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
4,032
Likes
883
Country flag
Given the massive recession happening around the world, I think both China and India are just doing fine.

In order to avoid a bigger recession, countries like China and India should collaborate more closely.
 

DaTang

Tihar Jail
Banned
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
483
Likes
121
Given the massive recession happening around the world, I think both China and India are just doing fine.

In order to avoid a bigger recession, countries like China and India should collaborate more closely.
Hopefully, Indians think the same.
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top