Rakibools Shoot BSF Jawans on their Backs as they're returning from a Flag Meet

What Should Be the Indian Response

  • Diplomatic Option: Get Bangladesh to Apologize and Courtmartial those Involved

    Votes: 27 36.0%
  • Tactical Option: Indiscriminately Kill One BGB personnel, preferably headshot, and injure another

    Votes: 48 64.0%

  • Total voters
    75

Bleh

Laughing member
Senior Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2017
Messages
2,667
Likes
7,294
Country flag
2 days...........................................
 

Flying Dagger

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
742
Likes
1,531
Country flag
We need to train and arm BSF better .

Helis need to be made available to them to take Bangladeshi into task. I don't know what should be the right platform in that environment. But LCH kind of platform with high speed and range if not Apache must be there. 3-4 Apache along with light artillery the old one which army want to send into reserve should be used. They must realise across the border Their Kaal is waiting for them.

Whenever you see "smugglers" or illegal "trying to get in" fire indiscriminately . If they ask let them take the bodies else burn it.

Since they have repeatedly broke the sanctity of flag meet . It should be cancelled indefinitely. Infact best is to ask them after some time to come over and kill them all . This should be repeated and BSF should never be involved in meeting with them.

As far as fishermen are concerned their security should be assured by taking down bangladeshi posts whenever they capture someone. Every Indian life should be equivalent to 100+ bangladeshi . You need to put a price for every life they took .

And this should be our official line too that every Indian's life is worth more than n no. Of bangladeshi .

Second is to go hard on bengali muslims who have made inside India illegally or legally. Both should be targeted. we know the politics but atleast illegals can be taken into task.
 

Kra

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2019
Messages
210
Likes
377
Response should have been then and there . No point in doing anything now. Considering what happened in 2001 i never had any hopes. If our armed forces so much as want to take a piss there would be a whole army of babus to stop them so that their daily routine of chai biscuit is not interrupted, bsf is capf so it's even worse.
And political interference is out of question since our govt is so high on raqibool charas that we are suspending our own troopers who shoot illegal BDs.
 

Flying Dagger

Regular Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
742
Likes
1,531
Country flag
Wtf we are such pussies man , we deserved to be slaves , ek desh bacha hai wo bhi chodo Kafiron.
Pussies ?
we are spending resources to build up their economy so that they can buy some Jf17s and bomb some Indian cities.

We are a classic case of jaichand ourselves.

And people think Hindus hate jaichand .

Nope we adore him our leaders adore him because he is our ideal now and we have been following his work in politics as well in real life.
 

mist_consecutive

Flight Lieutenant, 17th Squadron, "Haram Trolls"
Contributor
Joined
Oct 2, 2018
Messages
354
Likes
1,835
Country flag
We need to train and arm BSF better .

Helis need to be made available to them to take Bangladeshi into task. I don't know what should be the right platform in that environment. But LCH kind of platform with high speed and range if not Apache must be there. 3-4 Apache along with light artillery the old one which army want to send into reserve should be used. They must realise across the border Their Kaal is waiting for them.

Whenever you see "smugglers" or illegal "trying to get in" fire indiscriminately . If they ask let them take the bodies else burn it.

Since they have repeatedly broke the sanctity of flag meet . It should be cancelled indefinitely. Infact best is to ask them after some time to come over and kill them all . This should be repeated and BSF should never be involved in meeting with them.

As far as fishermen are concerned their security should be assured by taking down bangladeshi posts whenever they capture someone. Every Indian life should be equivalent to 100+ bangladeshi . You need to put a price for every life they took .

And this should be our official line too that every Indian's life is worth more than n no. Of bangladeshi .

Second is to go hard on bengali muslims who have made inside India illegally or legally. Both should be targeted. we know the politics but atleast illegals can be taken into task.
BSF Jawan's Killing a 'Misunderstanding', Will Talk to Amit Shah, Says Bangladesh Home Minister

https://www.news18.com/news/india/b...ah-says-bangladesh-home-minister-2351791.html
People on this forum are too trigger happy and think world politics is Age of Empires. Don't we have enough enemies on all sides that we need to make another one?

Yeah, the incident is unfortunate, and I bet heavily that it was indeed a misunderstanding. Even if it was a trigger happy BGB commander, do we need to prove the whole Bangladesh and world that we have the bigger dick? Punish Bangladesh and become belligerent in local people's opinion?

You know, if we take revenge as many members are voicing here, who will have the upper hand? India will be the loser. China and Pakistan will have the upper hand and laughing at the foolishness of India.

Rather, force them to make a formal apology by BGB chief, or maybe their external affairs ministers. Force BGB to court marshall the miscreants and give them a strict sentence equivalent to intentional franticide.
 
