Project-75I class SSK Submarines

[BON PLAN]

MOD cleared 6 project 75i submarine

It's only a RFP so far. It will takes time, specially with the famous indian bureaucraty.
Don't expect a first operationnal sub before 7 or 8 years.

 

[BON PLAN]

Cost of shortfin barracuda class sub for austrailia including TOT, SUBMARINE MANUFACTURING INFRA is 3 billion dollar per submarine

since we have french sub infra so cost will be 2-2.2 billion dollar per submarine

displacement of shortfin barracuda 4500 tons submerged

There is no sub manufacturer in Australia => All is to be built, from dock to school. Not the Indian situation.
The man hour cost is not the same in India and Australia.

So it's not fair to use the Australian bid to elaborate an Indian bid.

 

[bhramos]

Lessons from Project 75

The Defence Ministry clears six P-75I submarines for the Indian Navy. What lessons it must learn from the P-75 Scorpene submarine project

www.indiatoday.in

 

[SavageKing456]

 

[Lonewolf]

Point lies in negligence , our shipyard wrre just a meme , just some repair and all ,never focussed on rnd , and you can't make a submarine out of box when you don't have any sort of integration between design agency and a shipyard , all managed by bureaucrat fuckers .

Heck if any of you have time ,go and search all indian shipyard , on satellite image of google maps ,you will realize that it's poor than a fucking dumpyard , ships are being bult in open ,no cover , and all those sheds look like some slum .


Fucking pathetic , we may have good research at some extent but for shipbuilding is just dump , no order for civilian market with good quality tankers and all ,some one or two in whole shipyard history is just embarrassment .

 

[Lonewolf]

In shipbuilding we have a long way to go , we should better start now ,this p 75 i Should be our chance to learn our experience and modernize those shipyard

 

[SavageKing456]

In shipbuilding we have a long way to go , we should better start now ,this p 75 i Should be our chance to learn our experience and modernize those shipyard

Better to give 3 subs to L&T and 3 to MDL to cut down the delivery time.
We cannot further waste time and we have project alpha to deliver too.
And other programs.

 

[Lonewolf]

Better to give 3 subs to L&T and 3 to MDL to cut down the delivery time.
We cannot further waste time and we have project alpha to deliver too.
And other programs.

Lnt Should be given project alpha ,

 

[BON PLAN]

View attachment 94182

Nothing strange : the political support in S Korea was strong and regular, with a continuous flow of money.
In India it's like a turn signal : one time OK, one time non OK.... You often loose the skill acquired by foreign ToT. S Korea cultivate this ToT, with patience.

Always the same problem.

 

[BON PLAN]

Better to give 3 subs to L&T and 3 to MDL to cut down the delivery time.
We cannot further waste time and we have project alpha to deliver too.
And other programs.

The unit cost will be far higher, because no serial effect, and the training of 2 teams instead of one.
Add to that a potential dupplication of the machine tools...
A bad solution. I hope India will not make that kind of error.

 

[Haldilal]

Lnt Should be given project alpha ,

Ya'll Nibbiars Project 75 A is given to the Navy Shipbuilding Centre.

 

[Haldilal]

There is no sub manufacturer in Australia => All is to be built, from dock to school. Not the Indian situation.
The man hour cost is not the same in India and Australia.

So it's not fair to use the Australian bid to elaborate an Indian bid.

Ya'll Nibbiars even for 1.5 to 1.8 Billion Dollar's it's costly considering a Conventional propulsion. Rather than that The more order for the Project 75 A Class from the L & T.

 

[Starlight]

I feel another follow-on Scorpene enhanced is better.

 

[FactsPlease]

View attachment 93733

Lessons from Project 75

The Defence Ministry clears six P-75I submarines for the Indian Navy. What lessons it must learn from the P-75 Scorpene submarine project

www.indiatoday.in

Exactly the reminder we need here, now, at this critical point.
Other than governm't change, what else can we guarantee that this tragedy of P75 won't happen again.

 

[Starlight]

Exactly the reminder we need here, now, at this critical point.
Other than governm't change, what else can we guarantee that this tragedy of P75 won't happen again.

The submarines will be selected in proper time, don't worry.

 

[BON PLAN]

I feel another follow-on Scorpene enhanced is better.

That means no VLS, because diameter of the hull is to low.
If not, it's always possible to fit SCALP Naval (or Nirhbay ?) for a fire with torpedoes tubes. And of course AIP.

 

[Jimih]

 

[fire starter]

Hope it's true.

 

[SavageKing456]

Hope it's true.

Already told that this should be taken.
Good if it happens imo

 

[BON PLAN]

A good TKMS look