Rakibools Shoot BSF Jawans on their Backs as they're returning from a Flag Meet

What Should Be the Indian Response

  • Diplomatic Option: Get Bangladesh to Apologize and Courtmartial those Involved

    Votes: 27 36.0%
  • Tactical Option: Indiscriminately Kill One BGB personnel, preferably headshot, and injure another

    Votes: 48 64.0%

  • Total voters
    75

Assassin 2.0

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2019
Messages
5,039
Likes
24,972
Country flag
Our neighbors were in romance with Chinese and now they are realizing China is one beautiful, gorgeous woman with aids.

China will give pleasure initially but eat up the host nation later.

Lungis aren't fan of Chinese either because of rohingayas crisis and ulghar Muslims issue. They are trying to become ummah chumma ideal Muslims and they will hate us for not being Muslim if not for anything else.
Kangladeshi hates india on the basis of Hinduism. Polytheism. Idol worshipping. Terrorist threat already emerging from there state.
Now deep state there is already started to use there Chinese ak-47 against india. Chinese subs already docking in Bangladeshi ports.

We are surrounded by enemies from 3 side's.

Chinese is one country which is trying to build a empire on earth.

Military modernization is need of the hour.
 

Rudy123

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2019
Messages
101
Likes
220
Country flag
Our neighbors were in romance with Chinese and now they are realizing China is one beautiful, gorgeous woman with aids.

China will give pleasure initially but eat up the host nation later.

Lungis aren't fan of Chinese either because of rohingayas crisis and ulghar Muslims issue. They are trying to become ummah chumma ideal Muslims and they will hate us for not being Muslim if not for anything else.
I agree with your second point but not the first. China is only favourable in trade and every nation love them from Asia to Africa.

But these Muslim majority countries are hardcore people whether developed or poor. They will never deviate from their goal of jihad. Yes some are dormant for now untill they reach a growth Point from where they will work on their goals.

Modi's sabka vishwas will fall face first. If this concept taken seriously, after few decades it will be seen as blunder. Some things are irrevocable. Our thinking that if we attack from Gujarat and baloch will welcome us, is a mistake. Temple in UAE will also not stand for long.

Every other country works on core agenda apart from growth. What is our agenda. Dropping of akhand Bharat concept is foolishness. At present we trying to acieve growth but what will happen when we become developed. In our ancient times we are developed too. Never aggressive toward others never imposed our thoughts, only give what we have, welcome everyone. And what we get in return. History is bound to happen but this time it will happen early. This union is bound to fail.
 

ezsasa

Mod
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,509
Likes
42,953
Country flag
After few victories on international forum now we rely mostly on diplomatic powers. We are soft power and tit for tat reply does not suit us. That can be an example of dhimmi ideology.

Look example of Nepal and Maldives . In Maldives we got successful but only after changing their government. They told us to lift out chopper, exile our backed high persons. In Nepal we still not able to achieve what we needed. They given less constituency to lower Himalayan people which are close to us. We protested, blocked them and failed miserably

We as a giant nation never fully influenced our neighbours for longer periods. Soft power projection is not solution of everything , sometimes nation have to stand up and should do little and impactful to leave a mark.

These incidents will keep happening. We might be looking for some diplomatic channel. If Ms Hasina is so favourable to us then why BGB not understand this, are they operating on their own. They do have separate economy and source of income, and if it so then they needed a lesson. I am afraid of growing confidence of these small group (which works against their national alignment). We must leave a deep mark which should be remembered for ages
Just because sheikh Hasina is favourable to us, doesn’t mean the message travels to every personnel of BGB.

No country is a monolith, not even Bangladesh.

Coming to our relationship with neighbours, It’s not As if our neighbors are not being wooed by anybody. It’s an active competition with Chinese for more than 4 decades, there are bound to be ups and downs.
 

Jameson Emoni

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2018
Messages
1,474
Likes
4,226
Kangladeshi hates india on the basis of Hinduism. Polytheism. Idol worshipping. Terrorist threat already emerging from there state.
Now deep state there is already started to use there Chinese ak-47 against india. Chinese subs already docking in Bangladeshi ports.

We are surrounded by enemies from 3 side's.

Chinese is one country which is trying to build a empire on earth.

Military modernization is need of the hour.
If things escalate, we can do few simple things to box Bangladesh -- nothing fancy will be needed. But for now some "disciplinary" actions against BGB would be sufficient.
 