Last edited:

Kra

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2019
Messages
210
Likes
377
People on this forum are too trigger happy and think world politics is Age of Empires. Don't we have enough enemies on all sides that we need to make another one?

Yeah, the incident is unfortunate, and I bet heavily that it was indeed a misunderstanding. Even if it was a trigger happy BGB commander, do we need to prove the whole Bangladesh and world that we have the bigger dick? Punish Bangladesh and become belligerent in local people's opinion?

You know, if we take revenge as many members are voicing here, who will have the upper hand? India will be the loser. China and Pakistan will have the upper hand and laughing at the foolishness of India.

Rather, force them to make a formal apology by BGB chief, or maybe their external affairs ministers.
We should have attacked their bgb post at once and then asked them to cool down. That was very doable. Unfortunately thats impossible because our govt will ruin the life of any officer at the position that gives such an order. So no one will stick their neck out. No wonder it takes a bajillion meetings between the nsa, pm, and everybody to decide how to respond to Pakistan if it makes so much as a peep.
 

mist_consecutive

Flight Lieutenant, 17th Squadron, "Haram Trolls"
Contributor
Joined
Oct 2, 2018
Messages
354
Likes
1,835
Country flag
We should have attacked their bgb post at once and then asked them to cool down. That was very doable. Unfortunately thats impossible because our govt will ruin the life of any officer at the position that gives such an order. So no one will stick their neck out. No wonder it takes a bajillion meetings between the nsa, pm, and everybody to decide how to respond to Pakistan if it makes so much as a peep.
It's also worth noting down that the same is valid on the other side. The instigator who opened fire, along with their commander will be court-martialled and may be given a strict sentence to serve. I believe India should also push BGB for the same.
 

Kra

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2019
Messages
210
Likes
377
It's also worth noting down that the same is valid on the other side. The instigator who opened fire, along with their commander will be court-martialled and may be given a strict sentence to serve. I believe India should also push BGB for the same.
Yes we should send a strongly worded letter complaining to madam hasina that bgb troopers were mean to us. Maybe she'll take pity in us and scold them.
 

mist_consecutive

Flight Lieutenant, 17th Squadron, "Haram Trolls"
Contributor
Joined
Oct 2, 2018
Messages
354
Likes
1,835
Country flag
Yes we should send a strongly worded letter complaining to madam hasina that bgb troopers were mean to us. Maybe she'll take pity in us and scold them.
:rofl:
Very funny sir, your sense of sarcasm that is.

Let's go by your style.
  1. After BSF soldiers return from flag meeting with an injured and dead comrade, local commander directly phones the supreme leader @Kra as the next step of action. Supreme leader orders immediate retaliation.

  2. BSF starts shelling and shooting towards BGB posts. BGB retaliates.

  3. Since this is a peace-time operation, both side's forces are matched, and no one enjoys numerical superiority. Moreover, since no one was anticipating any hostility and built any solid bunkers, our, as well as BGB posts, are just makeshift huts and trenches. Both suffer casualties.

  4. Matter de-escalates in 1-2 days.

  5. Bangladesh is now on bitter terms with India, with Bangladeshi armed forces disagreeing with India-friendly govt (Hasina) and plotting a coup.

  6. Pakistan and China pledge support to Bangladesh with more fighters, tanks, and submarines.

  7. Now India is forced to protect the vast swathe of the unmanaged and unfenced border with Bangladesh, directing a significant amount of resources which was previously allotted on Northern and Western border.

  8. We are fearing a joint-attack by Bangladesh and China on chicken's neck.

  9. ??

  10. Profit?
 

ladder

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2013
Messages
5,564
Likes
4,945
Country flag
:rofl:
Very funny sir, your sense of sarcasm that is.

Let's go by your style.
  1. After BSF soldiers return from flag meeting with an injured and dead comrade, local commander directly phones the supreme leader @Kra as the next step of action. Supreme leader orders immediate retaliation.

  2. BSF starts shelling and shooting towards BGB posts. BGB retaliates.

  3. Since this is a peace-time operation, both side's forces are matched, and no one enjoys numerical superiority. Moreover, since no one was anticipating any hostility and built any solid bunkers, our, as well as BGB posts, are just makeshift huts and trenches. Both suffer casualties.

  4. Matter de-escalates in 1-2 days.

  5. Bangladesh is now on bitter terms with India, with Bangladeshi armed forces disagreeing with India-friendly govt (Hasina) and plotting a coup.

  6. Pakistan and China pledge support to Bangladesh with more fighters, tanks, and submarines.

  7. Now India is forced to protect the vast swathe of the unmanaged and unfenced border with Bangladesh, directing a significant amount of resources which was previously allotted on Northern and Western border.

  8. We are fearing a joint-attack by Bangladesh and China on chicken's neck.

  9. ??

  10. Profit?
Yes, BGB and Bangladesh Army are waiting for BSF to pound them before they mount a coup.

Chinese, Pakistani and fill in the blanks forces are waiting for the coup to install their puppet govt.

Yes, let BGB now walk down the dusty Bengal path and kill as many BSF they want because replying in kind my cause a coup in Bangladesh.
 
Last edited:

nongaddarliberal

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2016
Messages
1,865
Likes
5,589
Country flag
:rofl:
Very funny sir, your sense of sarcasm that is.

Let's go by your style.
  1. After BSF soldiers return from flag meeting with an injured and dead comrade, local commander directly phones the supreme leader @Kra as the next step of action. Supreme leader orders immediate retaliation.

  2. BSF starts shelling and shooting towards BGB posts. BGB retaliates.

  3. Since this is a peace-time operation, both side's forces are matched, and no one enjoys numerical superiority. Moreover, since no one was anticipating any hostility and built any solid bunkers, our, as well as BGB posts, are just makeshift huts and trenches. Both suffer casualties.

  4. Matter de-escalates in 1-2 days.

  5. Bangladesh is now on bitter terms with India, with Bangladeshi armed forces disagreeing with India-friendly govt (Hasina) and plotting a coup.

  6. Pakistan and China pledge support to Bangladesh with more fighters, tanks, and submarines.

  7. Now India is forced to protect the vast swathe of the unmanaged and unfenced border with Bangladesh, directing a significant amount of resources which was previously allotted on Northern and Western border.

  8. We are fearing a joint-attack by Bangladesh and China on chicken's neck.

  9. ??

  10. Profit?
Exactly. That's why a precise and proportionate operation will be coordinated with the Hasina government. We exert far more control on her than people think. 2-3 east porki troops will be killed. Matter will be resolved.
 

vishnugupt

Regular Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2013
Messages
323
Likes
608
Country flag
:rofl:
Very funny sir, your sense of sarcasm that is.

Let's go by your style.
  1. After BSF soldiers return from flag meeting with an injured and dead comrade, local commander directly phones the supreme leader @Kra as the next step of action. Supreme leader orders immediate retaliation.

  2. BSF starts shelling and shooting towards BGB posts. BGB retaliates.

  3. Since this is a peace-time operation, both side's forces are matched, and no one enjoys numerical superiority. Moreover, since no one was anticipating any hostility and built any solid bunkers, our, as well as BGB posts, are just makeshift huts and trenches. Both suffer casualties.

  4. Matter de-escalates in 1-2 days.

  5. Bangladesh is now on bitter terms with India, with Bangladeshi armed forces disagreeing with India-friendly govt (Hasina) and plotting a coup.

  6. Pakistan and China pledge support to Bangladesh with more fighters, tanks, and submarines.

  7. Now India is forced to protect the vast swathe of the unmanaged and unfenced border with Bangladesh, directing a significant amount of resources which was previously allotted on Northern and Western border.

  8. We are fearing a joint-attack by Bangladesh and China on chicken's neck.

  9. ??

  10. Profit?
These Dhimmi"s way of thinking has been costing Hindus dearly for centuries ....... and there are plenty like him. let me suggest you what we can do..
9. we will flatten Bangladesh from the top and make chicken neck 100km wider than today
10. Profit - this will send starke messages to our all neighbour countries for centuries to come and nobody will dare to shoot our solder from the back. Furthermore, illegal piglets will think a thousand times before crossing the border
 

mist_consecutive

Flight Lieutenant, 17th Squadron, "Haram Trolls"
Contributor
Joined
Oct 2, 2018
Messages
354
Likes
1,835
Country flag
Yes, BGB and Bangladesh Army are waiting for BSF to pound them before they mount a coup.

Chinese, Pakistani and fill in the blanks forces are waiting for the coup to install their puppet govt.

Yes, let BGB now walk down the dusty Bengal path and kill as many BSF they want because replying in kind my cause a coup in Bangladesh.
The Islamic population of Bangladesh does not hold positive views towards India, even though we saved their mothers from rape and pillage by Pakistani forces. Indian-friendly govt installed in Bangladesh (yeah, by RAW) is not very popular. Let's give the local public a good reason to see us as enemies, because why not, right?

Yes, Chinese and Pakistanis are waiting exactly for a strong anti-Indian mentality to install their own puppet government.