Rudy123

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2019
Messages
101
Likes
220
Country flag
Just because sheikh Hasina is favourable to us, doesn’t mean the message travels to every personnel of BGB.

No country is a monolith, not even Bangladesh.

Coming to our relationship with neighbours, It’s not As if our neighbors are not being wooed by anybody. It’s an active competition with Chinese for more than 4 decades, there are bound to be ups and downs.[/QU
So should take it as an isolated incident or some mistake from individual. One soldier of CAPF died on active duty. This is not some regular incident. This is a national issue at least for me.

Does India has taken contract to go by the book. And this does not mean by retaliation, why not this mistake happens by our soldiers.

So we cannot control countries in our backyard and we will become global superpower. If its up and down then tell me in how many neighbouring countries of china we have our substantial presence.

We are lost cause if incidents like this does not boil blood.
 

ezsasa

Mod
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,509
Likes
42,953
Country flag
So should take it as an isolated incident or some mistake from individual. One soldier of CAPF died on active duty. This is not some regular incident. This is a national issue at least for me.

Does India has taken contract to go by the book. And this does not mean by retaliation, why not this mistake happens by our soldiers.

So we cannot control countries in our backyard and we will become global superpower. If its up and down then tell me in how many neighbouring countries of china we have our substantial presence.

We are lost cause if incidents like this does not boil blood.
if this incident would have happened same month last year, i would have agreed with you.
This time i don't think these are coincidences that a hindu mahasabha leader gets killed and in the same week BGB soldiers kills a BSF soldier in the same week. guess what is common among killers in both cases?

do spend time reading kashmir fateh and RJB thread, there are enough posts written by many members indicating that there would be multiple attempts to inflame passions in the hinterland of india.

too many variables at play these days...
 

Jameson Emoni

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2018
Messages
1,474
Likes
4,226
This wasnt even an attack in military terms but a literal cowardly stab in the back,
They didnt even get a fighting chance as they strolled into a ambush in half pants and flip flops , we dont even know ,how many chutiyadeshis surrounded and fired at them.

I wish SF is used , Also how good is bangladeshi army and SF ,they only have to fight mostly in jungle and marshland area ,so they must have good experience and ability ,

How capable are they?
Jungle gives them natural cover .
I do not think anyone has more experience than Indian SF when it comes to fighting in forested mangros. 1971 war is a good example of that.

Note: Except for may be US. They did some heavy duty fighting in Vietnamese jungles that had swamps.
 
Last edited:

jadoogar

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2016
Messages
196
Likes
341
Country flag
3 smugglers, 9 intruders held at Bangla border

https://www.outlookindia.com/newsscroll/3-smugglers-9-intruders-held-at-bangla-border/1644176


Now let them come for Flag meeting.
this is good.

There are more intruders from across the border. Maybe the scale can be expanded. BSF must be pissed off. Does it make sense to waste food on the intruders? The key is to announce nothing, admit nothing. Just do what needs to be done. Repeatedly.

Intrusion from BD is a 1000 times more than intrusion from India. This is a battle BD jihadis cannot win.

A public execution of some radical BD forces in Dhacca on some suitable charge would be a suitable apology ??
 
Last edited:

bose

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
4,789
Likes
5,187
Country flag
This wasnt even an attack in military terms but a literal cowardly stab in the back,
They didnt even get a fighting chance as they strolled into a ambush in half pants and flip flops , we dont even know ,how many chutiyadeshis surrounded and fired at them.

I wish SF is used , Also how good is bangladeshi army and SF ,they only have to fight mostly in jungle and marshland area ,so they must have good experience and ability ,

How capable are they?
Jungle gives them natural cover .
BSF is more than capable for give those cowards BGB a good lesson ... What is missing is the political will from te GOI to send a strong message to Bangladesh ...
 

tarunraju

Sanathan Pepe
Mod
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
7,327
Likes
22,290
Country flag
I think it was a planned hit by *enemy* to see how willing we will be to escalate on two fronts.
Even today we can reach Dhaka just as quickly as we did in 1971. Not sure about that.

Maybe it's just latent jihadi delinquency by the local BGB C.O., and the only way to answer that is by force. As someone else mentioned in this thread, they don't care about numbers. So our action should be big enough that it can't go unnoticed.
 

hit&run

Mod
Joined
May 29, 2009
Messages
9,182
Likes
21,996
Country flag
Best avenge will be to find and hunt the same Soldiers who are involved.
 

afako

Hindufying India
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
1,911
Likes
6,961
Country flag
It could be Islamic mentality of the local commander against Ram Mandir that provoked him to break the RoE and open fire. I don’t rule that out.