Yes, let BGB now walk down the dusty Bengal path and kill as many BSF they want because replying in kind my cause a coup in Bangladesh
Is BGB increasingly hostile towards us? Are attacks and violations of BSF increasing? No? Isn't it a lone incident in the last decade? If yes, then I call it an unfortunate incident, and your reaction to it immature.
 

mist_consecutive

Flight Lieutenant, 17th Squadron, "Haram Trolls"
Contributor
Joined
Oct 2, 2018
Messages
354
Likes
1,835
Country flag
These Dhimmi"s way of thinking has been costing Hindus dearly for centuries ....... and there are plenty like him. let me suggest you what we can do..
9. we will flatten Bangladesh from the top and make chicken neck 100km wider than today
10. Profit - this will send starke messages to our all neighbour countries for centuries to come and nobody will dare to shoot our solder from the back. Furthermore, illegal piglets will think a thousand times before crossing the border
Hey, I understand your emotions. Irking for revenge when you have a dagger stabbed in your back is completely normal. But acting without thinking about consequences is immaturity, which our dear western neighbour suffer dearly.

Ask yourself -
  • Is it worth it to start a war for an unfortunate incident? (Yeah, even if it was intentional, BGB do not support it, it was the mischief of the local commander).
  • Is it worth it to make another Islamic trigger-happy enemy, having a large number of uneducated and extremist population and sharing a large unmonitored border with us?
To your suggestion -
we will flatten Bangladesh from the top and make chicken neck 100km wider than today
We will be seen as invaders and bullies. Already Kashmir situation hot, this is not a good move.

Profit - this will send starke messages to our all neighbour countries for centuries to come and nobody will dare to shoot our solder from the back. Furthermore, illegal piglets will think a thousand times before crossing the border
Pakistan will keep on being, well, Pakistan. China won't care. However, our other smaller neighbors, Nepal, Bhutan, Myanmar and Sri Lanka will start to fear India, along with a latent fear that they, too will be annexed next time, making them cozying up (more) with China (Profit !) and avoiding India.

“The greatest victory is that which requires no battle.”
― Sun Tzu, The Art of War
 

Kra

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2019
Messages
210
Likes
377
:rofl:
Very funny sir, your sense of sarcasm that is.

Let's go by your style.
  1. After BSF soldiers return from flag meeting with an injured and dead comrade, local commander directly phones the supreme leader @Kra as the next step of action. Supreme leader orders immediate retaliation.

  2. BSF starts shelling and shooting towards BGB posts. BGB retaliates.

  3. Since this is a peace-time operation, both side's forces are matched, and no one enjoys numerical superiority. Moreover, since no one was anticipating any hostility and built any solid bunkers, our, as well as BGB posts, are just makeshift huts and trenches. Both suffer casualties.

  4. Matter de-escalates in 1-2 days.

  5. Bangladesh is now on bitter terms with India, with Bangladeshi armed forces disagreeing with India-friendly govt (Hasina) and plotting a coup.

  6. Pakistan and China pledge support to Bangladesh with more fighters, tanks, and submarines.

  7. Now India is forced to protect the vast swathe of the unmanaged and unfenced border with Bangladesh, directing a significant amount of resources which was previously allotted on Northern and Western border.

  8. We are fearing a joint-attack by Bangladesh and China on chicken's neck.

  9. ??

  10. Profit?
What happened was
We got shot at with 1 injured, what do?
Wait let me ask my superior, don't wanna get fired
His superior: let me ask mine. What if i got suspended?
Home minister: arre dekhte h what if hasina madam jee threw a fit and ordered invasion of india with her bff xi?
Meanwhile 2 days have passed and window of opportunity gone.
Wouldn't be first time, wouldn't be the last.

We can't strike now. All is left is kadi ninda.
 

ladder

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2013
Messages
5,564
Likes
4,945
Country flag
The Islamic population of Bangladesh does not hold positive views towards India, even though we saved their mothers from rape and pillage by Pakistani forces. Indian-friendly govt installed in Bangladesh (yeah, by RAW) is not very popular. Let's give the local public a good reason to see us as enemies, because why not, right?

Yes, Chinese and Pakistanis are waiting exactly for a strong anti-Indian mentality to install their own puppet government.



Is BGB increasingly hostile towards us? Are attacks and violations of BSF increasing? No? Isn't it a lone incident in the last decade? If yes, then I call it an unfortunate incident, and your reaction to it immature.
From 1947 till 1971 and many years after that East Pakistan/ Bangladesh wasn't exactly friendly. And Chicken's neck wasn't wider either.

So doomsday prediction of cuttings off Chicken's neck just shows that you have studied India's security scenarios in all maturity .
Since I can't match your level maturity in predicting security scenarios, let's end the debate here. Have your views, let me have mine. Thanks.
 

Global Defence

New threads

Articles

Top