But be ready for small battles across the subcontinent by Abdul’s if Islam confronts all out.

Imagine Hindus start an online petition demanding PBUH to be declared as gay. This would piss of Muslims across the subcontinent. One Abdul in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Kashmir, UP, Telangana, Kerala might independently harm Hindu interests at the same time like killing Hindu leaders, attacking temples, trying to target Hindu women, Break idols, taqiyya declaring Hindus as Islamophobe, targeting security forces, some bombs. All just in response to one Hindu attack.

Read about Muslim response to Charlie Hebdo. Terrorist attack that place. Islam uses fear to strike in the heart of the enemy. But they fear massive strike by the enemy as such. They also have leftists sitting to scratch their back. That will be double whammy for us.
 

tarunraju

Sanathan Pepe
Mod
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
7,327
Likes
22,290
Country flag
It could be Islamic mentality of the local commander against Ram Mandir that provoked him to break the RoE and open fire. I don’t rule that out.

But be ready for small battles across the subcontinent by Abdul’s if Islam confronts all out.

Imagine Hindus start an online petition demanding PBUH to be declared as gay. This would piss of Muslims across the subcontinent. One Abdul in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Kashmir, UP, Telangana, Kerala might independently harm Hindu interests at the same time like killing Hindu leaders, attacking temples, trying to target Hindu women, Break idols, taqiyya declaring Hindus as Islamophobe, targeting security forces, some bombs. All just in response to one Hindu attack.

Read about Muslim response to Charlie Hebdo. Terrorist attack that place. Islam uses fear to strike in the heart of the enemy. But they fear massive strike by the enemy as such. They also have leftists sitting to scratch their back. That will be double whammy for us.
Why Telangana? Hindu population in Telangana is well above national average.

upload_2019-10-20_6-33-21.png


Agree with the rest, though.
 

afako

Hindufying India
Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
1,911
Likes
6,961
Country flag
Why Telangana? Hindu population in Telangana is well above national average.

View attachment 39477

Agree with the rest, though.
France has what 5% Muslims? That doesn’t stop many bombings, knifings, Truck or car over running the streets, gun attacks on French.

Telangana still has 12% Muslim population.

In my example, you could put in any place even if one Muslim exists there.
 

tarunraju

Sanathan Pepe
Mod
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Messages
7,327
Likes
22,290
Country flag
France has what 5% Muslims? That doesn’t stop many bombings, knifings, Truck or car over running the streets, gun attacks on French.

Telangana still has 12% Muslim population.

In my example, you could put in any place even if one Muslim exists there.
Every other place you mentioned has a higher % of Muslims than Indian national-average, so I thought you spoke of Telangana in the same light as Kerala.

Many people see the Charminar, the name of the state capital, Owaisis, and misunderstand Telangana that it's "south Pakistan."

Telangana (85.09% H / 12.68% M) is more Hindu than so-called "Devbhumi" (Uttarakhand, 82.97% H / 13.95% M).
 

Jameson Emoni

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2018
Messages
1,474
Likes
4,226
But mukti bahini was at fore front too and actually did a lot of dirty work .
Bangladesh specialises in jungle warfare and guerilla warfare ,they train only for that ,so i dont want to underestimate them as far as small incursions are concerned ,
in full skirmish we will bring big guns and overwhelm them but in small incursion it will be equal equal and advantage defender i.e. bangladesh ,thats why i want SF to do the raid and bsf to do target firing.
SF personnel were embedded with Mukti Bahini. Mukti Bahini was trained and led by SF. It never was all Mukti Bahini operation except for suicide missions.
 

ladder

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2013
Messages
5,564
Likes
4,949
Country flag

Kra

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2019
Messages
210
Likes
377
Every other place you mentioned has a higher % of Muslims than Indian national-average, so I thought you spoke of Telangana in the same light as Kerala.

Many people see the Charminar, the name of the state capital, Owaisis, and misunderstand Telangana that it's "south Pakistan."

Telangana (85.09% H / 12.68% M) is more Hindu than so-called "Devbhumi" (Uttarakhand, 82.97% H / 13.95% M).
There a lot more Muslims in uttarakhand than that
 

Latest Replies

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top